4 ms·
> My high school driver’s ed textbook asserted that a head on collision between two cars each going 50 miles an hour had the same effect on each as running into
by WalterBright 2y ago
> My high school driver’s ed textbook asserted that a head on collision between two cars each going 50 miles an hour had the same effect on each as running into a brick wall at 100 miles an hour.
I've intuitively believed this to be true for a long time. But the article made me think about it, and the textbook is quite wrong.
It's a test similar to if you're in a train in motion, and you drop a ball in the aisle, does it fall towards the front or the back of the train?
- didgeoridoo 2y agoI’m still confused about why the textbook is wrong. Is there something about the energy or momentum scaling differently in the brick wall case vs. the head-on collision case?
- fmajid 2y agoPerhaps the fact the wall is to a first approximation an unmovable object, the oncoming car isn't.
- WalterBright 2y agoConsider hitting a brick wall. The energy of the moving car is all dissipated in the collision, leaving a mangled wreck. With two cars hitting head on, the energy to be dissipated is twice as much, but it is equally distributed to each car, and so the energy dissipated in each car is the same as if each independently hit a brick wall. In other words, conservation of energy.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- gruez 2y ago>Consider hitting a brick wall. The energy of the moving car is all dissipated in the collision, leaving a mangled wreck. That might be correct but it comes off as a smart-ass answer unless the course covered deformation, which I suspect it did not given it was a high school course.
- acdha 2y agoI’m pretty sure the basics were covered in AP Physics when I took it but have no idea what the curriculum was like when he was in high school. That said, I agree that it’s generally a smart ass answer but a) teenage boy and b) I would be incredibly unsurprised to learn that a child of academic economists who goes on to get a PhD might be the kind of insufferable high school student who reads ahead and makes sure everyone knows about it.
- WalterBright 2y agoA perfectly elastic collision would still be the same - the energy is still conserved and divided equally between the two cars. Assuming the cars are of equal mass. If not, the heavier one will drive the other car backwards faster, and the energy will not be divided equally between them. But the sum will remain the same.
- jhp123 2y agothe head on collision has zero net momentum while the car hitting a wall has significant net momentum which must carry into a shockwave through the wall, which also absorbs some of the energy of the crash. This makes the wall collision significantly gentler at the same speed.
- reidacdc 2y agoI think yes? Kinetic energy scales as velocity squared, so a car at 100 MPH has 4x the energy of a car at 50 MPH. But in the 50 MPH scenario there are two cars, so the total energy dissipated in the 50 MPH head-on collision is half that of the 100 MPH brick-wall collision. In the brick-wall case, presumably all the energy is available to demolish the one car, but in the head-on case, the energy is spread out demolishing two cars. Impact force is maybe trickier, it depends on the acceleration, but if the two 50 MPH cars end up with zero momentum, then they have 50 MPH of delta-v each over some collision time. The single car of course has 100 MPH of delta-v. If the collision times are the same (arguably a reasonable approximation if the head-on is a highly symmetric), then the impact force in the head-on case is half that of the brick-wall case.
- HPsquared 2y agoAlthough the single car at 100 MPH has twice the initial kinetic energy of two cars at 50 MPH, not all of this gets dissipated in the collision. After the collision in the "single car 100 mph hitting an identical stationary car" case, we have both cars moving at 50 MPH in the same direction, NOT two stationary cars. Half the original kinetic energy is still in the form of kinetic energy, in other words. The 100MPH car does not experience a velocity change of 100 MPH, but only 50 MPH - the same as if it had hit an oncoming car at 50MPH.
- sseagull 2y agoAlong with the other answers: Imagine the two cars hitting each other in a (unrealistically) symmetric, mirror image way. Where they hit is a plane that neither car crosses. That is your immovable wall, it’s just both cars experience it.
- ScottBurson 2y agoWalter's answer is good, but here's another. When the two cars collide, it's possible to imagine that they are exact mirror images of each other and hit exactly head-on, so that a large sheet of paper hung vertically at exactly the collision point would not be torn. Of course we know that wouldn't literally happen in the real world, but it is possible. This thought experiment demonstrates that the collision is equivalent to hitting a brick wall at 50mph, not 100. Alternatively, imagine one car is parked (in neutral, with its brake off) and the other car hits it at 100. The center of mass of the two cars is moving at 50 both before and after the collision (conservation of momentum); after it, the cars will be moving at that average speed. The impact will again be equivalent to the original scenario. The original claim probably results from a conflation of these two scenarios. ETA: So what student drivers should be told is that hitting another car head-on is like hitting a brick wall at the same speed. For this to be exactly true, the momenta (mass * velocity) of the two vehicles have to be equal and opposite, but to communicate the general idea, I don't think we have to go into that.
