5 ms·
> I know a fair number of them personally and they are often very young, generally inexperienced, highly intelligent, but with a hefty dose of hubris. Part of
by latexr 2y ago
> I know a fair number of them personally and they are often very young, generally inexperienced, highly intelligent, but with a hefty dose of hubris.
Part of the issue is that we keep calling these people “highly intelligent” and that is all they and others focus on. That is how we get the Zuckerbergs of the world. Their hubris is not a “but” (as if it were unrelated), it is instead a direct consequence of that unqualified praise.
But qualification is important. Intelligence is relative to the domain it is applied to. Being highly logical is often conflated with being intelligent, but being good at computers has zero relation to emotional intelligence, social intelligence, environmental intelligence, or any of the myriad of important types of intelligence which are useful to humanity.
Basically, stop calling those idiots “highly intelligent” or “geniuses” because they can make a line go up and have an irrational market throw money at them. You’re praising them for the characteristics that make them selfish.
- fnordpiglet 2y agoI meant what I said. The ones I know working on safety and alignment are highly intelligent on all those dimensions you mentioned. They are really smart yes, but also have high emotional IQs and are deeply committed to doing the right thing on every dimension they can. But they’re still children. And I mean they’re in their 20’s. Their confidence outweighs their experience. That’s what I mean by hubris, not that they’re on spectrum savants playing with power they don’t understand and can’t. They fully can appreciate the consequences of their work, but they don’t have the world experience to understand what in their work will fail and what will work. One day they will be people I trust can be responsible for the decisions they’re making. And hopefully by that time it’ll be the time their decisions really matter a lot. But right now they’re just too young.