5 ms·
Actually we moderate less, not more, when YC or a YC startup is the story. This is the #1 rule of HN moderation and has been since pg first explained it to me o
by dang 2y ago
Actually we moderate less, not more, when YC or a YC startup is the story. This is the #1 rule of HN moderation and has been since pg first explained it to me on the morning he started showing me how to moderate HN. If anyone wants to read about this, there are ten years' worth of past explanations here: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&query=by%3Adang%20moderate%20%22less%2C%20not%20more%22&sort=byDate&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&qu....
It looks like a mod downweighted this story but also saved it, along with your comment, for me to review. Since the rule is the rule, I'm reducing the downweight now. (Edit: I've since checked with the mod and indeed their intention was to follow the same rule - see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40720026 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40720026.)
This looks like a flimsy story from a couple of months ago about something from many years ago. It's hard to tell if there's any there-there but, given how this sort of story usually works, the odds seem low*. It's obviously getting attention not because of intellectual curiosity (the right reason on HN) but because of celebrity outrage (a popular human pastime but not the right reason on HN). It's also repetitive of many other outrage threads we've had in recent months—an additional reason to downweight it (beyond the outrage aspect). We never let articles like this stay on HN's frontpage normally—if we did, HN would consist of little else.
Still, I'm happy to reduce the downweight on this because that rule is key to the trust we have with the bulk of the community. I think most HN readers know that we moderate shallow outrage stories off the front page, and why; and I think most can appreciate that we bend that rule the other way for the sake of the above principle, even if they don't like it.
It doesn't stop people from making up false claims (edit: I mean about HN moderation, like the parent comment), but it does let us answer them in good conscience, and the rest is just standard internet dynamics (sinister speculation, etc.)
* Note the photo that describes Geoff as YC's "new president". That hasn't been the case for 5 years, and he stopped being president 18 months ago.
- eduction 2y ago> It's hard to tell if there's any there-there but, given how this sort of story usually works, the odds seem low. Not at all. The source links the relevant SEC filing. https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1849056/000110465921035909/tm218987-1_s1.htm https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1849056/000110465921... On page 111 the false claim is plainly visible: “ Prior to joining OpenAI, Mr. Altman served as President of Y Combinator from February 2014 until March 2019. Mr. Altman currently serves as the Chairman of the board of directors of Y Combinator.” There is also a screenshot in the Business Times story showing the false claim was visible on the AltC website in April. You can go to the AltC site and confirm that Sam is CEO. The story also includes comment from YC confirming that Sam was never chairman after it was announced he would be. Dang, what is the basis for your comments on this story? The San Francisco Business Times has been a reliable and fairly pro business local source for years. Hardly tabloid journalism. Can you specify and explain one of the “false claims” you allege?
- tensility 2y agoCrisis of trust in Altman reflects back on Y Combinator. They have significant financial motivation to downplay his behavior regardless of any moderators claims.
- dang 2y agoOh, I meant false claims about HN moderation, like the GP comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40711123 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40711123 ("The mods suppress anything that makes YC or anything they invest in look bad"). That wasn't just completely made up, it's the exact opposite of the truth. My comment originally included that explicitly, but I was trying to edit it down a bit and thought this would be clear from the context. Since it wasn't, I've added an edit there now.
- eduction 2y agoYou called the story “flimsy.” How so?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- mlyle 2y ago> it's the exact opposite of the truth. One can hardly call it the exact opposite of the truth if the feared downweighting of this post actually happened. It's commendable that it was corrected and that you are attempting to be transparent. But, it sure creates the appearance of a self-protective attempt to moderate.
- dang 2y agoYes, I take your point and would have preferred the original downweight to be less for that reason. (Edit: I checked with the mod and originally it was - see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40720026 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40720026. It looks like user flags made the difference.) Different mods inevitably make different calls sometimes, though. That doesn't change the fundamental practice, which has been stable for a long time (long before I took over HN long ago). One thing I often point out in these situations is that "moderate less" (which is what the rule calls for) is not the same thing as "not moderating at all". Most probably the mod in this case was thinking along the lines of "I'm still moderating less in this case than we normally would, but I'll check with dang just in case".
