3 ms·
Not the poster, but the issue is one of scale. Any visualization that showed a full orbit in a visual field that a human can see at once, necessarily has to ex
by lazide 2y ago
Not the poster, but the issue is one of scale.
Any visualization that showed a full orbit in a visual field that a human can see at once, necessarily has to exaggerate the size of the satellite or it would be completely impossible to see the satellite at that same scale. By millions or even billions of times.
A GPS satellite in medium orbit has an orbital diameter of around 45, 000 km but is only a little over 5 meters in size. A ratio of roughly 10,000,000 to 1.
If you had a visualization a meter wide of its orbit, the satellite to scale would be less than a micron in size. Completely invisible.
The same problem comes up with those ‘topology of the earth’ maps that try to show how things like depth of the oceans, height of the Himalayas, etc. on a globe.
They have to dramatically exaggerate the actual altitude differences for them to be perceptible. [https://www.quora.com/If-Mount-Everest-was-on-a-globe-and-was-made-vertically-proportional-to-the-globe-avg-size-how-tall-would-it-be https://www.quora.com/If-Mount-Everest-was-on-a-globe-and-wa...]
The actual to scale difference in height of the Himalayan mountains vs sea level on a regular sized globe would be less than .001 inches. Completely imperceptible without precision measuring devices. Even producing such a globe accurately would be a feat of precision manufacturing.
Even on a giant (1 meter) globe, we’re talking less than 1mm.
Literally smoother than a billiard ball.
But they are the highest mountains in the world, and absolutely breaktaking if near them.
And space is even bigger, and satellites even smaller.
- WillAdams 2y agoAn accurate steel replica of earth the size of a ball-bearing would be the most precise ball bearing ever. Great book on this: https://goodreads.com/book/show/35068671-the-perfectionists https://goodreads.com/book/show/35068671-the-perfectionists
- coolspot 2y agoDoubt it. Earth is not even a sphere.
- sandworm101 2y agoI've heard this a couple times and never believed it. Earth is perceptibly not round. Scott Manley did a quick video showing that in some satellite images the difference equates to more than a couple pixels. Some quick googling shows the earth being about 0.3% not-round, which would match a 1000-pixel image being not-round by a few pixels. But a 0.3% deviation is exponentially greater than is allowed by the standards for ball bearings. >> the Earth deviates from spherical by only a third of a percent https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Figure_of_the_Earth https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Figure_of_the_Earth >> For instance, the Anti-Friction Bearing Manufacturers Association (AFBMA) has a set of grades for bearing balls. A grade three ball has to be spherical within 3 millionths of an inch and the diameter must be accurate within 30 millionths of an inch. This means that for a grade three quarter-inch ball, the diameter would have to be between 0.24997 and 0.25003 of an inch and the smallest diameter measured on the ball has to be within 3 millionths of the largest diameter. https://science.howstuffworks.com/transport/engines-equipment/question513.htm https://science.howstuffworks.com/transport/engines-equipmen...
- lazide 2y agoTo do the last extra bit of math - that seems like the ball bearings would then be within .01%? Or am I missing a zero?
- QuercusMax 2y agoSmoothness vs perfect roundness are two different things. The earth is very smooth, even if it's not perfectly round.
- aetherson 2y agoI think you're talking about different things. It's true, the Earth is substantially non-spherical. But things like mountains are tiny irregularities on a smooth (not-perfectly-spherical) surface.
- samatman 2y agoA better way to talk about this is something like: given a globe of Earth, say a 50cm diameter one, finished with plate Bristol paper, the texture of the surface would not be as smooth as a perfect model of Earth at that scale.