4 ms·
First NIH said it does: https://www.nih.gov/news-events/nih-research-matters/viagra-associated-reduced-risk-alzheimers-disease https://www.nih.gov/news-events/
by WalterBright 2y ago
First NIH said it does:
https://www.nih.gov/news-events/nih-research-matters/viagra-associated-reduced-risk-alzheimers-disease https://www.nih.gov/news-events/nih-research-matters/viagra-...
Then it doesn't:
https://www.nih.gov/news-events/news-releases/nih-dream-study-finds-viagra-cialis-do-not-reduce-risk-alzheimer-s-related-dementias https://www.nih.gov/news-events/news-releases/nih-dream-stud...
Then it does:
https://www.ox.ac.uk/news/2024-06-07-sildenafil-viagra-improves-brain-blood-flow-and-could-help-prevent-dementia https://www.ox.ac.uk/news/2024-06-07-sildenafil-viagra-impro...
Who knows what to believe.
- throwup238 2y agoI’ve always been taught that “a wank a day keeps the doctor away” so I believe it.
- hulitu 2y agoI guess it depends on the Doctor. /s
- pcloadletter_ 2y agoMaybe these studies are particularly hard
- CydeWeys 2y agoThey certainly are hard, because dementia is something that develops over years if not decades. Anytime it takes that long to do a single iteration of your experiment, it's hard!
- jfoster 2y agoDoes it need to be, though? You can survey healthy but senior populations about their habits, and then over the following years track what happens. If medical records were public, the answers could even be in those for any medicines that are prescription based. You could then make statements like "A% of patients who took drug B within C years did/didn't develop disease D".
- CydeWeys 2y agoThat's not a randomized controlled trial though. You might find a correlation, but you couldn't actually establish causation, or eliminate hidden variables.
- hombre_fatal 2y agoWe have to get over this false meme where people think RCTs prove causation and the rest prove correlation. An RCT doesn’t prove causation, it only might observe another correlation that contributes to our causal inferences based on the convergence of evidence. We don’t have RCTs for most things that you take for granted.
- CydeWeys 2y agoWell, an observational-only study proves even less.
- lisper 2y agoAnd any time the object of your study is also a treatment for ED it gets extra hard. ;-)
- K0balt 2y agoThat seems a reasonable assumption.
- debo_ 2y agoDon't worry, I caught your innuendo.
- henriquez 2y agoIt’s hard science. I take viagra every day and have only become moderately demented, so obviously it’s working.
- ezekiel68 2y ago> Who knows what to believe. This may be a sincere statement, but I'm not sure it's a helpful one. What data do we have? A 2:1 advantage in published studies that it does help. Since there is no such thing in science as absolute proof of anything, these are pretty good odds. Certainly more work will be done in the future to try to replicate the results and figure out the one negative outcome. But until then, we cannot say that the evidence is in any way "equal" on both sides.
- zerocrates 2y agoThe first one is just a combination of some computer modeling guessing at possibly useful existing drugs and a look at the existing patient data showing that people who were on these seemed to have Alzheimer's less. It's very clear that it's just an initial step that doesn't actually show there's a benefit. The second is more of that same basic kind of research, but weighing in the opposite direction: it showed no association with Alzheimer's for people with a specific other condition who got these drugs vs. ones with the same condition that didn't (also they did some cell culture testing outside the body that didn't show any effect/improvement). This new one is an actual double-blind study giving people the drug. Equally important, it's not claiming an effect on Alzheimer's, but vascular dementia, a different form of dementia that's directly related to blood flow and therefore to Viagra's known effects. Of course it's still just really a marker for future research on if this is broadly useful.
- engine_y 2y agoMight be a 2:1 but we also have to take into account the level of evidence each study provides.
- HPsquared 2y agoStudies aren't conducted at random, it's not really valid to sample them as though they were. Major selection bias.
- deepfriedchokes 2y agoThis is like the supposed health benefits of drinking red wine. I don’t know if it’s true or not but it’s fun to find out.
- makeitdouble 2y ago> Who knows what to believe. Honest question: do we need to believe one or the other ? Or can we get away with "it depends" or "it works on some subjects and not on others"
- peutetre 2y agoAll I know for certain is there's no dementia in my pants.
- j45 2y agoCould be different for different folks
- hk1337 2y agoDifferent strokes for different folks?
- hk1337 2y agoMaybe they forgot what they said before?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- stoorafa 2y agoThat second study didn’t use as robust of methods as the first, and they each used observational data that benefit from advanced methods (propensity score analysis). With an RCT, the evidence is substantially increased. I’d conclude sildenafil reduces risk of age-associated cognitive decline