4 ms·
Researcher suggests that gravity can exist without mass
- guender 2y ago[dead]
- monocasa 2y agoHaven't we known about massless particles warping spacetime for a while, hence how kugelblitzes work? It's not just mass that warps spacetime, but mass or energy.
- mr_mitm 2y agoWe've known for over one hundred years that all forms of energy influence the curvature of spacetime: mass, radiation, momentum, pressure. The source of the gravitational field is literally called the energy-stress-tensor. This, however, is about topological defects.
- monocasa 2y agoIt concludes with > "But it is the first proof that gravity can exist without mass."
- Valgrim 2y agoHere's what I understand of this, correct me if I'm wrong. If 1 kg of matter and 1 kg of antimatter annihilate each other, their entire mass is converted into photons, which are massless. If said photons are entirely absorbed by a black hole, the mass of the black hole will increase by 2 kg, and so will the gravitational pull of the black hole. In that case, wouldn't it be safe to assume that photons, even if they're massless, create a gravitational field equivalent to their energy level?
- monocasa 2y agoYep https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kugelblitz_(astrophysics) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kugelblitz_(astrophysics)
- dustingetz 2y agoiiuc the photons need to be confined (e.g. by a mirror box) for the box-photon system to exhibit mass greater than the sum of its constitutents
- mitthrowaway2 2y agoWhat better box is there than a black hole event horizon?
- thfuran 2y agoYou can even theoretically make a black hole out of nothing but photons, though I don't think there's any plausible process that would ever put enough photons in one place to form a kugelblitz.
- mitthrowaway2 2y agoIs there a theoretical reason that a sufficiently-gigantic ultrafast pulse laser with a sufficiently-massive lens couldn't put enough photons at the focal point?
- ben_w 2y ago
- nico 2y agoIt was posted yesterday with a different title (the title of the paper about topological defects) In a way it’s the same concept as Einstein’s geodesics. And it doesn’t mean that reality is different, just that we can model it in another way that might make the mathematical models and predictions easier to work with I’m all for having better models, but they don’t need to all explain everything in the universe It’s ok if we have one model for each different phenomenon we want to describe, even if they don’t agree with each other outside their intended scope
- poopsmithe 2y agoThis isn't news to me. We've known for awhile that light circles around black holes.
- monadINtop 2y agoSo it's an absolute moonshot that posits that all observed discrepencies of galactic rotation curves is actually due to a coincidental and highly unlikely distribution of topological defects (that are not consistent with the full field equations) that have not been observed, and also fail to explain every other feature of dark matter at various different scales. nice. Its fine for a paper but doesn't really make sense as an article unless you are more interested in ad revenue from titles like "we don't need mass for gravity" than the ideas being presented. These science article websites live solely off of people who aren't equipped with the prerequisite background to actually critically parse the ideas that are being presented. This is probably the reason why everyone ~online~ (and not in departments) loved string theory two decades ago, and virulently hates it today, and also think that dark matter "is just a bunch of BS from the physics establishment" and that things like MOND or this are even remote competitors to the general consensus (which is basically just - we have no idea but we probably just need an extension to the standard model / quantum gravity at somepoint in the far future).
- nightowl_games 2y ago> not in departments I don't think it's valid to lay the blame for the failure of string theory on the media. There are plenty of academics who pushed string theory for years and years and years. The media and public got tired of hearing about it far before they got tired of researching it.
- monadINtop 2y agoyeah, and they pushed it as a theory of everything (which I think they had justification to believe for the first few decades [~] to get funding. So I also blame the entire economic system that academia is unfortunately embedded in. [~] It still isn't neccesarily ruled out, it's just incredibly unfeasible at the moment as a physical theory since it is currently very poorly understood and like centuries away from experimental tests (as is any GUT or QG theory i.e. this is not a criticism of string theory but basically any theory past the standard model). However it is extremely interesting currently as a subject in mathematics, and it has deep connections with current research in algebraic geometry and the geometric langlands program.
- RegW 2y ago> ... a thin outer layer of negative mass ... Brilliant! My antigravity boots are nearly here.
- ChrisArchitect 2y ago[dupe] Discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40610133 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40610133
- belter 2y ago"The binding of cosmological structures by massless topological defects (oup.com)" - 36 comments: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40620856 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40620856 "Gravity Without Mass: UAH Study Proposes Alternative to Dark Matter" - 43 comments: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40610133 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40610133