2 ms·
> With, like, 80+% of inbound SMTP traffic coming from Google, Microsoft Just do a challenge-response on incoming mail from new addresses on Gmail and Outlook.
by Animats 2y ago
> With, like, 80+% of inbound SMTP traffic coming from Google, Microsoft
Just do a challenge-response on incoming mail from new addresses on Gmail and Outlook. Send an auto-reply telling them they can get their mail through if they copy a code in the reply. That will kill most spams from those sources.
- mistrial9 2y agoisn't this essentially handing police powers to a duopoly of USA commercial corporations?
- Wingy 2y agoI think they mean that gmail/outlook are highly abused and you can reduce spam by demanding a challenge response from new addresses on those domains when they email your domain.
- Animats 2y agoYes. I'm talking about spam originating from Gmail and Outlook, not received by them.
- immibis 2y agoWe already did that.
- ttul 2y agoA few years ago, I would have said that the challenge-response approach was doomed to failure, but in light of the concentration of spam and phishing emanating from Gmail accounts, Gmail addresses are the new IP addresses. How long before someone starts distributing a Gmail address blocklist?
- johnklos 2y agoThat's a good idea in theory, but considering IPv4 addresses cost money and Gmail addresses are infinite for practical purposes, that wouldn't work. I don't know that I've ever seen the same Gmail address used more than once for spam and phishing. It'd be nice if Google did something about this. Until they do, I tell everyone that uses Google for email that they have to accept that they're hosting with one of the biggest sources of spam on the Internet that, as far as I'm aware, does absolutely nothing when spam from them is forwarded to their abuse addresses.
- PreInternet01 2y ago> Send an auto-reply telling them they can get their mail through if they copy a code in the reply Never auto-reply to any email ever. You're only making the spam problem worse. (Plus, if you think there are not actual persons behind most Outlook/Gmail spam, I've got news for you. They will reply, and beg you for another chance, sometimes in highly emotional terms). "550 5.7.1 The recipient has set a policy that prohibits email from this sender" at the SMTP level is the only way forward here.