4 ms·
Broadly I agree about Mars vs the moon. Two wrinkles, not really disagreements: > Low gravity is a problem It might be, we don't know. This ignorance is also
by ben_w 2y ago
Broadly I agree about Mars vs the moon.
Two wrinkles, not really disagreements:
> Low gravity is a problem
It might be, we don't know. This ignorance is also a problem.
> Mars's atmosphere is the worst of both worlds. It's of absolutely no use to build a breathable atmosphere.
Not directly, but it does mean (1) leaks can be represurised from outside, and (2) is a source of carbon, useful for plants and ISRU fuel manufacturing.
The fuel point is useful for any initial colonisation creation, but by the time we seriously consider a million people we should be able to build a mass driver… which works better on the airless moon than the thin atmosphere of Mars.
> I firmly believe humanity's future is in orbitals (aka an incremental Dyson Swarm). This approach has so much more going for it, except perhaps the added protection of living deep underground on a planet or Moon.
I understand the appeal, but I strongly suspect they only seem good due to the failure modes having not yet been deeply investigated.
- me_me_me 2y ago>> Low gravity is a problem >It might be, we don't know. This ignorance is also a problem. We did a study of prolonged stay on ISS - lower bone density, muscle loss, problems with eyes. Our bodies evolved and adapted to live in 9.8m/s2 its not a leap of faith to think there will be issues in 3.7
- ben_w 2y ago> We did a study of prolonged stay on ISS - lower bone density, muscle loss, problems with eyes Indeed, but the ISS is also zero gee. > its not a leap of faith to think there will be issues in 3.7 I'm not suggesting it requires a leap of faith, merely that it is currently untested. Until we try, either hypothesis is plausible.
- jgord 2y agoI t actually seems strange that the next 'step' isnt a spinning space science station, with simulated gravity. Is there an obvious reason this would not work ?
- arrowsmith 2y agoWouldn't it have to spin really fast to get workable "gravity" on board? Then if it's spinning really fast, how do people get on or off?
- jgord 2y agoWas assuming they do a kind of ferris wheel with center and 3 or 4 spokes to start, maybe 200m diameter, and gradually fill out the rim with modular units maintaining balance, and center of mass at central dock ?
- admissionsguy 2y agoThrough the middle
- vessenes 2y agoIf the loop is large, you don’t have to move too fast. Fairground rides spin fast enough to exceed 1g with little kids in them, and those rides are usually not wider than 10m, often less. Speed here is distance around the circumference, so twice the radius, half the turning speed. I don’t have the numbers in front of me, but generally it’s considered that the issue is more that if you’re standing on a spinning cylinder, you might have weird balance issues due to speed differences between head and feet. Also, you have to remember you don’t have gravity, so as you intuit, entry and exit are trickier. Two broad ideas for entry/exit: do it at the center where the physical position is stable, then “spin up” some how, or alternately get up to external speed and lock on to something that you then elevator through the surface.