3 ms·
Big shiny square metal block doesn’t look so bad to me, but big shiny heavy square metal block does. Perhaps big it is the switch back and forth… big and heavy
by bee_rider 2y ago
Big shiny square metal block doesn’t look so bad to me, but big shiny heavy square metal block does. Perhaps big it is the switch back and forth… big and heavy are fuzzily size-like characteristics while shiny is not…
Is a big shiny square metal block the same thing as a big square shiny metal block? I’m not sure. I think the former is a big square metal block which happens to also be shiny, while the latter is a big square block made of a shiny type of metal.
Does that make any sense at all?
- mtndew4brkfst 2y agoI love the examples in your second paragraph - that helps make the point that they're not entirely commutative. Still, I couldn't write a nice generalizable rule on why I do agree with your breakdown of these examples.
- bee_rider 2y agoIt is funny that shininess is a characteristic that can be attributed to the block, or the metal that makes up the block, despite the block being made of the metal!
- alwa 2y agoLinguists apparently have characterized this phenomenon and call it the “Royal Order of Adjectives” [0]: 1. Quantity or number (e.g., “two”) 2. Quality or opinion (e.g., “lovely”) 3. Size (e.g., “big”) 4. Age (e.g., “old”) 5. Shape (e.g., “round”) 6. Color (e.g., “red”) 7. Origin (e.g., “French”) 8. Material (e.g., “wooden”) 9. Purpose (e.g., “sleeping” in “sleeping bag”) [0] https://www.grammarly.com/blog/adjective-order/ https://www.grammarly.com/blog/adjective-order/
- MereInterest 2y agoThe exceptions to this are also interesting to see. For example, “stainless-steel hex nut” or “designer little black dress” both violate the standard ordering, which would predict “hex stainless-steel nut” and “little black designer dress”. These exceptions tend to arise with stock phrases such as “hex nut” or “little black dress”. In that case the entire phrase, including adjectives, is treated as the noun, with additional adjectives prepended.
- xerox13ster 2y agoWell, this is because a hex nut has a purpose and it is for you to hex your lost 10mm wrench. I would have thought that little black designer dress was correct. Designer little black dress feels incorrect. The L and BL in Little and black and then the Ds in designer and dress also lend an alliterative flow to “little black designer dress” that is not there for “designer little black dress”
- bee_rider 2y agoI think the dress example is not super great because “little black dress” is an expression or something. It is like an accessible and inexpensive but still nice and fashionable dress. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Little_black_dress https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Little_black_dress So I think a little black designer dress would be a designer dress which happened to be little and black. A designer little black dress would be a dress of the “little black dress,” variety, which also has the trait “designer” applied.