4 ms·
While I applaud anyone who gives up eating lots of animal protein (I believe it is bad for their health, and I know it is bad for our environment by using about
by mark_l_watson 14y ago
While I applaud anyone who gives up eating lots of animal protein (I believe it is bad for their health, and I know it is bad for our environment by using about 10x more water and energy for production), there is this:
why not just eat regular vegetarian foods? Why fake meat?
We eat vegetarian with little bits of seafood (Pescatarians), BTW.
- famousactress 14y agoI've often wondered (and been asked) this. I haven't eaten meat for about twenty years now. My wife and I purchase and eat plenty of fake-meat products. It's frankly, simple. Easy to prepare, easy to eat. Fairly high in calories and protein for effort-expended compared to many alternatives. The other interesting question was posed by another commenter who asked why fake-meat in terms of flavors, instead of finding their own identity. The interesting thing is that I don't think most of these things have much flavor either way. Does chicken have much flavor? The veggie-chicken doesn't. It's more of a high-protein, high-calorie carrier of other flavors. Dip it in siracha, fry it and make orange 'chicken'. All in all it doesn't contribute much flavor to the meal, just substance. All of that said, I think of it as junk food (not compared to meat, but compared to other vegetable based meals). I'd much rather get better about putting together more balanced dishes.
- UnFleshedOne 14y agoThe tasty parts of chicken have a lot of flavor, you can pretty much boil and eat drumsticks (in skin) with no seasoning whatsoever. It is white meat that is tasteless and needs a lot of postprocessing. (or mayo, mayo makes everything taste good...)
- famousactress 14y agoThat makes sense. I think it's the white meat that's imitated.
- _pius 14y agoWhy not just eat regular vegetarian foods? Why fake meat? Many people love the taste of meat, plain and simple. If I'm craving a medium rare NY Strip steak, neither a Portobello mushroom nor Ahi tuna filet will quite satiate that desire, no matter how good they taste. A fake meat that successfully replicates the flavor profile and mouthfeel of meat while providing the ethical and health benefits of vegetables would be a game-changer.
- ben1040 14y agoYeah. I'm trying to cut meat out for health reasons but I have 30 years' meat-eating inertia behind me. And I like the taste/texture of meat. I will happily buy something that gets me 80-85% of the way there without the health hit or energy expenditures related to real meat. I generally do not eat red meat anyway, so that loosens the constraints a bit - approximating chicken seems like it would be far, far easier to pull off than a rare steak. Also, it's different on the coasts, but here in the Midwest finding vegetarian meals out is a trial sometimes. A lot of places' "vegetarian" option is pasta with a cream sauce, or something with a ton of cheese. If they can sell this to restaurants to sub in for a chicken breast or the like, that would make it easier to skip meat when eating out.
- scott_s 14y agoI was a strict vegetarian for 12 years. Now, I eat seafood pretty regularly. I'm also an active person, which includes a lot of strength training. "Regular" vegetarian foods don't have enough protein. So veggie burgers are a staple of my diet. (Morning Star Farms brand Grillers Prime are the highest calorie, highest protein, best taste burgers I've found.) Also, I gave up meat for ethical reasons - I don't value those ethical reasons as much as I used to, hence the seafood. But I always have liked and missed meat. Even now, although I won't eat one, a cheeseburger would be great.
- mturmon 14y agoThere's kind of a sliding scale in meatiness from ordinary tofu to smart dogs to "soysages" (soy sausage links) to the product being developed in the article. They all have a place. There are some dishes that benefit from that texture.
- cpeterso 14y agoVegetarians don't need to eat less meat; meat eaters need to less meat. Fake meat tries to accommodate meat eaters taste preferences.