- didgeoridoo 2y agoPlease help me understand where my intuition (or maybe my assumptions/simplifications) is wrong. Assume two perfectly elastic cars. When they collide at 50mph, each car will bounce backwards at 50mph (due to conservation of momentum), representing a change in velocity of 100mph — identical to the brick wall case. I feel that introducing deformation or other energy dissipation to the equation kind of takes it out of the “high school physics” realm, right? What else am I missing? Edit: ah I see, the car will bounce off the brick wall at 100mph as well, resulting in a 200mph change in velocity. I guess you could explain it then that the effect of the impact is felt entirely in one car in the brick wall case, and it’s spread out over two cars in the head-on case?
- sseagull 2y ago> When they collide at 50mph, each car will bounce backwards at 50mph This is the incorrect part. They would both go to zero velocity/momentum. Momentum is a vector quantity, so has a direction and magnitude. Two identical cars with the same speed going opposite directions would have the same magnitude of momentum, but opposite sign. After colliding, their sum would be zero. If you watch billiards you would see kinda the same thing going on. Edit: completely messed this up. Other comments are more correct
- tbrownaw 2y agoStick an imaginary sheet of paper between the two cars. If they're perfect mirrors of eachother hitting perfectly head-on, it will be undisturbed just like if you stuck it to an indestructable wall that one of the cars was run into.
- dools 2y agoIf you do that then you're considering 2 collisions, ie. you're considering 2 cars, both hitting a brick wall at 50mph. The assumption therefore is that the force felt by the wall is not great enough to overcome the inertia of the wall, therefore each vehicle does not exert any force on the opposing vehicle. It's the same as saying that if you drive 2 cars into the same wall at 50mph the force felt by each driver is not the same as driving a single car into a wall at 100mph. That is true obviously. However if there isn't a perfectly immovable "piece of paper" in between the 2 cars, then you can't just ignore the force acting on each car, from the other car. F = ma Also, Newton's 3rd law states that forces generate equal and opposite forces. So if you punch a wall, you are exerting a force on the wall, and the wall is exerting an equal and opposing force on your hand. When car A hits car B going 50mph, the force is the mass of the car times the acceleration required to stop the car (ie. deceleration, acceleration in the opposite direction). However that force is matched by a force in the other direction PLUS the force of each car attempting to decelerate the other car. You have 2 forces for each car: the force felt by car A as car B tries to accelerate it in the direction car B was travelling, and the force felt by car B from car A that opposes that force, and vice versa. So if we assume the cars are driving in an Elon Musk hyperloop tunnel under Vegas in a straight line then yeah, the forces felt by the drivers in each vehicle is the same for a car driving 100mph into a "brick wall" (or more accurately a big pile of bricks the same size and shape as a car with equivalent mass).
- indigo0086 2y agoPeak Hackernews reply thread
- dools 2y agoWell that’s what you get when Milton Friedman’s son comes out as being as confidently wrong about physics as his dad was about economics
- hn_throwaway_99 2y agoTo be honest, I don't think any of these "sheet of paper" answers are good explanations. Stationary objects can still have varying forces applied to them. I think it's simpler just to directly look at the equation for kinetic energy: KE = 1/2mv^2. In other words, kinetic energy is directly proportional to the mass, and proportional to the square of the velocity. Also, let's assume that in both cases the car comes to a complete stop at the wall, or both cars come to a complete stop where they collide (a perfectly inelastic collision), so that all of that kinetic energy is essentially released as heat (i.e. the cars crush). In the case of 2 cars hitting each other, if the cars both have equal mass X and are traveling at velocity Y, then the total kinetic energy dissipated in the collision is 2 * 1/2XY^2, but then of course for each car it's just 1/2XY^2. In the case of a car hitting a wall but traveling twice as fast, the kinetic energy dissipated in the collision is 1/2X(2Y)^2, or 2XY^2 - so that's essentially 4 times what the car experienced in the head on collision (of course in the real world the wall would dissipate some of the heat, but in this "spherical cow" example I think it's OK to assume the vast majority of the crushing occurs in the car).
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- LegionMammal978 2y ago> the car comes to a complete stop at the wall It's this assumption that causes the entire discrepancy. For a wall to be truly immovable, the ground must exert a great force into the wall to keep it in place, which goes into the car. But if the wall isn't anchored very securely (or backed by the ground), then the car will bust through it and continue moving forward. In the limiting case where the wall isn't attached to the ground at all, both the car and wall move at 50 mph following the collision. The dissipated kinetic energy comes out the same as in the car/car case.
