3 ms·
> Won't run OSX. It's not a competitor unless you plan running Windows 8 on your Macbook which is not very smart. Am I to understand that you think Apple lapto
by dpark 14y ago
> Won't run OSX. It's not a competitor unless you plan running Windows 8 on your Macbook which is not very smart.
Am I to understand that you think Apple laptops and Windows laptops are not in competition with each other? Seriously?
- rbanffy 14y agoIt depends on what you intend to run. If you want to run either Visual Studio or Xcode, they are completely different machines. Both machines will run Office and a browser if that's your thing.
- dpark 14y agoIf you define the market narrowly enough, you could argue that the Honda Civic is not in competition with the Toyota Corolla, but you're just creating a self-serving definition at that point. The vast majority of consumers will never install or run either Visual Studio or Xcode. To most consumers, Windows laptops are in direct competition with Apple laptops, because they are both general purpose computing devices that will do what the consumer needs.
- rbanffy 14y agoDoes the Honda Civic compete with a Maybach? For most users, Windows laptops, Apple laptops, Chromebooks and iPads are in direct competition. All four do Facebook just fine.
- dpark 14y ago> Does the Honda Civic compete with a Maybach? Are you saying that Windows is the Civic while Apple is the Maybach (or vice versa)? This doesn't make a lot of sense, because Apple laptop vs Windows laptop is a comparison of similar products. Civic vs Maybach is a comparison between a low-end consumer product and an extreme luxury item. Exactly 63 Maybachs were sold in the US during all of 2010. So no, I don't think Honda would consider Maybach to be in competition with the Civic, and I assume Maybach is probably not especially concerned with the Civic, either. > For most users, Windows laptops, Apple laptops, Chromebooks and iPads are in direct competition. All four do Facebook just fine. Is this supposed be an argument in favor of your claim that Apple laptops and Windows laptops are not in competition? Because it seems like you're arguing with yourself at this point.
- rbanffy 14y agoSo, we agree the Civic and the Maybach, despite being both automobiles that run on internal combustion engines, have very different feature sets. Now let's consider this Asus and a Macbook Air. One is built to run Windows 8, Office, Windows games and become a tablet, the other is built to run OSX, Xcode, iWork, iLife. Both run browsers, but that's the same as saying both the Honda and the Maybach use asphalt roads. You can make a Macbook Air run Windows, but you cannot make an Asus ultrabook run OSX. They are machines built for different purposes.
- dpark 14y agoSure, and we no doubt agree that the iPhone and Dell's Copper Servers, despite both having ARM processors, have very different feature sets. I don't think that either of us would consider that a relevant comparison, though. Now let us look at the Asus and a Macbook Air. Both are general-purpose computers. The Asus is not made for Office or Windows games. The Air is not made to run Xcode or iWork or iLife. The software is actually written for the devices, not the other way around. The computers themselves are both made to be general purpose computing devices. They are intended for browsing the web, and writing documents, and watching video, and sending email, and maybe writing programs, and editing video, and any number of other tasks. They are both created for the same core purpose, though: to be a primary computing device for the consumer. What you're doing is looking at the Civic and saying it has dual overhead cams instead of a single overhead cam system in the Corolla, and therefore the two aren't in competition. Products don't have to identical to be in competition. Consumer products are rarely true commodities. To the typical user, Apple laptops and Microsoft laptops very much are in competition. They can get everything they need done on a Mac or a Windows machine, including developing software. Both Apple and Microsoft know this.