3 ms·
Except that having multiple valid definitions of something that is foundational to a discipline is a bit unsettling.
by graemep 2y ago
Except that having multiple valid definitions of something that is foundational to a discipline is a bit unsettling.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> having multiple valid definitions of something that is foundational to a discipline It’s foundational to one branch. Almost all of finance, for instance, doesn’t bother with utility functions. One can similarly complain that mathematicians have different rules for parallel lines depending on geometry. Like, sure. But if you’re in the field it makes perfect sense why parallel lines don’t intersect in a Euclidean space but do in a curved one. Given utility functions are literally ordered sets of preferences, it strikes me as trivial that there would be a multitude of them. (If this bothers you, don’t look up Gödel.) The economists who deal with utility functions are more or less applied game theoreticians. Some people have a problem with game theory and statistics because they’re unpure. Like, sure. Fine. I also have a small stable of useless opinions, e.g. raisins are trash fruit. That doesn’t mean raisins are themselves useless; it’s just my opinion that’s adding zero value in a world where raisins do.
- graemep 2y ago> Almost all of finance, for instance, doesn’t bother with utility functions. You need the concept of utility and some (reasonable) assumptions about the shape of the utility curve to derive CAPM - at least the way I was taught it and there may be an alternative I do not know of? I do not think there being a multitude of utility curves is a problem. It seems to be there is a lack of a clear concept. I do not think that your analogy with maths works. Maths is is more abstract and should change with different sets of axioms. Economics is supposed to be based on observations of the real world.