18 ms·
The DOD had two "better-than-Hubble" space telescopes just sitting around.
- pavel_lishin 14y agoCan someone explain how two telescopes meant to focus on relatively close targets, without any cameras inside, are "better" than a Hubble? What metric are they using?
- sp332 14y agoThe lenses are just as big but they have a moveable secondary, which gives them better focus and 100x field-of-view compared to Hubble. http://www.washingtonpost.com/national/health-science/nasa-gets-two-military-spy-telescopes-for-astronomy/2012/06/04/gJQAsT6UDV_print.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/national/health-science/nasa-g...
- unreal37 14y ago"With a Hubble here you could see a dime sitting on top of the Washington Monument." And these are better than that. And the DOD doesn't need them.
- sp332 14y agoThe maximum resolving power of a satellite with a 2.4m (8 foot) lens, at 650 km (400 miles) orbit, is 10 cm (4 inches). The Hubble is in a circular orbit so I don't see how it can do better than that. http://everything2.com/title/Spy+satellites+can%2527t+read+your+license+plate http://everything2.com/title/Spy+satellites+can%2527t+read+y... Spy satellites often use highly-elliptical orbits to swoop closer, say 320 km (200 miles) for part of their orbit. edit OK I might have found an answer actually. Using multiple exposures from different angles, you can resolve an object as if you had a lens that spans the entire angle. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aperture_synthesis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aperture_synthesis I'm sure the movable secondary lens helps with this :) I'd heard of this technique used by ground-based radio telescopes before, and according to Wikipedia, the ability to do this within the visible spectrum has become possible only recently.
- pavel_lishin 14y agoEvery time I read about this, I instantly wonder whether this means that I can turn my crappy consumer camera into a spy device. We have windows that span about fifty feet in the office, and a hotel across the street; if someone left the complimentary bible in the window open to a random page, could I combine multiple exposures into an image detailed enough to read the text?
- sp332 14y agoNot using that technique, since it requires that you measure the phase of the incoming light. But there are some super-resolution techniques that might double a noisy digital sensor's performance. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Super-resolution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Super-resolution Try the ClearCam iPhone app.
- smackfu 14y agoKind of a bummer that ClearCam is apparently abandon-ware now, yet still up in the store for $2.
- sp332 14y agoOh, maybe HD Camera? http://itunes.apple.com/us/app/hd-camera-13mega/id455960193?mt=8 http://itunes.apple.com/us/app/hd-camera-13mega/id455960193?... I don't have an iPhone so I can't try it :(
- beambot 14y agoI assume the NRO telescopes had their instrumentation removed before gifting the optics to NASA, yes? Or were they really just "blank casings"? Either way, it's kinda freaky to think that there are such powerful monitoring devices in space...
- sp332 14y agoSince they were never launched, and (according to NASA) the satellite itself is the part that takes the longest to build, it's plausible that the instrumentation was never installed before the mission was scrapped for whatever reason.
- Zaak 14y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mentor_(satellite) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mentor_(satellite) 100+ meter diameter radio telescopes pointed at the earth. That's the same size as the largest steerable ground-based radio telescopes. Makes you wonder what they can hear.
- planetguy 14y agoThe "Which headline will give us the most pageviews by exciting moral outrage in our potential readership?" metric.
- sp332 14y agoI think SpaceX should take one. Throw maybe $10k of off-the-shelf parts in there, add some comms, and you have the best proof-of-concept and advertising ever.
- pavel_lishin 14y agoI think Facebook should buy one. I'm tired of hearing about nebulous data-mining aggregate privacy concerns; I want to be afraid of Facebook literally watching me, damnit!
- gonzo 14y agoGoogle owns a satellite service, (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Keyhole,_Inc http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Keyhole,_Inc) why shouldn't Facebook and Apple?
- dasmoth 14y agoKeyhole wrote the predecessor to the Google Earth software, but while it's a great name for an imagery company, they don't run satellites themselves. Google did pay for a half share in GeoEye-1 (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GeoEye-1 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GeoEye-1) and have exclusive commercial access.
- Tooluka 14y agoFacebook should buy one and burn it down over their headquarters. Just because they can :) .
- Mvandenbergh 14y agoSpaceX doesn't have the capability to launch this kind of satellite and won't for another few years until they get their Falcon Heavy launch system working.
- petegrif 14y agoGood god.
- mladenkovacevic 14y agoIt's interesting to think about how far advanced their equipment is now if this is their equivalent of "spare change" to throw at NASA
- bradleyland 14y agoFrom Contact: > "First rule in government spending: why build one when you can have two at twice the price?" - Hadden For once, art has under-imitated the hyperbole that is our life.
