3 ms·
Indeed, and you correctly used a plural thus reinforcing the notion that methods with an undue focus on singular right answers a particular teacher is thinking
by defrost 2y ago
Indeed, and you correctly used a plural thus reinforcing the notion that methods with an undue focus on singular right answers a particular teacher is thinking of aren't all that great.
- WalterBright 2y agoThat's not what I meant, but I'll go with it for the moment. You can design and build a functioning automobile without math. You cannot design a functioning airplane without math. You cannot design a functioning spacecraft without a very, very strong math background. With aircraft parts, you can make mistakes up to a point, but those mistakes will make the airplane cost more, such as being overweight. There is always an optimum answer, and I took it as a point of pride to get things exactly right. I knew some engineers who couldn't do arithmetic very well. The results were parts that were overweight and often would not even fit together, causing expensive redesign and rework. Engineering management knew who they were, and assigned them tasks where their deficient work was not going to cause much trouble. But in no case was 2+2 not equal to 4.
- defrost 2y ago> You cannot design a functioning airplane without math. Did the Wright brothers use a lot of math in their wind tunnel experiments or was it more empirical .. given that "correct" math for flight dynamics took a while longer to come about. > With aircraft parts, there are a lot of "right* answers; three pairs of wings, two pairs, a single pair, a single wing, push from the back, pull from the front, control surfaces here or forward canards there. > There is always an optimum answer There are multiple optimums in the field of avionics.
- WalterBright 2y ago> Did the Wright brothers use a lot of math in their wind tunnel experiments Yes, they did. They did a lot of math in their design (their notebooks survive). That's why they were successful and their contemporaries all failed. They developed the first mathematical theory of propellers, for example, and used it to create a propeller that was twice as efficient as that of other experimenters. See "The Wright Brothers as Engineers, An Appraisal" by Quentin Wand > there are a lot of "right* answers None of them flew if they got thrust/lift/drag/weight/cg/strength/stability wrong answers. Lots of people died as the result of wrong answers.
- Symbiote 2y agoArguing over the metaphor isn't useful. This is school-level mathematics. The 'wrong' answer isn't a different optimization of cost, strength, weight and endurance, which Boeing might consider. It's an arithmetic or procedural error giving an incorrect result. There's great value in understanding the method, discussing ways to make errors and so on — but I think it's nonsense to suggest this has anything to do with race.