3 ms·
IPCC: Renewables now 10 times more efficient than nuclear at CO2 mitigation
- fuzzfactor 2y agoThis is cost efficiency and it seems pretty realistic currently to me. Cost is a major factor and when the petroleum crisis was triggered in the 1970's the economic devastation was front & center without nearly as much consideration for climate. Regardless, the urgency was greater and I thought they had equations that converged on this approximate outcome at about this point into the wondrous, unknowable, far-future-if-it-was-going-to-get-here 21st century. Without much attention to the climate, there might have been more awareness of the environment in a more locally-focused way though. Before long they had bumper stickers that said "No Nukes". Now I really do like the data presentation with the relative bar graph on a linear scale starting at zero on the left. Realistic efficiency improvements are shown but conservation is not on the chart. Under ideal conditions theoretically it would be "so cool" if total usage were to be cut in half, and the right-hand half of each bar would simply be lopped off with no further worry about the highest-cost options for each mitigation. But even if the lowest-cost half was lopped off instead, the scope of needed mitigation is so dramatically lower that still nothing else even comes close. I guess you would have to say that conservation is "off the chart" in it's effectiveness.
- credit_guy 2y agoThat’s great news. It means nuclear needs to get only 10 times cheaper to be as cost effective as renewables.
- rekabis 2y agoRenewals cannot produce at night, or when the wind isn’t blowing, or under various other conditions. Even a good hailstorm can take out multi-million-dollar solar installations. Nuclear is absolutely essential in providing a stopgap power source that can quickly ramp up or down as needed, yet which does not contribute to climate change. Add in non-breeder reactors that produce much less waste, Candu reactors which are pretty much meltdown-proof, and Thorium reactors that can take spent fuel from “traditional” reactors and reduce it down to almost negligible levels of radioactivity, and we will have the backup systems in place to go truly whole-hog in on renewables. We need a strong and vigorous network of recent-tech nuclear reactors in order to minimize or even eliminate our dependence on fossil fuels.
- sanbor 2y agoThere is wind during the night. Also, you can store the energy lifting heavy things[1] when there is generation and then use that energy later. And you don’t have to deal with nuclear waste, mining plutonium, or nuclear risks (operational issues, attacks, natural disasters, etc). [1] https://www.livescience.com/renewable-energy-storage https://www.livescience.com/renewable-energy-storage
- rekabis 2y ago> There is wind during the night. The wind is also highly variable. > Also, you can store the energy lifting heavy things 60% of North America has no significant vertical changes in terrain to do this on.
- yongjik 2y agoAm I dense, or is it actually showing how much total global CO2 mitigation we can expect from each sector? I.e., it shows we expect countries to build much more renewables than nuclear until 2030, which may be a good choice for them, but that doesn't mean renewables are 10x more efficient. (If Tesla Model X sells 10x as many as Hyundai Ioniq 6, that doesn't mean Model X is 10x as efficient.)
- marcusverus 2y agoRenewables evangelists are among the least trustworthy of all partisans. How is it possible that solar and wind are "10X more efficient at CO2 mitigation" when their low reliability drives us to regularly fire up natural gas plants to shore up their sagging production? With every cold snap, on every cloudy day, solar and wind create CO2 by relying on dirty backup. Nuclear does not. There is no way that you can get to this "10X" figure without cynically ignoring this reality.