- moron 14y agoLumping it all under "government spending" is burying the lede a bit.
- bradleyland 14y agoI'm not sure I follow. I'm not telling a story here, just pointing out a funny tie in from a piece of pop culture. There's probably something more subtle that I'm missing, because I'm dense like that :)
- zandorg 14y agoAnd that pop culture was written by Carl Sagan, who is no stranger to this subject!
- MiguelHudnandez 14y agoBuilding two is hardly twice the cost. The design and development work has surely got to be more costly than fabrication, assembly and installation. Not that this nit-pick changes the nature of the discussion.
- excuse-me 14y agoThat's the point of the joke. In the real world you can build two bits of identical high tech equipment for little more than the cost of one - in military procurement the normal rational rules of supply and demand don't apply
- bradleyland 14y ago1) My comment wasn't meant as a serious critique of the situation 2) Econ isn't my forte anyway C) You have my permission to stop being pedantic and laugh D) I switched from numbers to letters, lest anyone develop the impression I am at all serious :) When you make bullet lists like this, you can throw in a smiley emoticon and it will confuse at least a handful of people 6) Hope this made your Monday a little brighter :)
- jakejake 14y agoIt would be interesting to see the two telescopes (or whatever device) that replaced these two. There's probably a very limited number of groups that would be able to use this technology in a way that was agreeable to the military.
- sakai 14y agoAsked whether anyone at NASA was popping champagne, the agency’s head of science, John Grunsfeld, answered, “We never pop champagne here; our budgets are too tight.” Austerity notwithstanding, that's really a sad sign of the times (and state of science funding in the US).
- jerf 14y agoThere's no austerity. I don't even know where you'd get the idea there's some sort of austerity in the US. NASA's problems lie elsewhere, mostly in the form of having a boss (Congress) who demands that they spend their money in mind-bogglingly inefficient ways, and then adds further inefficiencies by continuously jerking them around. Giving them more money won't solve this problem.
- gizmo 14y agoYep, austerity. See decrease in govt expenditures over time (http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/04/27/the-secret-of-our-non-success/ http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/04/27/the-secret-of-ou...). Also, NASA isn't mind-bogglingly inefficient. Citation needed, I guess. Besides, their budget is a puny 0.5% of the federal budget, compared to 1% back in 1990. The return on science spending is, as far as I know, typically pretty good in the US. The NASA budget outline can be found here: http://www.nasa.gov/news/budget/index.html http://www.nasa.gov/news/budget/index.html. And the complete 2012 budget report: http://www.nasa.gov/pdf/516675main_NASAFY12_Budget_Estimates-508.pdf http://www.nasa.gov/pdf/516675main_NASAFY12_Budget_Estimates... It all looks pretty reasonable to me.
- adventureful 14y agoTotal government spending in the US doubled from 1998 to 2011. While the US economy only increased by 1/3, and population only increased by roughly 15%. Why would you need twice the government spending for 15% more people? We had 270 million people in 1998, and now have 312x million. Total government expenditures (local + state + federal) in the US came to over $7 trillion in 2011 (counting the deficit spending). Out of an economy that is close to $16 trillion. Under absolutely no scenario is that austerity, it's the greatest spending binge in world history. To put it another way, our government system spends more than the combined economies of Germany + France + Britain are worth. If that's austerity, then the 1990s were hyper austerity by comparison. Somehow we managed to have a government that was more functional then than the one we have now.
- Jabbles 14y agoWould they be any use as ground-based telescopes?
- geuis 14y agoProbably not. The design of telescopes face different environmental challenges between Earth-based and space. On Earth, we have the benefits of accessibility but the downside of peering through the atmosphere. In space, there's no atmosphere but you have to deal with inaccessibility, extreme cold, micrometeorites and space debris, and radiation. Also take into consideration mirror size. On Earth, we have built (and are building) giant mirrors many meters across. In relation, the mirrors on Hubble and other space telescopes are rather small in comparison. Its really the lack of atmosphere that provides most of the advantage to space-based installations.
- gonzo 14y agowell that, and the CCDs love cold.
