3 ms·
No, but someone else can use a "reliable source" (whatever that means) or an authoritative primary source to add that information. Personally, I want a resourc
by CamperBob2 2y ago
No, but someone else can use a "reliable source" (whatever that means) or an authoritative primary source to add that information.
Personally, I want a resource that values primary sources, not one that censors them. The world isn't short on hard drive space (and deletionism didn't make sense back when it was, either.)
I would prefer that an article about XYZ Co. is edited by the former CEO of XYZ Co., rather than by someone who knows nothing about XYZ Co., but whose opinion regarding "reliable sources" is informed by their biases regarding the "social structure of capitalism."
- dessimus 2y ago> I would prefer that an article about XYZ Co. is edited by the former CEO of XYZ Co. Even a former CEO would keep secrets. The next corporation's board is not going to hire a CEO that will knowingly be frank on Wikipedia about a former company.
- CamperBob2 2y agoNote that he didn't say anything about the information the CEO tried to add/remove/edit, just that the edit was "historical" in nature and epistemically unacceptable based on its source. It might not have involved a secret plot to dilute the company's baby formula with methanol, it might have been as innocent (and as objective) as their date of formation or ownership structure. We simply don't know. There's a lot we don't know because somebody like this didn't approve of where the information came from. Somewhere a homeowner's association is missing a lawn committee chair.