- twoodfin 2y agoI dunno if it’s outrage-worthy, but the silent evolution of the YC blog post on Sam’s departure was weird, and nobody involved—particularly pg in his recent comments meant to be definitive—has managed to explain why that went down the way it did. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38384090 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38384090
- cynicalkane 2y agoIt's worth noting that `dang` is one of the people who noted the evolution happening.
- zamadatix 2y agoHey Dang, I appreciate the transparency and general policy in such situations. As well as undowning the story Do you think there will ever be in band signaling of when (or perhaps even why) a post was artificially depressed by moderation? Particularly aimed at cases where people are already using tools like https://news.social-protocols.org/stats?id=40710417 https://news.social-protocols.org/stats?id=40710417 on posts like this where more people have already seen the story drop off and confirmation that it was via moderation than will probably ever see this comment in its later revival explaining how or why. Something like a "downed" with hover alt text next to the flag tag even. Apart from being immediately clearer to everyone without waiting for a comment/email that helps solidify against "and then 5 hours later they back tracked it slightly but not all the way with some other excuse why after being called out" type thinking/arguments. I mean you'll never get rid of that completely but it's a lot more powerful that the message existed there at T=30 minutes than T=5 hours. Would typically email but this seemed like something good for an open message :).
- CobrastanJorji 2y agoYeah, as much as the transparency is very much appreciated here, "yes, a mod totally did try to subtly bury this story exactly as you predicted and despite our official mod policies" sounds pretty bad, even if you undid it. Some visible "[Moderator Downvoting]" warning would help earn trust that mods are not in fact doing this to YC-related stories.
- dang 2y agoI checked with the mod and they weren't trying to bury the story but rather to downweight it less than we normally would, in keeping with the #1 rule I described upthread (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40712900 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40712900). The intention was to downweight it enough that it wouldn't be near the top of the front page but not so much that it would leave the front page. That's the same thing I would have done, btw. It looks like what happened was that more user flags came in and that, together with the moderation downweight, moved the story off the front page. Eventually we noticed this and restored it to the lower part of the front page, which is the standard practice for stories of this kind, which we'd never allow to be on HN's front page if they were about anybody else. (Though, as someone pointed out to me, this story wasn't negative about YC.)
- CRConrad 2y ago> This looks like a flimsy story from a couple of months ago about something from many years ago. "Here's me obediently following the rule (Oh, the world is so full of silly rules!), but let me editorialise a bit on why any story about how Sam Altman isn't the greatest thing since sliced bread should be disregarded..." And you don't see how that undermines any "trust we have with the bulk of the community"?
- dang 2y agoI don't, because it doesn't. If the bulk of the community distrusted us, that would be by far the dominant issue on HN. That's how internet dynamics work. The reason I post such long explanations when a case like this comes up is not because I think it will satisfy the disgruntled, chronically distrustful fraction of users (though that would be nice!) but because I know that explaining everything that happened, and why, is enough to reassure the bulk of the community. (I wrote a bit more about this here if anyone cares: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40720410 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40720410)
- CRConrad 2y ago> I don't, because it doesn't. It rather obviously does, AFAICS -- would we be having this discussion if it didn't? ;-) > The reason I post such long The issue for me certainly isn't the length, but the tone (or "whiff" :-) of your comments. > explanations when a case like this comes up is not because I think it will satisfy the disgruntled, chronically distrustful fraction of users (though that would be nice!) Hope I don't count among those. I've been a bit vocally critical recently, but that's just (at least intended as) pointing out where you slip up in your stated goals and policies, which on the whole I'm fairly certain you (all) are doing a pretty good job at. > but because I know that explaining everything that happened, and why, is enough to reassure the bulk of the community. OK, so I'm apparently not in that bulk. Hope there's some "moderately sceptical" group between that bulk and your "disgruntled, chronically distrustful fraction" above for me to be counted in.
- dang 2y ago