16 ms·
Ted Chiang has won the PEN/Faulkner Foundation's short story prize
- jebarker 2y agoWell deserved. "Hell is the absence of God" is my favorite of his stories. It's one of the few short stories I find myself repeatedly re-reading.
- renewiltord 2y agoMine too. Beautiful work. The characters. The imagery. The language. Magical. It's published in an anthology that has many other good stories too.
- nlawalker 2y agoOne of my favorite sentences in any book. “And God sent him to Hell anyway.”
- fleshdaddy 2y agoGod I love that line. I almost wish the story ended right there.
- sunshowers 2y agoMy favorite as well.
- eh_why_not 2y agoInteresting that he's never written a full novel, only short stories. I wonder if that in itself made his works higher quality: no pressure for high word count, and thus economy with words and no filler content.
- soneca 2y agoWhat differs a short story from a novel is definitely not “economy words and filler content”. The two are very different narratives, structure and concepts. You don’t usually start writing a novel and realize it’s a short story or vice versa. Even if you do, then you rethink your whole structure. Economy with words and filler content might differentiate a good from a bad novel, but not a novel and short story.
- eh_why_not 2y agoGood point. Which novels would you recommend that had no filler content?
- bookofjoe 2y ago"A Canticle For Leibowitz"; "The Stranger"; "The Fall"; "Childhood's End"; "Riddley Walker"; "The Martian Chronicles"; "The Sea of Tranquillity"; "Animal Farm"; "Catch 22"; "The Catcher in the Rye"; "A Clockwork Orange"; "Dr. Strangelove"; "To Kill A Mockingbird"; "The Little Prince"; "The Unbearable Lightness of Being"; "Lord of the Flies"; "Charlotte's Web"; "A Tree Grows in Brooklyn"; "All Quiet on the Western Front"; "The World According to Garp"; "Invisible Man"; "Flowers for Algernon"; "Sophie's Choice"; "The Road"; "All the Light We Cannot See"; "The Goldfinch"; "Atonement"; "The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time"
- marshray 2y agoTo the other great nominations, I would add: "The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy"
- Tavore 2y agoWhat is "filler content"? Because from how I understand it I'd argue there is no such thing as "filler content" in novels.
- soneca 2y ago“Filler” is very subjective. A very long chapter going on a tangential introspective mourning thoughts may be viewed by some, as it “doesn’t move the plot forward”, but it can be the most pungent point of emotional connection in the entire novel for others. Sometimes going on talking about minor characters routine is kind of the main point of an author’s intention, but it may read as “filler” by some. Or something like Brandon Sanderson books, where his fans enjoy spending more time in that universe, but make their novels very long.
- imwm 2y agoevidenced by the huge variation in word count among his short stories. some are a couple pages, while others are essentially novellas.
- karaterobot 2y agoGiven how long he's been writing (he sold his first story in 1989), the fact that he's only published 18 short stories and no novels in his entire career probably says a lot about his approach.
- paxys 2y agoHe has also written ~15 short stories over 35 years. Quality over quantity.
- a_bonobo 2y agoStephen King, to me, suffers from the exact opposite. His short stories are amazing and right to the point, but most of his novels are filler and would probably work better as short stories. In novels King has to answer questions he can skip in short fiction which is why his novels always end so unsatisfactory ('it was aliens all along!').
- constantinum 2y agoDivision by Zero (short story) Is my favourite of his.
- fsloth 2y agoTed Chiang is extremely recommended to anyone who enjoys inventive fiction. His work borders fantasy and science fiction, switching effortlessly from one topic to the next, with absolute mastery, being thought provoking, sophisticated, yet never stuffy or boring, with his only aim to tell a good story. If you like Borges, Clarke, Stephenson and others you will love Mr. Chiang. Some of his writing is the best I've read in creative fiction in any genre.
- 7thaccount 2y agoHis stuff is amazing. The only one I've read so far that I haven't liked was the one on the virtual pets. That one seemed to go on forever.
- justinpombrio 2y agoWell the virtual pet story had two problems! The first is that it seemed to go on forever, and the second was that it ended before the story was complete.
- gwern 2y agoYeah, I think that one suffered from not really having a clear vision of how AI would work, so it lacked the backbone that most Chiang stories start with and couldn't figure out what to do with itself and so went on too long. I'd like to see Chiang revisit that topic soon with DL scaling in mind to sharpen the vision and boil it down to its essence. (Hopefully he's no longer dismissing LLMs as 'blurry JPGs of the Internet'...)
