6 ms·
Canada imposes 5% tax on streaming to fund local news, diverse content
- mikemitchelldev 2y agoThis basically means that Netflix and other streamers are going to increase their prices.
- dmix 2y agoYes it's just another tax on Canadian customers to fund the CBC et al and whatever diverse content means.
- nequo 2y agoThis idea is not new nor uniquely Canadian. The purpose of all public media is to make programming and reporting possible that is seen as socially valuable but an advertising/click/like-driven business model cannot sustain. The money for it needs to be diverted from somewhere. The UK has had TV licensing to fund the BBC: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Television_licensing_in_the_United_Kingdom https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Television_licensing_in_the_Un...
- dmix 2y agoThat's great, almost no one is going to watch it still if they weren't already before. There's tons of existing subsidies that already at every level of gov. This isn't the 90s when they could force feed us bad Canadian produced TV shows on Canadian TV channels. Netflix gives people the choice of global content now and there's more opportunity and money floating around for young up and coming filmmakers than ever before.
- andrepd 2y agoPerfect, you have the choice of 1000s of bland AI-written slop and no local (or even national) independent press. Peachy. There is such a thing as a public good outside of the logic of The Market.
- morkalork 2y agoAgain
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- toomuchtodo 2y agoCompetitors can always licenses content and offer it at a lower rate. Netflix is blob storage and CDN, with a helping of a comedian production arm.
- gdsdfe 2y agoThe opposition doesn't seem to be smarter that's the real problem
- toomuchtodo 2y agoA business operating in a jurisdiction is a privilege. If you don’t like the rules, leave.
- bossyTeacher 2y agoNetflix can choose whether to increase prices. You can choose whether to pay Netflix. I know it sounds crazy but a Netflix sub is an optional item
- ryandrake 2y agoIf they could increase profitability by raising their prices before the tax, why wouldn’t they have already done it? Companies base their prices on what the market will bear, not necessarily on their costs.
- HaseebQ 2y agoBecause it wouldn't have increased profitability? See: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tax_incidence https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tax_incidence
- csa 2y ago> If they could increase profitability by raising their prices before the tax, why wouldn’t they have already done it? Because now they have an external reason they can point to, similar to “inflation”… even if the extra charges end up being mostly profits.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- rahimnathwani 2y agoIf one company in an industry faces higher costs, they may not be able to raise prices, as they would lose customers. If all companies in an industry suddenly face higher costs, that shifts the supply+demand equilibrium.
- Ajay-p 2y agoPublic funded news is a terrible idea because it's too easy to become corrupted by politics. This makes it easier for Netflix to raise prices, but it is what the people seem to want. Otherwise I guess we'll find out at the elections next year.
- andsoitis 2y ago> Public funded news is a terrible idea because it's too easy to become corrupted by politics. This makes it easier for Netflix to raise prices This argument is illogical. Netflix does not carry news, so how is that affected one way or another by public funded news?
- scosman 2y agoThis “idea” has been implemented for decades around the world with lots of success.
- southernplaces7 2y agoOne is tempted to think that local news, "diverse content" (however that's defined) would be something Canadians would pay for willingly and without need for yet another enforced subsidy from the government, but apparently not, they just want what they think is good.
- morkalork 2y agoTo be quite honest, most people don't really care about indigenous stories and languages in Canada because that's not their identity. Overall, indigenous peoples make up 5% of the population. It's a niche market that wouldn't sustain much on its own without subsidies.
- arghwhat 2y agoIt's not that simple, people do not buy each TV episode or movie they watch. They subscribe to a small number of streaming services which decide what content to produce and/or acquire. The only reasonable way for someone to pay for a particular type of content is either: 1. Subscribe to a major provider that has it in their library (e.g., "I want to watch some anime, and Netflix has some anime"), 2. Subscribe to a special-purpose provider for just this content ("I want to watch a lot of anime, enough to justify having crunchyroll beside netflix"). What happens is that people shop amongst the big ones, and just do away with content they do not offer. Unless people want to protest/boycott providers, there is no way to vote with your money on products they are not offered, nor does it work if the products are extremely inconvenient or financially unsound.
