2 ms·
That is a good point. Although, if we suppose intelligence can’t even be defined, then I don’t see how the question is even meaningful in the first place. We
by bee_rider 2y ago
That is a good point.
Although, if we suppose intelligence can’t even be defined, then I don’t see how the question is even meaningful in the first place.
We could I guess look at cognitive type tasks one by one, pick ones for which there is some sort of objective grading that can be done, and then ask if there’s any proof that a machine couldn’t do it better. But my gut says that machines should have a huge advantage in tasks where there’s an objective score.
Anyway the satire falls a bit flat if we don’t suppose intelligence is a thing like size that can be easily defined.
- throwup238 2y ago> Although, if we suppose intelligence can’t even be defined, then I don’t see how the question is even meaningful in the first place. No one is really saying that it can't be defined, just that it hasn't been defined yet. Until this latest round of LLMs basically flushed the Turing test down the drain, no one but ivory tower philosophers had cared about a rigorous definition of intelligence and without something akin to LLMs to experimentally ground their theories in language (like Wittgenstein's work), several thousand years of philosophy on the topic is pretty much useless to us now.