from the submission; 1- "The errors the authors corrected “do not alter the conclusions of the Article,” they wrote in the notice." 2- "the Blood paper contai

from the submission; 1- "The errors the authors corrected “do not alter the conclusions of the Article,” they wrote in the notice." 2- "the Blood paper contained falsified images, but Verfaillie was not responsible for the manipulations. Blood retracted the article in 2009 at the request of the authors. " 3- "The university found “no breach of research integrity in the publications investigated.” " 4- "The notice mentions two image duplications Bik wrote about on PubPeer. Because the authors could not retrieve the original images, it states: the Editors no longer have confidence that the conclusion that multipotent adult progenitor cells (MAPCs) engraft in the bone marrow is supported. Given the concerns above the Editors no longer have confidence in the reliability of the data reported in this article."