7 ms·
The binding of cosmological structures by massless topological defects
- purplerabbit 2y agoIs this saying that dark matter can be modeled well as defects in the topology of spacetime itself?
- Drunk_Engineer 2y agoIANAA, but this says we don't have to rely on with the notion of dark matter at all. The paper proposes a special type of singularity that apparently has all the properties of galactic rotation and bending light normally associated with dark matter.
- T-A 2y agoNo, the (hypothetical) topological defects mentioned in Section 7 of the article are configurations of (hypothetical) scalar fields (like the Higgs field, but with different equations of motion): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kibble%E2%80%93Zurek_mechanism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kibble%E2%80%93Zurek_mechanism Modeling dark matter as a scalar field is bog-standard stuff, what's unusual here is the way it's arranged.
- barfbagginus 2y agoTopological defects - also known as soliton solutions - are isolated solutions of PDEs that cannot be continuously deformed into the ordinary solutions. This is saying that the observed effects of DM could be explained as a bunch of enormous solitons in the gravitational field equations. Each soliton has no mass, but together they explain galaxy rotation curves and DM lensing. But there is a catch. The authors found a massless soliton in the poisson field equation for newtonian gravity. General relatively transforms into this equation in the limit when space is flat. But we don't know if that solution is still stable in spacetimes - like ours - that are curved by massive objects. In a curved space time being hit by relativistic particles and gravity waves, these spherical shells could wobble and collapse, fade away, or break apart. Proving this one way or another will be interesting work!
- T-A 2y ago> This is saying that the observed effects of DM could be explained as a bunch of enormous solitons in the gravitational field equations. From the abstract, first sentence, my emphasis: "Assuming spherical symmetry and weak field, it is shown that if one solves the Poisson equation or the Einstein field equations sourced by a topological defect, i.e. a singularity of a very specific form, the result is a localized gravitational field capable of driving flat rotation" In Section 7, the author has this to say about the topological defect: "although its origin is uncertain (despite being deemed stable in Section 3), there are scalar field solutions which can give rise to it (see Hosotani et al. 2002)" In short, this is not about "solitons in the gravitational field equations"; it's about topological defects in scalar field models. The author derives their gravitational potential in the weak field limit and shows that it has the the right shape to cause flat rotation curves. I agree with one thing you say: the author's claim of stability is unconvincing. Finding a time-independent solution, as he does in Section 3, shows that the configuration is static. To prove stability, you need to show that small perturbations of the static solution will shrink. The author's proposal is a set of "unresolvably closely spaced singular shells" (see paragraph under Eq. (8)). But as he notes under Eq. (4), there is no gravitational force inside a spherically symmetric shell. So what's keeping all these shells concentric? As far as I can see, nothing. If you give one of them an ever so small push, it will glide away from its concentric position until it collides with the containing and/or with the contained shell, whichever comes first. At the point(s) of collision, there is gravitational attraction (see paragraph under Eq. (8) again), so the colliding shells will stick together. Even if the hypothetical topological defects survive that (I wouldn't bet on it), they will then proceed together (because of momentum conservation) until they hit the next set of containing and contained shells, and so on. Each collision makes the whole thing less concentric and increases the gravitational attraction at the points of collision. That sure doesn't look stable to me.
- barfbagginus 2y agoIn my usage, a soliton and a topological defect are synonyms for certain isolated solutions to differential equations. Please replace soliton with topological defect in my statement above and see if it makes more sense. The idea is there are families of solutions to partial differential equations that are stable, but cannot not deform continuously into any of the "ordinary" solutions without leaving the set of solutions at some intermediate point of deformation. These outlying solutions are topologically isolated Islands in the solution space. We can think of them as disconnected families of non-standard solutions - solitons. We can also think about them as topological defects in the set of solutions. We ordinarily expect the solution set of a differential equation to form a path connected set including the trivial solution. If there is some region of solutions that is topologically cut off from the ordinary solutions, we call its solutions topological defects. But these are nothing more than the solutions that can't be smoothly deformed into the zero solution.
- zmgsabst 2y agoTangent, but: Kip Thorne once commented that black holes are “bigger across” than we’d expect from their circumference. Which I think is what those cusp-on-sheet models are showing. Does that create a topological defect? I ask because a circle around a cusp in a sheet will get “caught” on the infinite spike; and a circle not around the cusp will end up with weird deformations if it comes close. That suggests there’s something “topological” about such a cusp, akin to there being a hole.
