5 ms·
X: This week we're making Likes private for everyone
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- whoknowsidont 2y agoThis was an incredibly dumb change. No one asked for this, and there is no setting to keep likes public. We already had bookmarks. Seeing other people's likes was a great way to find additional content. Further illustrates that the purpose behind this change was to both protect a very small number of not-so-smart users and further remove analysis behind posts and its engagement. Very poorly thought out.
- xenospn 2y agoNot if you’re into things that will get you “canceled”! I think this is designed specifically to make it easier to spread hate speech.
- f38zf5vdt 2y agoIt will come back to bite people since the likes are still visible to the content creator. Elon has a history of liking stupid things and will be emboldened by this, and content creators may freely see/repost these likes on their accounts as endorsements. Feels bad all around.
- darklion 2y agoIt’s being done in response to Elon Musk being caught liking some questionable things. Now people (e.g., Musk) can like anti-Semitic and pro-white supremacy and pro-Nazi content all they want without fear of being exposed as anti-Semitic or pro-Nazi.
- forgot-im-old 2y ago[flagged]
- alan-hn 2y agoThis is the real reason
- mrguyorama 2y agoMore importantly, now how will we be able to make fun of politicians for "liking" weird porn on 9/11?
- skhunted 2y agoIndeed. Obviously this is the real reason for the change. Musk wants people to be able to follow whatever lunatic bullshit is out there without fear of being ridiculed. One can now be a sycophantic dupe without people knowing about it.
- tracker1 2y agoUsing left examples of activities that could also be filtered as extremist. One may definitely want to know all the people that liked a given Hamas post, BLM, Antifa, etc. How else are you going to keep the potentially disruptive and disastrous people out of your company. edit: I'm not a proponent of this type of action, only pointing out that it isn't just "far right hate speech" that can be a target.
- skhunted 2y agoYes. It works both ways as it always has. Being a communist was enough to get you fired at one time. Sinead O’Connor famously got canceled.
- alan-hn 2y agoSomeone liking a black lives matter post could be disastrous? That's an interesting take that definitely doesn't smell like white supremacy
- tracker1 2y agoLike lighting a police station on fire, shooting up a car, vandalization, tearing down a statue, or launching commercial fireworks at a courthouse? Can't see how someone might find that offensive at all (/s).
- alan-hn 2y agoThose are not BLM, BLM is the support of the idea that there should be racial equity in policing. What you are describing is vandalism which is not what the person I'm replying to said
- tracker1 2y agoThe riots, vandalism, etc was definitely under the BLM flag in terms of optics... which is why support for BLM was lower after the riots than before George Floyds death.
- jsheard 2y agoThey already had Bookmarks for the purpose of saving a Tweet without putting it on your public Likes feed, so what's the difference between a Like and a Bookmark now? I guess a Like gives an algorithm boost that a Bookmark probably doesn't, but that's a pretty opaque distinction for users.
- bluefirebrand 2y agoBookmarks are "this I may want to go see again later" Likes are "I want to express a positive feeling towards this but don't care if I can ever see it again" Not the same thing
- alan-hn 2y agoNow nobody can tell that others have expressed positive feelings, which is the point, no?
- bluefirebrand 2y agoThe person who made the post still can, which is the point to me I look at it more like walking up to someone and saying "Hey I like what you're doing" not like standing near them and shouting it for everyone to hear
- robotelvis 2y agoThis makes a lot of sense. In the current political climate people feel afraid of getting punished for liking the wrong thing. But it’s nice for the person whose post you liked to know who liked it. If you want to appreciate something publicly then that’s what reshare is for.
- darklion 2y ago[flagged]
- Ukv 2y agoBeing afraid of getting punished for liking the wrong thing could also be, for instance, an LGBT person in a non-accepting environment. There are many reasons for privacy that aren't anything to do with hate speech. Though, I think having it a toggle defaulting to private (like reddit votes) would be slightly better, for those who do intentionally want to share their likes.
- Teever 2y agoYeah sure, but is there anything to make you think that Elon Musk wants that versus what the person you're replying to is suggesting.
- Ukv 2y agoI imagine Musk wants higher engagement metrics to brag about, and removing barriers to liking content is one way to achieve that - which applies to many people and not just Nazis.
- Teever 2y agoWhy are you making the assumption that Musk is thinking about this in rational business terms? Have you not been paying attention to the things he's been saying and doing for the past few years?
- notarobot123 2y agoThe idea of Twitter as the “de facto public town square” seems a lot less plausible if post interactions are private. This move edges it closer towards a purely broadcast medium. The transition would be complete as soon as users can moderate replies. This feels like an experiment in reverse-engineering Twitter's USP by removing critical features until the network collapses.
- ronsor 2y ago> The transition would be complete as soon as users can moderate replies. They already can.
