5 ms·
It's worth re-reading works from the trenches of WWII. US troops haven't had to fight a war like that within living memory. Ukraine and Russia are fighting one
by Animats 2y ago
It's worth re-reading works from the trenches of WWII. US troops haven't had to fight a war like that within living memory. Ukraine and Russia are fighting one now.
The clouds of war are gathering. Germany is making plans for a draft. Poland tried a small-scale test mobilization of civilians. Poland and Latvia are planning to send back Ukrainian males who dodged the draft there. Sweden and Finland never stopped having a draft.
Russia is currently spending over 7% of GDP on its military. The EU averages around 1.5%. US around 2.9%. Russia supposedly lost 40,000 soldiers in Ukraine last month alone, although nobody has solid numbers. That's about 4x the losses on the Allied side for D-Day in 1944. Big wars kill large numbers of people.
- aebtebeten 2y ago> Big wars kill large numbers of people (Leaving NBC for a different comment:) Stalingrad had more Allied deaths alone (in ~half year) than Union and Confederate deaths combined of the US Civil War (in ~4 years). To be fair, that was (part of) a big war without medevac, but given (a) the determination of modern actors to ignore Geneva Conventions, and (b) the tech level of the RU/UA war, I'm not sure medevac is still a thing.
- Animats 2y ago> I'm not sure medevac is still a thing. Not the way it was for US troops from Vietnam to Afghanistan. Getting injured people out of the combat zone is much tougher. The combat zone is deeper. The first kilometer is now about as tough as it was before helicopters. Doing something major for a patient in the "golden hour" after injury is often not possible.[1] [1] https://journals.lww.com/journalacs/fulltext/2023/08000/putting_medical_boots_on_the_ground__lessons_from.31.aspx https://journals.lww.com/journalacs/fulltext/2023/08000/putt...
- KineticLensman 2y agoYes. Western ops in Afghanistan and Iraq - where we had total airspace domination - exhibited a best case view of medevac - all the way up to mobile operating theatres in Chinooks flying to the point of need. A full-on high intensity conflict between peer adversaries would be nothing like this.
- _carbyau_ 2y agoI am always amazed by the sheer ego of the "Geneva conventions" or any other "rules of war". Maybe I don't understand how the mentality works but for me, once you are at the point you are killing people - and killing them in the thousands - you are already either crazily desperate and/or have a complete loss of empathy for your opposition. Once you are in this alien mindset, why would you pay attention to any "rules" that might limit your murderous psychopathy?!? And this worries me. Seeing the world increasingly brace itself for war I fear there will be someone who thinks COVID was a great trial run for a bioweapon. And that is my simple unimaginative first grab at horror. I am sure smarter minds than me can think up worse.
- aebtebeten 2y ago> why would you pay attention to any "rules" that might limit your murderous psychopathy The theory is, that as war is just a continuation of peace "by other means", one should not start wars without having an idea of the various ways in which one might end them, and (as the NSDP discovered in 1945) it's a whole lot easier to end them if you haven't been doing war crimes (or "war crimes"; if you intend to end a war short of genocide*, de jure or de facto doesn't really matter) during them. (yes, I think we both agree that it'd be better to have a period instead of "without" after "one should not start wars", but if one allows for the existence of hawks, is it not better that they have some limits?) Which part do you consider sheer ego? The distinction between combatants and non-combatants, or the inclusion of medical personnel among the non-combatants? * compare Goebbels' Freudian slip in the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sportpalast_speech https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sportpalast_speech
- _carbyau_ 2y agoThe sheer ego is in the idea that all wars are started by gentlemen or aristocrats with options and we should have rules to incentivise them away from the risky inhumane options to the plain inhumane ones. Or that once a war is started the "idea of the various ways in which one might end them" actually holds up in reality after the enemy get their vote. I honestly tell you that if someone invaded my country in the manner of Russia with indiscriminate killing and bombardment of cities literally threatening the survival of those I care about then I will not give a toss what any convention says - what good does obeying a rule someone made up if I/my-loved-ones am/are dead? And at that point, bio/nuke/any-weapons become an option - the rules be damned. I very much know that I shouldn't be trusted with such calls.
- jajko 2y agoIf 1 good thing will come out of this russian war is the firm realization globally that russia is a solid dictatorship still/again actively opposing democracy anywhere in the world, with absolutely 0 regard for its own population and generally being very, very far from typical western values on which they frown as subpar, weak and a threat. There was some solid naivity not only in EU in past few decades, merkel et al completely ignored warnings from baltic members or Poland that russia can't be trusted yet. Current german leadership still doesn't treat this as their top urgency, they naively hope russians will get bored or scared from human losses and do just tiny glacial moves. This won't ever happen, just look at WWII, they still have the same mentality. They have to literally run out of equipment to stop at this point, they won't run out of men, not a country of 150 millions of which many are barely literate and fed propaganda every day.