- jimhefferon 14y agoI worked on the Hubble (my dad was systems manager for Perkin-Elmer's bid), on the ball bearings. They are literally the ones that were rejected from the spy sats. The spy sats bought a bunch of ball bearings (these might be a foot in diameter and are speced to be extremely low noise at low turn rates). They tested them all (using a phono needle resting on the outside of the bearing while it was slowly turned). The ones that made the least noise went in the sat while the others were sealed in a plastic bag and put on a shelf in the clean room. I was told that when Hubble came along, the US no longer had the capability to make those (I'm not sure if that was true). In any event the ones that went in Hubble were the least noisy of the ones that had sat on the shelf. My summer job was (largely) testing to see which was the best. A cool job.
- dmlorenzetti 14y agoIn a product design class, the prof asked us to draw the distribution of resistors in a bag of, say, 5-ohm resistors, bought from a local electronics shop. It turned out that a normal distribution centered at 5 ohms was not quite right. It was a normal distribution, but with a deep notch taken out right at 5 ohms. All the resistors that tested to very close tolerance had been bagged separately, and sold at a higher price. (The context was why you might want to put, say, four 5-ohn resistors in series, rather than just use one nominal 20-ohm resistor.)
- juiceandjuice 14y agoI hope your product design class covered error propagation, because one 1% 20 ohm resistor would still be cheaper and more precise than 4 5% 5 ohm resistors.
- JshWright 14y agoI think his point was that it would be better assuming you used the same "grade" resistor.
- klodolph 14y agoBut four 5%-tolerance 5-ohm resistors could be chosen to add up to almost exactly 20 ohms, but a 20-ohm resistor would never be 20 ohms due to the notch. In the old days, it might have been cheaper than the more accurate resistors. These days, high precision resistors are relatively inexpensive.
- gouranga 14y agoThat's what you now know about. They are probably quite primitive devices if they let you find out about them. From real experience, the commercial and public space programmes are positively infantile compared to the black project space programmes.
- guelo 14y ago> From real experience Did you just violate your security clearance?
- gouranga 14y agoNo. I worked on unrelated things that blow up and kill people (no more!). Lots of black holes with big obvious scary pieces missing. Drawing assumptions doesn't violate clearance. Speculation is allowed. Some things don't fit into normal technology progression.
- waterlesscloud 14y agoAnd part of the little psy-war game that no doubt played a role in the decision to turn these over to nasa instead of letting them rust in some warehouse.
- jpxxx 14y agoSadly, I'd imagine all those super toys are designed to point at Earth - different design requirements than for looking outwards.
- nobleach 14y agoThat's what has me curious. The Hubble isn't designed to point at earth and would be of little use if we tried. Why does the US Military have telescopes that are on par with Hubble? Are they looking out into space as well? Why would they do that?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- ams6110 14y agoAre drones replacing space telescopes? This sounds like a reasonable speculation to me. Drones would be orders of magnitude cheaper, more manuverable, expendable, not as subject to being obscured by cloudcover, able to survey many places at once or swarm over a wide area, etc.
- jackpirate 14y agoBut we can't fly drones over China and Russia like we can Pakistan
- jessriedel 14y agoYou can if you make them small enough. I don't think any of us know what the classified state of the art is.
- blhack 14y agoUh...look at this thing: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nnR8fDW3Ilo http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nnR8fDW3Ilo This is made by Festo, a German industrial automation company. They did this for a trade show. It was "for fun". Imagine what we're capable of building for spying on China. I doubt we're having problems with it.
- excuse-me 14y agoAnd satellite surveillance is less useful these days. 1960s - we have photographed Soviet SAM sites around Moscow. We know where to avoid to send bombers in. 2010 - we have photographed a semiconductor fab in china. We don't know what they are making but we can tell where the fab is to an inch.
- jackpirate 14y agoYou can tell a lot about what they're making based on its proximity to other resources, the shape of the buildings, the schedule of supply deliveries, etc. Intelligence analysts are a crafty bunch.
- codezero 14y agoBefore we get all excited about this, I want to point out that part of the costs of any space mission, which are included in the budget figures you usually see are both the launch and the maintenance and post-launch operations for commanding the satellite and analyzing the data. Just having two satellites sitting about isn't really that shocking, nor is the fact that the DOD has technology that is more advanced than Hubble, Hubble was originally funded in the 70s, slated for a launch in 1983, and finally launched in 1990.
- johngalt 14y agoMore proof that defense gets a lake of cash for every bucket that NASA gets. Optically I'd think looking down at a relatively bright earth would be a much different task than looking up at a very dark universe. Also field of view is much less important.
- Fizzadar 14y agoIf only the worlds combined military budgets could be directed towards a global space (/science) program. Less investment in death and more in the future of human kind.