- tr3ntg 2y agoI'm not on X much these days, but when I was, the greatest benefit of likes for me was when I would tweet something, I could see the folks who liked it. This has not changed. My greatest annoyance around likes was how my feed would include "So and so like this" type tweets. Maybe that still exists, but if they removed that too, it'd be a welcome change. Lots of great points being made in this thread, but for me personally, such a change would not affect my experience on the site.
- bluefirebrand 2y ago> My greatest annoyance around likes was how my feed would include "So and so like this" type tweets. Maybe that still exists, but if they removed that too, it'd be a welcome change. Couldn't agree more I didn't want to see "so and so likes this" and I don't want others to see "bluefirebrand likes this" If I wanted to share something then I would retweet it It was also baffling that people could turn off seeing "so and so retweeted this" but not turn off seeing "so and so liked this"
- blackeyeblitzar 2y agoI don’t use X/Twitter, but I am surprised it wasn’t always this way. People should be able to have a degree of privacy and anonymity while participating online. Cancel culture is very harmful to discussion, especially on politically controversial topics.
- ChrisArchitect 2y agoFurther killing the network effects that made the platform so powerful. Power users know how good it was on Tweetdeck with the Activity tab surfacing all the great tweets you wouldn't necessarily see. If likes are private now does that mean the For You tab will have even less powering it? Just so a bunch of ppl can creep on some 'questionable' tweets? Weak
- bluefirebrand 2y agoI disagree. There's already a function for sharing the stuff you see Turning a "like" into a sort of soft retweet was a bad move. Personally it made me much less likely to interact with stuff I don't want it to surface every action I take to people who follow me Does anyone actually even like the For You tab? All I ever see is "I was wondering why I was seeing so much garbage in my feed, turns out it changed me to For You and I didn't notice"
- jauntywundrkind 2y agoResharing content is a very high bar. I will upvoted or like >50 things in a day, many days. I tend to reshare stuff ~4 times a week. These are - to me - very obviously different levels of networking & connection; I want to share what I like but I'm not trying to flood the zone & broadcast on main every little thing I enjoy that I run across; my actual account distills down to things that make it across a high threshold barrier. But heck yes people should be able to see yeah what else I'm enjoying if they want to deep dive! What's fucking batshot insane is the lack of a feature is being imposed on everyone. Fine! Make it an option to hide your shameful guilty shit you don't want people to see! De-network if you must, if you are scared. But to take this away from everyone, to deny the option to network & share at this pleasant simple low level? That's insane. I cannot imagine how anyone would entertain such a destructive negative anti-network path as what should be forced on everyone.
- bluefirebrand 2y ago> Make it an option to hide your shameful guilty shit you don't want people to see! De-network if you must, if you are scared Why does it have to be about being "scared"? In my mind a like is between me and the person who posted. Why does every little interaction have to be broadcast as far as possible? And I agree the threshold for re-sharing is high. That's why turning likes into a soft re-share is annoying. I didn't want that shard. I don't really care if my likes are hidden. I don't care if people can look at the likes on a post and find my account But I don't want it broadcast either. If I wanted it broadcast I would use the "I want to broadcast this" button > I want to share what I like but I'm not trying to flood the zone But that's what it is doing by turning your likes into a reshare. Every like you make becomes part of the flood. Only you get to feel like you aren't doing it on purpose I found it incredibly annoying when I would see more "someone liked this post" than actual new stuff If my feed moves slower because I'm only seeing new posts and deliberate reshares then that is a good thing imo. I don't need the system to dig up infinite content for me by farming everyone's likes and other interactions
- ein0p 2y agoAs a privacy preserving move, I like it. Even though I can’t be bothered to like anything there. They probably see that as a problem for their ranking algorithm, hence the change.
- ucirello 2y agoThis just threw a huge wrench in the gears for a spambot detection system I was working on. The kind of content a spambot likes is a great indicator to choose whom to block or not.
- jauntywundrkind 2y agoIn general this is such a good way to assess & browse & evaluate people. Trying to figure out who to follow & who is definitely not someone to follow gets much much harder when the like-feed goes dark. Try as people might to defend this anti-networking anti-feature I just don't see it. It's an ok option for some I guess, sure, but tearing up your network unilaterally to create a safer space really just sends us into an even darker forest.
- ceejayoz 2y agoTed Cruz will be relieved; https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2017/sep/12/ted-cruz-twitter-account-likes-pornographic-tweet https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2017/sep/12/ted-cruz-twi...
- colpabar 2y agoDidn't they also just "allow" porn via some update to their rules? This change just seems like a way to say "hey, don't worry if you accidentally hit like on a porn tweet, we won't tell!"
- Apocryphon 2y agoFeels like another reason for this is to hide the rampant bot problem of obviously fake accounts liking tweets (and thereby pretending to have real engagement?)