- DiggyJohnson 2y agoWhat are some examples of diverse content?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- jalk 2y agorecent Disney shows perhaps (i.e Acolyte)
- shermantanktop 2y agoA guess: locally produced content, rather than content created for a US or global audience. A winner-takes-all victory has different implications in the cultural sphere.
- DiggyJohnson 2y agoFair enough, I see that as the best possible definition.
- ziddoap 2y agoThey give examples in the 3rd paragraph of the article. It's the italicized part in quotes.
- t222ic 2y agoWhere can I short Canada?
- throwup238 2y agoYou can short the Kraft Dinner manufacturer and invest in New England maple syrup futures.
- stocknoob 2y agoForex
- dwighttk 2y agoHave babies
- Someone1234 2y agoIf this is a genuine question: You'd short a Canadian "Total Stock Market" fund like (VCN) Vanguard FTSE Canada All Cap Index ETF. You can also short the currency, but that requires some expertise since you need to consider the relative currency you purchased from too.
- canadiantim 2y agoTrudeau's gone in a month so be careful with the volatility. Mark Carney coming in as replacement.
- 2y ago
- atonse 2y agoTo those asking what "diverse" means in this context, here's a quote in the article from the authorities: > “The funding will be directed to areas of immediate need in the Canadian broadcasting system, such as local news on radio and television, French-language content, Indigenous content, and content created by and for equity-deserving communities, official language minority communities, and Canadians of diverse backgrounds.” Original Announcement: https://www.canada.ca/en/radio-television-telecommunications/news/2024/06/crtc-requires-online-streaming-services-to-contribute-to-canadas-broadcasting-system.html https://www.canada.ca/en/radio-television-telecommunications...
- HyulianGrader 2y ago[flagged]
- mason_mpls 2y agook the first thing they mentioned was french language content, chill
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- csa 2y ago> the first thing they mentioned was french language content Based on the quote above, the first thing they mentioned was “local news on radio and television”.
- hunter2_ 2y agoThe headline says "Local News, Diverse Content" so when that condensed list is expanded to the full list, in which the first item of each list clearly aligns and the remaining item(s) of each list clearly align, then no, local news is not the first diversity item in the list. French language is.
- Dig1t 2y ago
- fidotron 2y agoThe sad reality of Canada is such things are just ways to fund new classes of kickbacks to Trudeau and his buddies. Episodes such as ArriveCAN have made even my lefty friends suspicious of all gov spending.
- xutopia 2y agoLaws like these existed in the music and film industries for years and it helped foster local talent. Even public radios had to have a percentage of Canadian music on the air. Streaming services have circumvented this and this law changes that for the better. The kind of cynicism on display about anything that Trudeau does is frankly disconcerting. Even a broken clock can be right twice a day.
- newsclues 2y agoJust because wealth transfers for culture existed before doesn’t make them right nor does it make the implementation of this policy good. Good policy is good if you reverse the winners and see if the people implementing it complain. So if we take this tax and fund media for men and white people instead of women, First Nation and immigrants would it still be good policy? No this is political patronage
- skidd0 2y agoBroken clocks don't belong in office though, do they?
- cmrdporcupine 2y ago"Lefties" don't vote Liberal, we vote NDP. And we've been trying to tell you this about the Liberal Party for 50+ years. It's a corrupt opportunistic self-interested institution. There's nothing intrinsically "left wing" about them, they just put up whatever ideological sail will keep their party in power. In the 90s they were the party of austerity. This decade, they're all about "debt doesn't matter" neo-Keynesianism. An election or two later and they'll flip again. But you can count on seeing the same faces and them putting the Party first. Me: self-identified socialist who knew ArriveCAN was a f*in disaster from the moment it was announced?
- brigadier132 2y agoAll taxes like this are hidden flat taxes. Also money is fungible, so if you are a Canadian you should ask would i accept a general increase in taxes to fund “local news or diverse content” Answer is probably no
- Loughla 2y agoWhy is the answer probably no? I think it's an interesting opportunity to see things I don't normally get to see. And I'm privileged enough that this isn't the end of my lifestyle with the increased cost that will occur. So why not?
