7 ms·
> I think mathematically this could be the missing link in evolution, where random gene modifications are just not probable enough to drive evolution. 3 billion
by ben_w 2y ago
> I think mathematically this could be the missing link in evolution, where random gene modifications are just not probable enough to drive evolution. 3 billion DNA pairs cannot evolve randomly, there is not enough time and matter in the universe to randomly try successful generations of life forms
This suggests you have not tried writing a simulated evolution based optimiser.
They're quite easy to write, the hard part is what you mean by a "fitness function" (which doesn't matter for nature, it just is whatever it is).
Such algorithms are also more than fast enough — remember that for the first 3 billion years we only had single-celled life, and that can reproduce in 20 minutes, so we had potentially 79 trillion generations (edit because "78.84 trillion" would be overselling the precision) before the first multicellular life. You get good results faster than that.
The number of base pairs is also just a misleading statistic. For example: each of XXX, XXY, XYY, and Downs are found in around 0.1 of human births, each of which gets an extra copy of a chromosome. These specific changes may not be too good for us, but this kind of sudden massive increase is also found in some plants without negative repercussions.
> However, bioelectric might be a much much more straightforward and fast way of driving evolution instead of randomly mutating DNA.
I have no reason to expect bioelectric processes described in this article to be able to direct useful effects on the genome, for the same reasons I think it unlikely your own brain could by sheer willpower turn you into a werewolf.
Wrong layer of abstraction.
- thaumasiotes 2y ago> For example: each of XXX, XXY, XYY, and Downs are found in around 0.1 of human births, each of which gets an extra copy of a chromosome. These specific changes may not be too good for us, but this kind of sudden massive increase is also found in some plants without negative repercussions. A couple notes: Downs is unlike the other defects you mentioned in that it severely impairs the patient while the various extra-sex-chromosome disorders vary from sterility through minor impairment to what basically amounts to behavioral differences. Downs is unusual, though, in that most extra chromosomes make the fetus nonviable. As far as trisomy disorders go in general, Downs is unusually benign. Plants are better known for increasing their -ploidy (number of sets of chromosomes) than the count of an individual chromosome. A triploid human, with three copies of every chromosome, would be hopelessly nonviable. Plants are different. Really different.
- briffid 2y agoI learnt that evolution is random mutations of genes + natural selection (selecting the successful random trials). If you have 10^14 generations on 3 billion years, always use up the mass of the Earth, 10^28g, that is 10^40 cells, so you have 10^54 cells randomly trying the best permutation of DNA, that's suprisingly few to balance the vast amount of possible permutations. 4^100000 being 10^60205
- mkl 2y agoEvolution doesn't find "best", it finds "slightly better" and "not disastrously worse" repeatedly.
- briffid 2y agoSure, but my question is what does evolution try? If it is full random, then it will TRY much better and much worse mutations as well, so will go back and forth, and will take a lot of time. If it is not fully random, e.g. it is not not able to try big changes, then what is the thing that actually determines what is "feasible", BEFORE trying it out.
- jjk166 2y agoIt will try much better and much worse, those that are much better will produce a lot of offspring while those that are a lot worse will produce few to none, and so in the next generation there will be a lot more starting from "much better" than "much worse."
- ben_w 2y agoIIRC, the rate is somewhat dynamic. That said, my experiments in silico say that what matters most is the pressure from the utility function, more so than the rate of mutation. So if some organism is in an environment where only a few mutations help, then evolution progresses slowly; and when most possible changes are improvements, then evolution progresses faster. Both environments can happen even without any dynamic change to the rate of mutations themselves.
- 2y ago