- baud147258 2y ago> solid naivity not only in EU in past few decades I think there were some naïveté on the US side of thing, just like both were naive on how mainland China would turn to democracy as it opened to outside trade and industry
- ricdl 2y agoHindsight as they say, is 20/20
- Animats 2y agoYes. It wasn't inevitable that Russia would take this route. There were a few years of freedom, but with a broken economy. Then the era of the oligarchs. That didn't work out too well either. So now there's a strongman. That it would be a strongman who wants to go back to the era of the tsars was unexpected.
- phone8675309 2y agoI wouldn't call it naivete on the US side - most people with a functioning brain weren't snowed by that. However, the money men who make theirs on the backs of success OR failure trumpeted that it was a new dawn for democracy and capitalism in China because it was in their best interests to do so despite what centuries of history and decades of dialog told everybody who would listen.
- llm_trw 2y agoThere were not trenches in WWII. It was a war of maneuver from start to finish, which is why it was so much more destructive than WWI. >Russia supposedly lost 40,000 soldiers in Ukraine last month alone Do not believe Ukrainian numbers any more than you believe Russian numbers. One thing we have learned from this war is that a core of genocidal right wing nationalists makes you country extremely difficult to defeat. With the current recruitment crisis in the West I wouldn't be surprised if we don't see a push from the agencies to make future generations more right wing.
- ChrisMarshallNY 2y ago> There were not trenches in WWII. Not WWI-style, but I think there were a number of trenches. For example, Fortress Europe (Germany's efforts to secure Europe), consisted of a number of Maginot Line-style entrenchments and tunnel complexes. I think that the Eastern Front also had a lot of that stuff. I believe that the Ukraine War is now featuring trenches, and I know that the Ethiopia/Eritrea War featured classic WWI-style trench warfare. WWII was real bad, and was one of the first modern wars to claim more civilian lives, than military. I think that's sort of become a standard feature of most wars, these days; even the small ones. I'm currently trying to figure out how my father[0] got a Silver Star, in Belgium, in WWII. He never told us, and the St. Louis fire destroyed his main records. It affected him badly. I think he fought in a similar fashion to this story. He was in mechanized artillery, but saw plenty of bad stuff, and was wounded twice. [0] https://cmarshall.com/miscellaneous/MikeMarshall.htm https://cmarshall.com/miscellaneous/MikeMarshall.htm
- ricktdotorg 2y agothat was a cool life your dad lived! hard, but he saw a lot and i'm sure became a better person because of that hardship. from eagle scout to omaha beach to CIA to idi amin-adjacent; wow! thank you for sharing. i enjoyed reading a little bit about your dad's exploits. /salute to Mike Marshall.
- levinb 2y agoRe your father; wow, what a life. Thanks for documenting that for us. My grandfather became a Navy navigator, B25s I think, right as the war ended. Chased hurricanes in the Pacific. I was the only person in the family to ever get much out of him about it in the last years before he passed. Even in peacetime operations, he watched many colleagues die in storms, fog, and from accidents. I think everyone who served then saw how arbitrary death could be, and how the entire service was designed to operate around the necessary assumption that lives would vanish for nothing - and that everything else had to keep humming along. Provides a very different perspective than the modern era.
- Tade0 2y ago> Poland and Latvia are planning to send back Ukrainian males who dodged the draft there. That's inaccurate - Poland at least declared that it will cooperate with Ukrainian authorities in this matter should they decide to recall their men. So far the only thing that happened in this direction is that the Ukrainian consulate in Poland stopped providing services for adult Ukrainian men.
- harkain 2y ago> Sweden and Finland never stopped having a draft Just for anyone interested: Sweden actually stopped conscription in 2010, switching to a fully volunteer-based professional force. After the Russian invasion of Ukraine in 2014, opinions began to change and conscription was reintroduced in 2017. The number of conscripts per year is much lower than it used to be (~5K last year compared to ~27K in 1997), but is planned to increase to ~10K/year by the early 2030's.
- ajuc 2y ago> Russia is currently spending over 7% of GDP on its military. The EU averages around 1.5%. GDP of Russia was about 2 trillion USD in 2023. GDP of EU was about 18 trillion USD. 1.5% of EU GDP is still double the russian military budget.
- euroderf 2y agoBut is there an accurate PPP-type measure for military spending worldwide ?
- matthewaveryusa 2y agoMost certainly, but not for the public to see (although we all know relatively where different countries are.) I recently read kill chain which is jarringly accurate for a 4 year old book, and it goes through what you're indirectly alluding to: US military ppp is not only too high, but the 'kill-chain' is too slow.
- voiceblue 2y ago> within living memory. People who are in their 90s: “Guess I’ll just die then.”