3 ms·
Apple needs to differentiate itself, and they have chosen privacy as a way to do that, which I'm all for. The headlines around Microsoft's AI efforts have large
by al_borland 2y ago
Apple needs to differentiate itself, and they have chosen privacy as a way to do that, which I'm all for. The headlines around Microsoft's AI efforts have largely been a nightmare, with a ton of bad press. If the press around Apple's AI is all about how over the top they went with security and privacy, that will likely make people feel a little better about using it.
I'm not a big user of OpenAI's stuff, but if I was going to use any of it, I'd rather use it through Apple's anonymizing layer than going directly to OpenAI.
- gpm 2y agoI actually thought one notable thing in the presentation was that they spent all this time talking about their new private cloud compute architecture. And then showed that they have a prompt asking if you're ok sending the data to OpenAI. Presumably because despite OpenAI promising not to use your data (a promise apple relayed) OpenAI didn't buy into this new architecture.
- al_borland 2y agoThank you for mentioning this. I thought I was going crazy, because I heard this too, but kept seeing comment after comment on other sites asking if a person could choose not to use OpenAI, or that it was happening magically in the background. The way I heard it, the user was in control. I think this goes back to what Steve said in 2010. https://youtube.com/watch?v=Ij-jlF98SzA https://youtube.com/watch?v=Ij-jlF98SzA And yes, while the data might not be linked to the user and striped of sensitive data, I could see people not wanting something very personal things to go to OpenAI, even if there should be no link. For example, I wouldn’t want any of my pictures going to OpenAI unless I specifically say it is OK for a given image.
- rekoil 2y agoI was under the impression that the OpenAI integrations were more about content generation and correction than the Apple Intelligence-driven personal stuff.
- manmal 2y agoI’m not sure but I thought I saw it mentioned that OpenAI is still allowed to train on the data received from Apple customers.
- FumblingBear 2y agoActually the opposite. They’re explicitly not allowed to.
- brookst 2y agoDifferent features. OpenAI provides the chatbot interface we all know. The PCC cloud serves all of the other integrated AI features like notification prioritization, summarization, semantic search, etc. At least when those can’t be run on device.