- pdonis 2y ago> Kip Thorne once commented that black holes are “bigger across” than we’d expect from their circumference. Which I think is what those cusp-on-sheet models are showing. Does that create a topological defect? No. There are no topological defects in any of the standard black hole spacetimes.
- nyssos 2y ago> I ask because a circle around a cusp in a sheet will get “caught” on the infinite spike; and a circle not around the cusp will end up with weird deformations if it comes close. That suggests there’s something “topological” about such a cusp, akin to there being a hole. Your intuition is right, this is an example of a topological defect, but it's not directly related to circles having the "wrong" sizes. It's topological in that it's just a property of how your sheet is connected, and can't be changed by continuous deformations. Black holes are not topological defects in the same way, because they're not really "infinite spikes".
- ssijak 2y agoWhat does topological defect even mean really?
- _Microft 2y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Topological_defect https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Topological_defect
- nyssos 2y agoLoosely speaking, it's a structure that can't be continuously transformed away. For example, consider a (frictionless, non-dissipative etc.) fluid flowing in a circle around a given point: a vortex. Since this has net angular momentum, and a fluid moving uniformly in one direction doesn't, it's impossible for the vortex to dissipate. We can move it around, or split it up, or fuse it with other vortices, but we can't just smooth it out.
- simne 2y agoI think, most close point, to think of it like additional dimension. For example, imagine we live on 2D infinite plane, and once found out, that in some places, moving on for example for 1km, we see same shift as with moving linearly (to be more exact, by some arc or some polygonal line) by other route for 100km (really need much less to prove topological defect, just standard scientific 3-sigma difference from our model is enough), so this mean, we have crease on space-time topology (and possible, some sort of wormhole, or just holes on plane and controllable way to navigate/move from one hole to other and move between hole and our plane).
- simne 2y agoBTW when I said controllable way to navigate/move, I mean quasi-controllable, so we may not understand what happen, but our tech measure that we have moved IN OUR SPACE-TIME much less or much more than expected by our models, by means of some unknown magic.
- User23 2y agoI was speculating along these lines just a month ago[1]. Sadly I lack the training to take it anywhere formally, but it’s still pleasing to see my notion wasn’t entirely crazy. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40331470 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40331470
- ambicapter 2y agoThe structure in question is a “massless spherical shell”? I still don’t understand how that works.
- barfbagginus 2y agoYou define the density function of the shell using a direct Delta function and the derivative of a direct Delta function. That means that on the shelf the density doesn't take any real value. But we can formally integrate Delta functions and their derivatives. When we perform the mass integral we end up with the result m = 0. It's an artifact caused by allowing generalized functions as our density functions A problem is that we don't know how to physically interpret a distribution as a density function. Mass distributions caused by matter all have positive real valued functions as density functions. So if we have these structures in the universe, their cause is probably not physical matter! It would be as if god put his thumb on the scale, and his finger print indented a concentric series of shells where the mass density goes completely nonphysical.
- schoen 2y agoDid you mean Dirac delta function? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dirac_delta_function https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dirac_delta_function Maybe an autocorrect issue?
- barfbagginus 2y agoIt was a speech recognition issue! Yes, I'm talking about the dirac delta function.
- tbrownaw 2y agoYes, if your galaxy is embedded in an infinite series of infinitely thin spherical shells of the appropriate positive and negative masses spaced infinitely close together, then you can make the rotation curve be anything you want it to be without adding any overall net mass. I checked, and the publish date is not in fact the first of April.
- m_dupont 2y agoAgreed. This paper is pretty much pointless. Its extremely implausible, putting it generously, that such fine-tuned structures could even form. They mention at the end "this paper does not attempt to tackle the problem of structure formation" but that feels like a colossal understatement. I've studied physics myself, and I understand that sometimes people toy around with implausible theories solely for the sake of it but .... it seems like these peoples brainpower could be much better spent elsewhere.
- m_dupont 2y agoAlso, strictly speaking these aren't topological defects. They are massless spherical shells, i.e. a sphere embedded in 3d space and thus can be continuously deformed to a point by sending the radius to zero. Spheres are literally the second homotopy group and the homotopy group of flat space is zero. Q.E.D
- barfbagginus 2y agoThe sense in which they are defects is that on the shell, the density function is a distribution and takes no real value. Distributions are singularities/non-functions that we get when we take certain limits of ordinary functions, or solve certain differential equations with generalized functions. The distribution used works roughly as if we overlapped two equal positive and negative mass shells. But there are some extra details that ensure there is a net inward force for matter situated on the final shell. We'd have to actually work the math to really understand why that force appears, without hand waving.
- ChrisArchitect 2y ago[dupe] Discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40610133 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40610133