4 ms·

I thought it was underwhelming. The fact that integration with ChatGPT is not seamless pours cold water over it. Siri will seek your permission each time before

I thought it was underwhelming. The fact that integration with ChatGPT is not seamless pours cold water over it. Siri will seek your permission each time before passing the question to ChatGPT. I can avoid that step by using ChatGPT directly.

notdarkyet 2y ago
There are a lot of people who do not want their phone seamlessly hooked into anything OpenAI touches. Choice is important
tr3ntg 2y ago
I think this is good. For folks like you, that will always be an option. For people that have yet to touch ChatGPT and "still don't know how to access AI" (I've heard this sentiment from many people that couldn't care less about it all) it's a perfect balance. Siri will operate as you expect, until one day it prompts you to pass your question over to ChatGPT. You can opt out or give it a try. I do agree that the extra tap is a bummer for anyone that wanted ChatGPT baked into the OS, even easier to access than it is in the ChatGPT app.
kaba0 2y ago
But it has an on-device LLM plus an in-cloud LLM, that can handle many types of queries, so why would it be bad?
TaylorAlexander 2y ago
Personally I feel less and less comfortable giving OpenAI access to my private data tho, so I’m really happy there’s a divide. As you said, if you really just need ChatGPT for something you can open that app. But I’m happy the default isn’t to send all Apple users requests to OpenAI all the time.
nerdjon 2y ago
On the opposite side, it not being seamless is entirely why I would actually trust using the new Siri with any sensitive data. I am not entirely sure I will ever actually allow it to connect to ChatGPT for privacy reasons, but having the option when it can't be handled another way is nice. I imagine this is more a stopgap until more and more of this can happen locally anyways. Especially since it sounds like Siri determins when it should reach out.

notdarkyet 2y ago

There are a lot of people who do not want their phone seamlessly hooked into anything OpenAI touches. Choice is important

tr3ntg 2y ago

I think this is good. For folks like you, that will always be an option. For people that have yet to touch ChatGPT and "still don't know how to access AI" (I've heard this sentiment from many people that couldn't care less about it all) it's a perfect balance. Siri will operate as you expect, until one day it prompts you to pass your question over to ChatGPT. You can opt out or give it a try. I do agree that the extra tap is a bummer for anyone that wanted ChatGPT baked into the OS, even easier to access than it is in the ChatGPT app.

kaba0 2y ago

But it has an on-device LLM plus an in-cloud LLM, that can handle many types of queries, so why would it be bad?

TaylorAlexander 2y ago

Personally I feel less and less comfortable giving OpenAI access to my private data tho, so I’m really happy there’s a divide. As you said, if you really just need ChatGPT for something you can open that app. But I’m happy the default isn’t to send all Apple users requests to OpenAI all the time.

nerdjon 2y ago

On the opposite side, it not being seamless is entirely why I would actually trust using the new Siri with any sensitive data. I am not entirely sure I will ever actually allow it to connect to ChatGPT for privacy reasons, but having the option when it can't be handled another way is nice. I imagine this is more a stopgap until more and more of this can happen locally anyways. Especially since it sounds like Siri determins when it should reach out.