- wyager 2y agoAlso strongly recommend Greg Egan, who I place in a similar bucket to Chiang. Egan has some books that fall into an (afaik) completely unique sub-genre that I have heard described as "math-fi". Some of his books are (credibly) described as a textbook wrapped in a narrative veneer. E.g. he has 3 books set in a universe with a ++++ metric tensor, and another book set in a ++-- universe. He painstakingly rederives many details of physics, chemistry, etc. to a level of detail that I've never seen even in physics textbooks, and then creates a story where characters in that universe discover its properties. The books are good even without paying too much attention to the math, but if you find that part interesting, he has detailed supplemental materials on his website.
- avnfish 2y agoAbsolutely love 'Anxiety Is the Dizziness of Freedom' by him
- RandomCitizen12 2y ago+1. Possibly my favorite story ever.
- superposeur 2y agoReading this story inspired me to work through Joe Polchinski’s classic paper on the “Everett phone” [1]. The paper partially answers a question I’ve long had about Quantum Mechanics, what is so special about linearity? In a nutshell, the paper demonstrates that even the tiniest bit of nonlinearity (at least of a certain sort) would allow for communication between branches of the wavefunction, like in the Chiang story. Super deep stuff that, in my opinion, physics hasn’t even fully come to terms with. [1] https://en.m.wiktionary.org/wiki/Everett-Wheeler_telephone https://en.m.wiktionary.org/wiki/Everett-Wheeler_telephone
- bangonkeyboard 2y agoI was hoping this had meant he'd written a new story.
- hrdwdmrbl 2y agoI would really like to know why he continues to work a day-job. Does he enjoy writing technical documentation that much?
- vessenes 2y agoI feel like the only person in scifi who doesn't LOVE Ted Chiang. Don't get me wrong -- I like his writing a lot. But, I often feel like it's a little 'light' -- not sure how to describe this exactly. I guess I'm saying he's not Philip K Dick or Stanislaw Lem, or even William Gibson, but he's awarded/discussed as much. I will, of course, buy his next book, short or long-form. But I'd love it if he went a little higher/deeper conceptually. I think he has it in him.
- elevatedastalt 2y agoI get you. A lot of short stories feel a bit... empty? to me. Like there's an effort to be profound but they don't get there.
- therealdrag0 2y agoAgree. Many feel like “I had an idea, I daydreamed a bit, then I wrote down my daydream”, leaving me with a shrug.
- vessenes 2y agoYes. I re-read some Chiang after this thread popped up, and I would say his writing style is aimed at like a sixth grade level. I’m sure Mr. Chiang can write to many audiences, but I think this contributes to this feeling of lightness/emptiness — simple writing, and I’d say sometimes simplified concepts. And, in the story I re-read, I’d say some of it was overexplained. It may explain his broad popularity though; I’m just not sure I’m his audience.
- karaterobot 2y agoOh wow! I'm late to the Ted Chiang game, having only read his books last year, but I've read a lot of PDK, a fair amount of Gibson, and a little bit of Lem. I think Chiang's less eager to end on a grim note than they are. And maybe that's what you're feeling. But I think the topics he deals with can be incredibly big, and incredibly dark. For instance, The Lifecycle of Software Objects was so realistic, and so dismally cynical about the software industry in particular, that it made me feel palpable fear and pre-emptive shame for the future.
- modernerd 2y ago”What's expected of us” is wonderful. https://www.nature.com/articles/436150a https://www.nature.com/articles/436150a
- kaiokendev 2y agoHighly recommend his Tower of Babylon, I think about it regularly, love his brand of sci-fi
- Mobius01 2y agoI re-read it often. It’s one of the best short stories I’ve read in the entire life.
- loudmax 2y agoTed Chiang's "Story of Your Life" was the basis for Denis Villeneuve's film "Arrival". The movie isn't a literal adaption of the short story, but IMHO it is very true to the original. Since all of Chiang's stories are short stories or novellas, they've very approachable. You're not committing to a full novel, you can easily read these stories in a single sitting. Ted Chiang is one of my favorite writers. I don't think I've read a single story of his that I didn't find interesting, and a lot of the ideas raise profound deeply engaging questions.
- stavros 2y agoThe anthology "Stories of your Life and Others" was the best scifi anthology I've read.
- bognition 2y agoPersonally I love "Exhalation" a lot more
- stavros 2y agoThat's up there too, maybe it's because I read SOYLAO first. I really liked both, though.
- marshray 2y agoMerchant and the Alchemist's Gate I shared this with a friend who grew up native in an Arabic-speaking country. After finishing it, he said he'd like to read it again but in the original Arabic. He'd interpreted it as authentic from his native storytelling culture. Such an amazing writer.
