3 ms·
It depends on what you get from music. For me, the important part of music isn't how beautiful or ugly it is (some of my favorite music is beautiful, some is u
by JohnFen 2y ago
It depends on what you get from music.
For me, the important part of music isn't how beautiful or ugly it is (some of my favorite music is beautiful, some is ugly). It's the communication of human emotion and experience that I value.
So yes, for me, it matters a great deal who made it. Even the most beautiful music in the world loses meaning and impact to me if it's made by machine. (Nuance here: not "made by people using machines", but "created by a machine instead of a human".)
I know that I'm very far from alone in this, which makes me think that the answer to the headline question is "no, its not the end for musicians". Perhaps it will (or won't) reduce the number of them, but they will always exist because at least some people will always want that human communication.
- nabla9 2y agoIf machine performs a piece and musician is just there for playback performance, you enjoy it until you find the truth?
- JohnFen 2y agoI assume you mean "if a machine authors a piece of music"? A musician performing a piece of music created by another is not just there for playback. Two musicians performing the same composition will not produce identical pieces of music. The musician is inevitably adding their own layer of interpretation during the performance. So, at worst, it becomes communication from the musician to me rather than communication from the composer to me.