- brigadier132 2y ago1. For most people money is a thing that they gain by literally converting their lifespan into it via work. So if we take it from people it should be for things of importance 2. There is a finite amount of money and there are things more important than tv. Maybe curing cancer? Subsidizing childcare? Dunno two easy ones off the top of my head
- ziddoap 2y ago>it should be for things of importance Local news is important. >things more important than tv. Maybe curing cancer? This is a fallacy. The people making local news shows aren't the same people that are curing cancer, and the people curing cancer aren't going to stop to go make local news shows because of this.
- voisin 2y agoWe’re not talking about the people. We’re talking about where tax dollars get directed.
- glitcher 2y agoMany people will know quite personally the struggle you describe, but I think there's an implicit assumption in it that reliable news sources will always remain available with or without direct monetary support from the population. I'll admit that "reliable" is a loaded word here, but what happens if the only news available becomes a hyper sensationalized engagement at all costs over facts dumpster fire? Freedom of the press was an important enough idea to make it into the US first amendment, but just like freedom the press isn't free.
- rybosworld 2y agoCanada seems to be making all the wrong decisions, all of the time.
- Teever 2y agoWhere are you getting that impression? Like in curious which media sources you're watching that are informing you about the state of Canada?
- voisin 2y agoJacking up immigration without any infrastructure planning to support it? Keeping medical school residencies small - zero growth! - while in a crisis of lack of primary care physicians? In the midst of record inflation, choosing $40b deficit spending that any economist will tell you is inflationary? In the midst of record low - and dropping! - productivity, increasing taxes on capital to disincentivize investment in this country?
- Teever 2y agoYour answer doesn't answer my question. I'm asking that user where they get their news about Canada from. I'm assuming that they're not Canadian and I'm interested to know where non Canadians read news about Canada.
- voisin 2y agoMy response is that this list of things is covered across the political spectrum of media sources - these items are not controversial, fringe issues covered only outside of Canada to portray Canada poorly for some purpose. Our most prominent news organizations cover these debacles constantly: National Post (right leaning) or Globe and Mail (left leaning), CBC, and out to the fringes as well.
- Teever 2y agoAgain, your answer is to a question that wasn't directed towards you, and it doesn't answer the question. I'm a Canadian, I read these sources and am well aware of the issues you want to soapbox about. I'm not interested in hearing about them from you. If I did I would go to /r/canada to hear the exact same stuff. What I'm far more interested in is seeing where non-Canadians get their news about Canada.
- askonomm 2y agoIs that sort of like bad healthcare that is not optional and forcefully taken from each salary you make when you could instead use a fraction of that healthcare tax to get a vastly superior private healthcare, and yet you're not allowed to NOT pay healthcare tax, thus if you want better healthcare you pay for it AND the private one?
- bossyTeacher 2y agoIt's such an American idea to think that you will always have a job and that you will never be unfit to work before you can afford not to work
- halostatue 2y agoHaving spent four days in the hospital recently on something and only having a $45 ambulance bill out of it without even having to think about whether going to the hospital would bankrupt me — I’ll take Canada's taxes over those in the US. We at least get value for our taxes, and (mostly) don’t have greedy US healthcare companies denying necessary coverage because it would drop their profitability by 0.001%.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- MattPalmer1086 2y agoPlease point me to anywhere that provides bad health care at vastly more cost than private health care? Private health care in the US is ruinously expensive with worse outcomes than most of the rest of the developed world.
- GrantMoyer 2y agoMaybe the private healthcare is only cheap because it has to compete with free. (free in the sense that any costs are sunk costs, not that there are no costs)
- mminer237 2y agoHow much could it possibly cost? As a young, healthy American, I currently pay over $10,000/year (about half of which is forcefully taken not even counting Medicaid/Medicare) for a plan with a $7,000 deductible. In other words, I get zero benefit other than an annual checkup unless I have something catastrophic happen. This was by far both the cheapest plan and best plan available for every situation for me. Google says the average Canadian pays, including taxes, about half of what I do. Do you just not get any coverage at all?