- ACS_Solver 2y agoI read both collections after, like others, getting introduced to Ted Chiang because of Arrival, and both rank highly among my favorites. Chiang can write some beautiful prose (best exemplified by "The Merchant and the Alchemist's Gate") and excels at taking a single interesting idea and taking it somewhere fascinating. With very few exceptions, his stories don't have real characters - they're just named tools to express ideas - but that works well with the kind of stories he writes. Highlights for me from Exhalation: The Merchant and the Alchemist's Gate - beautifully written story in the style of Arabic literature The Lifecycle of Software Objects - resonated strongly with me due to its criticism of the software industry, and raises great ethical questions about AIs The Truth of Fact, the Truth of Feeling - I was intrigued by the Tiv tribe's concepts of truth, and blown away when I later found out that "mimi" and "vough" are real concepts and not Chiang's imagination Anxiety Is the Dizziness of Freedom - a great and plausibly seeming examination of the psychological and social effects of communicating with alternate realities
- philipkglass 2y agoFrederik Pohl said "A good science fiction story should be able to predict not the automobile but the traffic jam." Chiang's stories are good SF stories in this vein -- even the stories with magic. He considers the consequences of his What-If hypotheticals in depth, whether they are plausible according to known physics or operate on fantasy suppositions. Consider his story [1] "Liking What You See: A Documentary." It's about a world in which people can have their perceptions of human beauty suppressed as an anti-discrimination measure. In some authors' voices this would be a strident sermon about a dystopian Equality Gone Too Far, or in others, about the new Utopia that arises when people are judged on their actions instead of their appearance. But Chiang doesn't preach to any choir. He plausibly represents how people would react to this hypothetical technological development without putting his thumb on the scale to tell readers how to feel about it. Most ideas are not as clearly bad as the Torment Nexus [2], nor as clearly beneficial as the polio vaccine. I love that Chiang can write about ideas that might as well be a pitch for a Black Mirror episode but with much more consideration than Black Mirror would treat it. His slow writing pace probably helps too. [1] https://waldyrious.neocities.org/ted_chiang/liking-what-you-see-a-documentary https://waldyrious.neocities.org/ted_chiang/liking-what-you-... [2] https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/torment-nexus https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/torment-nexus
- z5h 2y agoAs someone with aphantasia, who typically reads non-fiction and watches fiction, Ted Chiang’s work really stands out for me. Most visual descriptions are in service to technical details, and therefore they are enjoyable conceptually.
- shawnc 2y agoThank you! I too have aphantasia and I really appreciate this comment :)
- mkoubaa 2y agoI'm another aphant who really appreciates Chiang's writing! I wonder if he is one too
- theragra 2y agoYou make me doubt myself. I can't imagine stuff with the closed eyes, but when I read book I kind of can imagine stuff somewhat. Is it aphantasia or not? Matter of degree?
- z5h 2y agoAphantasia is objectively measurable. Aphants lack a pupil response to “imagining” shapes of various brightness. They also lack the measurable “stress/anxiety” response to anxiety provoking written passages, but not images. If any part of your imagination is like the experience of seeing, you probably don’t have it.
- theragra 2y agoNo, I remember it was like experience of seeing when I was a kid. I really saw stuff when I read the book. Now I kind of imagine it with thinking somehow. Hard to explain.
- nswest23 2y agointeresting...see this is why I although I find some of his work interesting I can't really get into it. I prefer fiction w/more visual descriptions that I can get immersed in.
- tetrisgm 2y agoIf you haven't had the chance, I highly recommend his short story called Understand. It'll resonate with a lot of people who are on the spectrum and like to think very meta.
- MattPalmer1086 2y agoSlightly off topic, but I now refuse to read any web site that does "malicious compliance" with cookies. If my only options are "consent" or manually going down a very long list unchecking everything, and don't forget to click on the little "vendors" link because there's an even longer list in there too... Then I give up. This isnt even compliant (you have to offer a way to reject easily). I don't know why they even bother; it's already illegal, and is just annoying. Bye!
- marshray 2y agoIMO, discussion of website function ought to be always on-topic on HN. My solution is simply to open every website (that I don't specifically want to be logged-in to) in incognito mode, accept all cookies, and close all the windows when I'm done.
- MattPalmer1086 2y agoAh, nice solution to prevent the cookies persisting. But I'd rather simply not give them my attention, if they're going to treat their audience with such contempt.
- injuly 2y agoWell deserved. My top 3 Ted Chiang works: 1. The merchant at the alchemist's gate. 2. What's Expected of us 3. Exhalation
- n4r9 2y agoThanks. I've only read Exhalation but really enjoyed it. Will check out the others.
- gyre007 2y agoI loved Stories of Your Life and Others. It had some really great stories. Exhaltation on the other I found mediocre. Stories are either elaborate or very tiresome.
- n4r9 2y agoWhat did you dislike about Exhalation?
- cubefox 2y agoScience fiction is perfectly suited for short stories. It's a way to explore thought experiments, without being too constrained by the possibilities of the present, while also not being able to be as arbitrary as in fantasy and similar genres.