- photochemsyn 2y agoProbably the textbook author was thinking of velocities, but kinetic energy is 1/2 mv^2, going as the square of the velocity. If we imagine superballs with perfectly elastic collisions, then yes, the two balls would have the same relative velocity to each other after the collision (100 mph for perfect head-on) as the single 100 mph ball after hitting the wall. If we consider the force experienced by a passenger in any car, then you also have to take into account the crumple zone (larger in modern cars). Here we imagine the cars have perfectly inelastic collisions coming to a complete rest as they crumple, first calculating the KE in each scenario: 100 mph (44 m/s) into a brick wall -> KE = 1/2 m (44)^2 = m(968) 2 50 mph (22 m/s) into each other -> KE = 2 * 1/2 m (22)^2 = m(484) Thus the car in the brick wall scenario has to absorb twice the energy of the overall collision in the two-car scenario, in which each car only has to absorb 1/4 of the brick wall total KE (assuming the brick wall absorbs nothing, maybe a giant granite boulder is a better model). Thus in modern cars it's not just the KE but the crumple zone that reduces the force felt by the two-car passengers. (Incidentally I used Chat GPT4 to help sort this out and it tried to claim that (x/2)^2 == (x^2)/2 so use with care - it did catch the error but only when I said double check that calculation in a step-by-step manner. User beware!)
- roarcher 2y agoIt falls straight down relative to the train, regardless of the train's speed. If you're standing next to the stationary brick wall, it falls straight down relative to the wall. To me this is a clear demonstration that motion is relative, therefore the two collision scenarios ARE equivalent. Imagine that the two cars are in space. Are they both moving at 50MPH towards each other? Or is one stationary and one moving at 100MPH, like the wall scenario? Or perhaps moving the same direction, but one at 100MPH and the other at 200MPH, about to catch up to the first one? The answer is that it doesn't matter, because the only difference between these scenarios is the reference frame. The collision is the same in all of them.
- _dark_matter_ 2y agoOne big difference is the car has a crumple zone to absorb some impact, but the brick wall does not.
- roarcher 2y agoIn reality yes, but I assume the thought experiment is meant to take place in Spherical Cow Land where all colliding objects can be considered the same. I'm also not sure how relevant the crumple zones were when this was first thought up, as cars haven't always had them.
- AlexandrB 2y agoThe simple fix to that is have the car hitting another, stationary car at 100mph. It's still a horrendous collision despite the 2x crumple zones.
- s1artibartfast 2y agoboth are crumpling, but the line between the cars does not change and acts as a wall. Imagine compressing two springs in a line vs one against a wall.
- hn_throwaway_99 2y agoThis is absolutely incorrect. I could repeat myself but see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40628932 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40628932.
- TheOtherHobbes 2y agoCar/car is identical to car/wall if the cars have identical masses and there's no residual velocity after the collision. The momentum vectors cancel out, but the relative velocity is identical and the total kinetic energy is the same. The damage isn't the same because car/car has twice the crumple zone. More of the energy will be dissipated through elastic deformation, so the deceleration will be slightly gentler. (Although almost certainly still fatal.) That aside - the driver's ed book is basically saying that head-ons are much more dangerous and deadly than most people understand, even at low speeds. All of which is true.
- ajkjk 2y agoThe total kinetic energy is not the same, it scales as v^2?
- WalterBright 2y agoThe kinetic energy is relative to the reference frame being used.
- s1artibartfast 2y agoexpanding on Walters response, each car has the same kinetic energy as if it hit a wall at 50mph. Together, they have the energy of two cars at 50 each hitting a wall, and this energy is split between the two cars. If somehow ALL of the kinetic energy was absorbed only by one car , it still wouldnt be equal to 100mph, do the the square. Together, two cars traveling at 50mph have the same energy as one car traveling at 70mph. The only case when two objects colliding at 50mph is like 100mph is if the final reference frame is still traveling at 50mph. a Car going 50pmh hitting a train going 50mph would be like the car hitting a wall at 100mph (net velocity change of 100mph.
- LegionMammal978 2y agoIf a car hit an actual brick wall, it would likely be closer to your 50 mph final reference frame scenario, with the wrecked car and wall remnants both moving near that speed. It would take some good anchoring for the ground to exert enough force on the wall to keep it immovable.
- pulvinar 2y agoWhat's missing from the problem statement is how elastic/inelastic the collision is. If it's 100% elastic, both cars will experience a 100 MPH change in velocity (to 50 MPH in the opposite direction). But yes, the textbook is wrong. Unless the brick wall (and only the wall) is 100% inelastic so it "catches" the 100 MPH car, slowing it to 0. Quite unrealistic.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- protocolture 2y agoMy physics teacher was really good with this stuff. He put things into context. This example is not true, however, this example is true enough to teach you xyz. He suggested that part of continuing on to higher forms of physics study meant that a lot of these older concepts had to be beaten out of you, and his preference was largely not to rely/solidify them as concepts so it wouldnt take as much energy to remove them later. We were encouraged to find ways to break these examples too, if we could, which was rare, and on some occasions he would stay back to demonstrate how they were false after class.
