2 ms·
> More recently, its use has been promoted for environmental reasons. promoted ... in the USofA and in Brazil. I'm in neither country and I questioned then an
by defrost 2y ago
> More recently, its use has been promoted for environmental reasons.
promoted ... in the USofA and in Brazil.
I'm in neither country and I questioned then and still question today whether it was ever actually effectively a green solution or just an industry with influential lobbyists.
The dependancy on large amounts of land was known from early on, it was written about in the 1970's.
There's a good argument that ethanol is a net positive for GHG production: https://afdc.energy.gov/vehicles/flexible-fuel-emissions https://afdc.energy.gov/vehicles/flexible-fuel-emissions
but the counter argument is in practice GHG emissions continue to increase when there's an excuse to avoid travelling less in smaller cars and not develop better city transport infrastructure.
All that aside; h2odragon has simply pivoted away from the paper bag V plastic claim onto another "those darn environmentals say one thing then another" talking point.
They're not uniform, they're not the same people decades apart, and often the statements people quote come from idustry think tanks and don't represent what the general zeitgeist of scientists of particular periods considered as their breadth of thought.
- eesmith 2y agoI agree with all of your comments. I did not mean to imply that "promote" mean "was effective." I believe, with low confidence, that ethanol's net positive for GHG production wasn't realized until the 1990s, due to an increase in corn yields from what was possible in the 1970s and the oil crisis.