- datadrivenangel 2y agoIf you like Ted Chiang and scifi short stories, consider checking out Jay Lake's Last Plane to Heaven, or Charles Stross's Wireless collection. Short stories are such a fantastic and frustrating format, because the best ones blow your mind and leave you wanting another thousand pages.
- mtalantikite 2y agoI thought most of the authors nominated for PEN prizes this year were boycotting the organization and the awards were canceled? [1]. I guess Ted Chiang didn't withdraw his nomination like everyone else did. [1] https://www.npr.org/2024/04/23/1246578813/pen-america-cancels-awards-ceremony-writers-protest-gaza-response https://www.npr.org/2024/04/23/1246578813/pen-america-cancel...
- anamexis 2y agoFrom your linked article: > But the event was canceled when nearly half of the writers and translators nominated withdrew their books from consideration. The awards will still be granted to those who did not withdraw.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- mtalantikite 2y agoLooks like this is sort of a lifetime achievement award you can't withdraw from. Other authors donated their winnings to Palestine in protest, so maybe he will as well.
- deanCommie 2y agoI read the letter [0] and am deeply confused. For context, I agree with the basic philosophical premise. I'm a Jew, but Israel is a repressive apartheid state, and while it had a right to defend itself, it's approach in Gaza absolutely meets the internationally accepted definition of genocide. The positions of individual Jews and Israelis are on a wide spectrum, but it's also not controversial to say that as far as the current Israeli leadership, this genocide is not an accident, not even from a lack of care. It is absolutely within their goals and desires to have all Palestenians eliminated from the territory administrated by Israel, and they're going as far as they can without losing the international support of the United States. With all of that said, I have no idea what PEN has to do with this. If they are endorsing it, they should stop. If they're funding it, they should stop. If they're invested in organizations directly supporting the Israeli government, they should stop. But if all they are is "an organization in the US", then their tax dollars are going to fund the genocide. And every single American taxpayer is equally complicit here, which is to say not at all. People SHOULD be fighting for change, and advocating for it. But not through empty speeches or statements. Statements from PEN do not protect or save the rights of Palestinians. I also think this is meaningfully different from the BLM era when protestors stated that silence is violence, and a lack of a statement is a tacit rejection of the movement. BLM was/is about an inherently American problem of systemic racism. White Americans benefit from systemic racism through no action of their own, so acknowledging it and at least making an effort to get woke to it (the original meaning of the term) is at least a necessary step to choosing to helping to dismantle it. American Corporations do play a part in that. But on Israel/Palestine, I just think these moves do not help the cause. [0] https://docs.google.com/document/d/1VEF-Hrg8wN7WHiSljqwd9IqHbRHDsHWRM0j576PFT1I/edit https://docs.google.com/document/d/1VEF-Hrg8wN7WHiSljqwd9IqH...
- gallerdude 2y agoFor someone who loves Ted Chiang, what adjacent writers would people recommend? I tried Borges, and I like him, he just seems less accessible and intentionally opaque at points.
- lubujackson 2y agoNever Let Me Go by Kazuo Ishiguro. Only barely sci-fi, but shares the same lyrical precision as Ted Chiang. Somehow it's the first thing that came to mind. I'd also recommend short stories by Kafka. Not just his most famous ones like Metamorphosis (which is fairly long), but his very short stories are quite intense and have a similar sort of "weight".
- predictand 2y agoI found Axiomatic by Greg Egan to have a similar vibe.
- gtsnexp 2y agoI wish he would write more often, especially if he decides to tackle non-fiction using his distinct prose style. His creativity, combined with factual writing, could make for a deep/transformative read.
- water-data-dude 2y agoHe’s always thought provoking! “Story of Your Life” is obviously great. A lot of people mention it down below - an order of magnitude better than the movie IMO, since I think the movie missed the main interesting, mindblowing point. Possibly my favorite is the last story in the “Story of Your Life” collection, “Liking What You See: A Documentary” (I think I got the title right). It’s about a controversy on a college campus where the administration is getting ready to make a rule requiring that students use a technology that blocks their perception of beauty in humans. It’s not even a real technology, but the way he shows all sides of the issue - showing that it’s a lot more complicated than it looks at first glance - it feels REAL. Amazing author.
- predictand 2y ago"Anxiety Is the Dizziness of Freedom" is one of the best stories I have read about quantum physics. I highly recommend it. I can't wait for it to become a movie.
- RandomCitizen12 2y agoI dearly hope it becomes a movie. It reminded me of Naval Ravikant idea, except Ravikant was talking about money and Chiang wasn't: "In 1,000 parallel universes, you want to be wealthy in 999 of them. You don’t want to be wealthy in the 50 of them where you got lucky. We want to factor luck out of it." (https://nav.al/rich https://nav.al/rich)