- WarOnPrivacy 2y agoI've spent decades considering journalism shortcomings from lots of angles, inc hard R and L. My conclusion is most of us can have the news we wanted if we focused on ineptitude/competency. A strong negative example: Reporting a Gov/Corp/LEO press release without analyzing the integrity of the remarks or the issuer is classic ineptitude. Especially when the data that discredits them are trivial to find. kids alone are at meaningful risk of stranger kidnapping FBI/DA says encryption makes Americans less safe Today, Huge Corp announced ambition new plans to... I truly appreciate a financial lifeline to keep news orgs from dying completely (even if the method is highly questionable). I do not relish a continuation of journalists failing to minimally vet the info they're advancing.
- apantel 2y agoMarket distortion. People don’t want to pay for local news, diverse content.
- ToucanLoucan 2y agoI mean based on what does well in the various markets, sometimes markets are wrong. Maybe a controversial opinion but a market is basically just a popularity contest where dollars are votes, which is not only inherently biased towards the wealthy, since those with more dollars get more votes, but it's the same flawed people doing the voting at the end of the day. The results of that certainly matter in that those who want to succeed in a given market will pay attention to what does succeed, but it's far from beyond reproach. Sometimes markets choose badly.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- jejones3141 2y agoCanCon 2.0?
- Waterluvian 2y agoThe incredibly low quality comments mustered here, compared to typical HN posts, makes it very difficult not to just see this as a sump of bots and foreign agents.
- martythemaniak 2y agoI agree with the general shittyness of these comments, but they're probably real people. Whenever Canadian politics makes an appearance here, it's a combination of ignorant foreigners projecting their own local politics without any context, or groups like the convoyers or Ontario Proud spewing their usual garbage.
- smallbluedot 2y agoA lot of Canadians are sick and tired of our corrupt, lying government. It's laughable to reduce critics of Trudeau and the Liberal party as mere "convoyers" or "Ontario proud" characters. I voted for Trudeau in 2015 and am so fucking done with this clown and his party.
- Waterluvian 2y agoThat's not the issue here. It's that this is the entirely wrong place to go off-topic and begin airing political grievances. It just screams "bots and agents."
- GarettWithOneR 2y agoThe pattern is so consistent across online discourse about any Canadian news, no matter the platform. I would've though HN would be too small but apparently not.
- CryptoBanker 2y agoNo offense, but you look like one of the offenders here when you make posts like > Eek… I’d never want to fly a plane that’s beneath me. I’d prefer it to be at the same altitude.
- temporalparts 2y agoI can't tell if people in this thread are negative about taxes or negative about funding local news, which is crucial for a robust democracy.
- akie 2y agoTaxes, of course. The crowd here contains quite a few libertarian techno-optimists.
- GarettWithOneR 2y agoI thought HN was better than /r/Canada but apparently not.
- hylaride 2y agoMy god, has that subreddit has ever gone downhill (and it was never particularly on a high one).
- cantSpellSober 2y agoThe word "diverse" is flamebait on this site
- maxxfury 2y ago[flagged]
- shrubble 2y agoSo who controls, where the money goes?
- ChrisArchitect 2y ago[dupe] More discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40576696 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40576696
- matthewfelgate 2y agoThis is nasty vindictive stuff from government. Taxing successful companies to fund their pet projects that the state thinks we should watch.
- DaleNeumann 2y agoA lot of media in Canada is subsidized, the government needs to justify its expenses somehow. It has nothing to do with Canadian exceptionalism or something like that.
- liminal 2y agoPeople here don't seem to realize the importance of Canadian content rules in maintaining a cohesive national identity and supporting local content producers. The overwhelming barrage of U.S. media necessitates funding the creation of Canadian content, artists and points of view.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- rifty 2y ago> The fee systems effectively mirrors the fees already imposed on local broadcasters. I suppose the question becomes should it have been there on the others? I kind of feel that due to the reduced population scale and density of Canada, if you want marginal communities to have closer to home produced content you need to do something like this. The base for the niche groups isn’t big enough (and realistically often isn’t wealthy enough) to minimally support niche content sustainably. Then again, it feels the recent focus in Canada has been to strip down the taxable to fund and placate the untaxable, with total disregard as to making the taxable or the untaxable more productive and improving their outlook on life. The tax feels fine to me if in decent circumstances, but it’s another example of the governments broader attitude which makes it off-putting.
- theyknowitsxmas 2y agoThe kids aren't buying cable any more and most of the stations are owned by the government.