3 ms·
> If they're just scraping to train then I think you also imply there's no issue. If they're just copying your content (even if the prompt is "Hey Perplexity, s
by TeMPOraL 2y ago
> If they're just scraping to train then I think you also imply there's no issue. If they're just copying your content (even if the prompt is "Hey Perplexity, summarise this article <ARTICLE_TEXT>") then that's vanilla infringement, whether they lie about their UA or not.
Except, it can't possibly be like that - that would kill the Internet as you know it. It makes sense to consider scrapping for purposes of training as infringement - I personally disagree, I'm totally on the side of AI companies on this one, but there's a reasonable argument there. But in terms of me requesting a summary, and the AI tool doing it server-side before sending it to me, without also adding it to the pile of its own training data? Banning that would mean banning all user-generated content websites, all web viewing or editing tools, web preview tools, optimizing proxies, malware scanners, corporate proxies, hell, maybe even desktop viewers and editing tools.
There are always multiple programs between your website and your user's eyeballs. Most of them do some transformations. Most of them are third-party, usually commercial software. That's how everything works. Software made by "AI company" isn't special here. Trying to make it otherwise is some really weird form of prejudice-driven discrimination.
- danlitt 2y agoThis is not accurate, and it would not. As much as I would like it to be the case, you are not free to use public internet content for arbitrary purposes. In general (as you probably know), you rely on the idea that a court would consider your processing fair use. It's not transformative, it uses the entire work, the work copied is not a summary of facts, and insofar as their is a market at all, it circumvents that market. It fails every test. (training OTOH is inherently transformative, and I suspect likely to turn out to be a fair use)