4 ms·
I always just thought of telepathy in science fiction as being like faster-than-light travel: clear nonsense, but a very convenient and interesting method of av
by JohnFen 2y ago
I always just thought of telepathy in science fiction as being like faster-than-light travel: clear nonsense, but a very convenient and interesting method of avoiding physical realities that interfere with telling certain types of stories. It's an aspect of the "fiction" part of science fiction.
But, relatedly, I think that a certain kind of category error happens that can play into this as well: a lot of science fiction is actually fantasy, just in a technological setting. Star Wars, for instance, is not science fiction so much as it's fantasy.
- pixl97 2y agoI mean how much of telepathy is in reach of science now? Think of two individuals with some kind of neurolink style device. Could they be able to communicate with just thought?
- WorldMaker 2y agoFor a related but flipped perspective: imagine you were describing modern society and the ubiquity of texting. The speed and non-verbal aspects of it, coupled with some people's ability to multi-task texting in the middle of other conversation would be hard to describe to an audience in the 1950s or 1960s, but if you were going to describe it a lot of scifi descriptions of telepathy come close. Maybe we already invented "telepathy" in the future we are living in, it's just so ubiquitous and "dull" and "everyday" we underestimate how fantastic and weird it is from past perspectives?
- WalterBright 2y agoA lot of scifi is just westerns, with blasters replacing guns. See "The Mandalorean".
- fl0ki 2y agoA lot of westerns are just samurai movies, with guns replacing swords.
- pyuser583 2y agoIt took me a while to realize ST original series is just a western. It’s Captain Kirk and his gang of cowboys going from town to town. Not a bad thing in any way.
- WalterBright 2y agoIt was originally "Wagon Train to the Stars".