- DividesByZero 14y agoIt's more difficult to profit from scientific exploration than it is from weapons and the maintenance contracts that come with them. The military industrial complex has a stranglehold due to simple market forces.
- jcnnghm 14y agoNASA has a fully functional copy of Hubble "sitting around" at Goddard Space Flight Center as well. If something goes wrong in space, fabrication of replacement components and the training of the astronauts that will fix it does not occur in space. It is invaluable to have an exact duplicate on the ground for this reason. Interestingly, the total 2010 US Space budget was $64.6B. The entire rest of the world combined spent only $22.5B. NASA's 2010 budget was $18.7B. Many programs that people think are NASA projects are actually defense projects. For example, the GPS system is not included in NASA's budget, it's spearheaded by the Air Force Space Command, and comes out of the Defense budget. Chances are the main satellites that these are duplicates for have been decommissioned, so these are no longer needed. I would guess they are actually two distinct but similar designs, and not two copies of the same design. I would assume NASA already determined that the risk of these satellites failing and NASA being incapable of fixing them is outweighed by the desire to have higher powered telescopes in space. My mother has worked in the thermal blanket lab at Goddard for years. Several years ago, she got one of the engineers working on the James Webb Space Telescope to take her and I on a tour of the clean room where they are fabricating one of the core components, the micro-shutter array. The micro-shutter array is an array of 65,536 shutters on an area about the size of a postage stamp. We got to go into the clean room and see the entire process. It is very similar to the process used to fabricate semiconductors, and I think they were operating at about the 60nm level. The idea of the micro-shutter array is that each shutter can be independently operated to shut out interfering light sources, so that the telescope can look much further back in space and time for deep fields. These should be spectacular. Instead of imaging the entire shutter area as the Hubble does, JWST will be able to close all but one micro-shutter which should allow very long exposure times, and the ability to see extremely distant objects. More on the array at http://www.jwst.nasa.gov/microshutters.html http://www.jwst.nasa.gov/microshutters.html. Edit: Also, the Hubble is huge. It is a cylinder with a diameter of perhaps 15ft and a height of roughly 40ft. Pictures really don't do it justice, I had no appreciation for the size until I saw it. I know my mother did some of the thermal blanket fabrication (think the tin-foil looking stuff on the outside of spacecraft) for Servicing Mission 4.
- excuse-me 14y agoThere isn't a fully functional flight spare of Hubble sitting in bubble wrap waiting to fly. There is a mockup of the Hubble structure and there were flight spares for SOME optical components and some parts of instruments. The mockup is to train astronauts on instrument swap outs. Many of the instruments and the current solar panels aren't even Nasa builds The "better than hubble" telescopes are old keyhole era spy sats, this is the design Hubble was originaly based on. It's also partly the reason for the original Hubble screw-up. The contracts for Hubble went to companies that had experience building 2.4m mirror space telescopes (nod+wink). But security walls in the suppliers meant that the people who had build these spy sats didn't work on Hubble or pass on their knowledge - then oversight of the Hubble build process was hampered by security concerns that meant NASA QC engineers never got to see the mirror being built. A few other points. The cost of the Hubble 'airframe' was a small part of the space telescope cost, compared to the launch and service missions, the building of the STSci and the 1000 of professors, postdocs, researchers and students that it funded. Just the cost of storing it in a clean room for 3years after Challenger was estimated at more than raw commercial build cost. The JWST isn't just a better Hubble it's a completely different concept - actually designed as a scientific instrument rather than compromised by being a spy sat design built to justify the Shuttle launch - as HST was.
- Natsu 14y agoI wouldn't complain too loudly. Otherwise, next time, they'll quietly dispose of such things, rather than risk public backlash.
- InclinedPlane 14y ago"Better-than-Hubble" is flat out wrong here, the only correct interpretation is "with larger apertures than Hubble", but there is so much more to a telescope, especially one in Hubble's class. A spysat is optimized for taking only exposures lasting a fraction of a second, for example, whereas Hubble is optimized for taking exposures that last many minutes at a time, with guidance that keeps Hubble pointed in the same direction to sub-pixel precision. Let's take a moment to walk down the aisle with the label "Current Hubble Science Instruments". First, we come upon WFC 3, a 4k x 4k high quantum efficiency CCD imager with a wide field of view, spectral coverage from the near-UV through visible spectrum and with 63 different narrow and wide-band filters. Oh, and with a set of grisms and prisms for taking spectra, and with a separate 1k x 1k IR sensor with 17 of its own filters. Next up is NICMOS, an IR imager and spectrometer with a spectral range of 0.8 to 2.4 microns, this instrument alone places Hubble into the rankings as one of the top 3 or 4 most productive and capable Infrared telescopes in history all on its lonesome. Then there is STIS, a 3 CCD sensor with coverage from far-UV through near-IR wavelengths which is capable of taking high resolution spectra for 500 separate points simultaneously while also taking a full frame image, this instrument alone is responsible for much of all of the astronomical observations in the UV-range throughout all of history. And there are several other equally impressive instruments I have not mentioned. The point is, none of these instruments or capabilities are going to be on a spysat. And they make up the vast majority of the value of a space based observatory. If a space telescope was nothing more than a big mirror, some guidance, and an imager then we could save billions of dollars, but they are so much more than that.