- WalterBright 2y agoI used to believe that a baseball kept accelerating after it left my hand in a throw. It was a major reorienting for me to learn differently.
- gravescale 2y agoIn the relativistic inertial frame of the thrown baseball, it'll not be accelerating, at first. But it will be accelerating at 9.81m/s² (along with the Earth's surface, and hopefully you) after it lands and is just sitting there. The inertial frame will have continued along its original geodesic into the ground, though (or rather, the frame is only instantaneously defined at the moment of the release, but the ball would have followed that path). If you can convince the ball to continue to not-accelerate indefinitely, NASA or Vought International may have a job for you. In the Newtonian inertial frame of the "stationary" Earth, it accelerates downwards at 9.81m/s² until it hits the floor and comes to a stop and is no longer accelerating ("gravity", which is a thing here, and the normal force now summing to zero). This is fairly academic for sporting goods, as if working with these two frames results in substantially different outcomes for you or your ball, your day is probably going badly, or at least fairly energetically, and baseball isn't your priority right now.
- randerson 2y agoI wonder how this old scenario would play out in 2024. Now that most cars have Automatic Emergency Braking, 2 cars driving toward each other should be spared a serious collision. But AEB generally won't brake for stationary objects, so the wall scenario would still be as bad as ever. (More likely, the answer would be that it's now a software problem, so nobody really knows.)
- EasyMark 2y agoMaybe if 2024 car models but most cars on the road do not have automatic emergency braking currently, not by a long shot
- arkis22 2y agoReminds me of my high school physics final. A difficult class, one of the few that curved grades. Maybe half the multiple choice questions were phrased to trick you into giving a wrong answer that broke newtons 3rd law.
- LegionMammal978 2y agoAssuming equal mass and an inelastic collision, the missing information here is, "How well is the wall fixed to the ground?" If the wall is immovable and perfectly fixed to the ground, then the car/wall collision will indeed have a greater effect than the car/car collision. But if the wall's connection to the ground is negligibly weak (e.g., an actual brick wall), then after the collision, both the car wreckage and destroyed wall will continue forwards at 50 mph, until some other force slows them down. In this case, the effect (change in kinetic energy) is the same as the car/car collision, not counting the impact of crumple zones. In the former case, the kinetic energy of the car relative to the ground is relevant only because the ground is exerting a massive force to keep the wall in place.
- cycomanic 2y agoI think what the drivers ed textbook is asserting that the acceleration experienced in both collisions is equivalent. I think the assumption that it is not mentioned is that in the running into a brick wall is an inelastic collision, while the two car's hitting each other is an elastic collision. So in one case the acceleration is from 100 -> 0 km/h while the other is from +50 -> -50 km/h. I have no idea if that is true in reality, but to me that seems like the most likely explanation. I agree, without this the statement does not make sense. As a side note on the article, I'm not sure why David Friedman associates being open to being questioned by their children with libertarian economics (with circumstantial evidence at best)? I, myself and many of my friends have been educated in a similar way and our parents were definitely not libertarian economists. In fact I would argue that this philosophy is routed in anti-authoritarian education, which originates in communities more associated with anarchistic/socialist political/economical leanings.
- adammarples 2y agoIf you run into a car head on at 50mph you're going to decelerate to 0mph, not -50mph and go flying backwards like a rubber ball. If you happen to be a rubber ball, then you will, but you also would on hitting a static wall too.
- hackthemack 2y agoMythbusters did an episode on "car vs car" vs "car vs wall" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r8E5dUnLmh4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r8E5dUnLmh4
- tzs 2y ago> It's a test similar to if you're in a train in motion, and you drop a ball in the aisle, does it fall towards the front or the back of the train? Once people are done with that they might be amused by try this one: • You are on a stationary bus, holding a helium balloon on a string. The balloon is floating directly above you. The bus starts accelerating forward. Does the balloon: 1. Move toward the front of the bus relative to you, 2. Continue to float directly above you, or 3. Move toward the back of the bus relative to you.
- skybrian 2y agoThe problem with the original statement is that a wall is not a car. If a car at 100 miles per hour hits a stopped car, let’s assume they will both move forward together at about 50 miles per hour. If the kinetic energy for a car at 50 miles per hour is 1x, at 100 miles per hour, it’s 4x. After the collision, the total kinetic energy is 2x, and the other 2x was absorbed by damaging both cars. That’s different from hitting a wall where all the kinetic energy goes into damaging the car. The damage from hitting the parked car matches the head-on collision, which starts with 2x kinetic energy and afterwards, it’s zero. (If they are stopped afterwards.) If the cars were rigid, they would bounce off and go in opposite directions, like balls on a pool table. That would be very bad for anyone inside. Crumple zones absorb energy for good reasons. I expect that guard rails absorb more energy than a brick wall?