- ars 14y agoDid you read the actual article? It's just the telescope (the mirror) - it doesn't include the cameras.
- InclinedPlane 14y agoThat's my point. These aren't "better than Hubble" telescopes, they're just optical assemblies. That's more than nothing but it's hundreds and hundreds of millions of dollars of equipment short of a Hubble equivalent observatory.
- DigitalSea 14y agoNow I see why the government is in so much debt. Building something they already had two of, saving potentially billions in research & development creating another telescope. This is ridiculous. What else have they got two of just "sitting around"
- gonzo 14y agobecause the KH-12s didn't work as designed?
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoI've just worked it out. Years ago I went to one of my first programming conferences , sat in the same room as GvR and Stroustrop and had one of those what am I doing here moments. But it was an amazing revelation - hundreds of people way smarter than me all of whom chatting where the side conversations and corridor chats are always more interesting and informed than the set talks HN is just like the corridor outside the worlds biggest tech conference. The door bangs open and someone is talking about space and suddenly you realise there are actual rocket scie fists standing in ear shot. I used to want to write scintillating blog posts and bump my karma score. But that happens in the main hall. Not in the corridors and I think I am happier here, like a young guy open mouthed that brilliant people actually like explaining stuff and it's beginning to make some sense...
- hexagonal 14y agoYou're already wiser than Walter Bright. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3061222 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3061222
- Kelliot 14y ago'Second, if the DOD didn't need these two birds, which are both better than any civilian telescope, what do they have?' This line worries me the most, hubbles pictures of things thousands of light years away are spectacular. Imagine what a better scope could so pointed at earth 300 miles below!
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- pvarangot 14y agoNot too long ago there was this diplomatic incident in my country where the US military forgot to mention they where bringing (or tried to smuggle in) a briefcase with some GPS equipment and other stuff. They where discovered when their plane was inspected and the briefcase was not in their customs declaration. They where forced to open the briefcase, which was less than 1 meter (3 feet) wide. They agreed only if the briefcase was opened under a roof, alluding it was standard procedure because of spy satellites looking at its content. That was when I realised that spy satellites currently have ridiculous amounts of optical resolution I had never though equipment could achieve in orbit.
- excuse-me 14y agoThey can't. The diffraction limit of a 2.4m (HST/KH) mirror from their orbit is around 6cm, the practical limit with an atmosphere is around 10cm. However the photo-recon interpreter guys are amazing. They can look at a 1m resolution image of a vehicle made up of half-a-dozen blurred pixels and say "that's the new mkII whatever - you can see the extended wheelbase from the length of the shadow"
- rdtsc 14y agoCan you fly lower? You'd have to fly faster but wouldn't that be one way to increase resolution?
- excuse-me 14y agoYes - for a few minutes before you burn up! 300km is about the lowest practical orbit with any reasonable lifetime, it depends on the size of the satelite and the solar weather
- dasmoth 14y agoYou can improve things a little by flying in an elliptical orbit. Some of the KH8s have listed orbits with perigees as low as 125km -- but they're not that low for the whole orbit. They also didn't have particularly long mission durations (weeks, not years) and may have used their attached Agena stages for some reboosting. Still impressive, though!
- rsanchez1 14y agoYes, in case you didn't know, the DoD operates a secret space program completely independent of NASA and with an unknown budget.
- mironathetin 14y agoDefine "better". If these telescopes have to be equipped with instruments, what is left? The optical system? Thats nothing compared to the instruments. Better in terms of optical system would mean an order of magnitude at least. This is obsolete, more or less, because ground based instruments come closer to a proper correction of atmospheric turbulences. They are cheaper to build and cheaper to run. The next generation optical space telescope may be a very long baseline interferometer. This cannot be build on earth. Infrared is also a space domain. Thats why Herschel, ISO, Spitzer and James W. Webb are space telescopes.