5 ms·
Disabled people tried to play by the rules. It cost them their federal benefits
- h2odragon 2y agoThe definition they use for a bank account counting as yours is "can you access it": so if you're able to sign checks for anyone else, including a business, that account balance counts towards the asset limit too.
- PartiallyTyped 2y agoThat sounds absurdly idiotic and almost vindictive.
- jabroni_salad 2y agoThis distinction and overlap also comes into play for the medicaid "asset spend down." If you share any financial assets with your parents, be sure to separate entirely 5 years before they apply for medicaid or you will need to either count it as gone or buy it out at FMV.
- LorenPechtel 2y agoDon't know why you're being downvoted. I can see why the rule exists, it's simpler to simply decree this than it is to sort out whether you're simply managing money that is not yours. Doesn't make it the right answer, though.
- therobots927 2y agoBecause this forum is full of libertarians lol. That’s why.
- snakeyjake 2y agoOne day a federal research grant will fund a project that determines the specific form of brain damage that leads to libertarianism.
- therobots927 2y agoI don’t think their attitude is indicative of some sort of brain damage. It’s likely that their opinions come from deep in the lizard brain and played a role in human survival at some point. It’s possible that libertarians have certain personality traits in common with conservatives like low openness and low conscientiousness. It also wouldn’t surprise me if they’re statistically more likely to have low empathy - they also have very “small” minds - they don’t think about the big picture. I don’t even necessarily think that these traits are hard wired, it’s just that they’ve fed into their own attitudes and in general it’s hard to move someone from low openness to high openness especially (unless you give them psychedelics). There’s also an entire propaganda machine in the US owned and operated by some very rich and powerful people that’s designed to feed into all of the personality / thinking styles I listed above to get these people to vote against their own self interests and the interests of others. Sad situation all around, but I’d be lying if I said I didn’t deeply resent them, even if they are brainwashed and operating from a place of ignorance and fear.
- thayne 2y agoIn many places in the US, it is hard to find a place to rent for less than $2000 dollars per month. That seems absurdly low to limit your total assets to. That also seems like a way to trap people in poverty, since saving money for something that might allow you to work, like education, a vehicle, assets to start a business, etc. would mean giving up your income.
- NikkiA 2y agoAnd I assume renting in the US these days means you'll need a 2xMonth bond in addition to your normal rent in advance, like here, meaning you need savings of 3xMonthly-rent to even consider moving, probably more unless you intend to move using a borrowed shopping trolly.
- Sirizarry 2y agoDepends on the place but plenty of properties I’ve seen are one month in advance. Arguably still rough but not the 3x in advance kind of rough
- hollerith 2y agoNot defending the $2000 rule, but there are charities that will give you move in costs if you are on SSI and bring them a lease agreement.
- iteria 2y agoWhich is an utter failure. The government has set the limit so low that people who take the assistance much rely on the grace of others or become homeless. The limit should be set to the federal poverty level. Having assets that amount to literal poverty wages is not wealth building or cheating the system and would make life possible. Setting it to take would be appalling as well, but at least defendable. I have no idea how anyone even came up with the 2K number. I assume the federal poverty rate on a monthly level, but people should be allowed to have savings.
- 2y ago
- NikkiA 2y agoAnd of course, the average 'end all benefits' type of person will shout 'these are the exceptions, it's the cheats that we want to stop', newsflash, these ARE the cheats the system claims are the problem, they're not the exception, the cruelty to otherwise normal people is the whole point
- therobots927 2y agoYep. I’m guessing discussion of politics is against forum rules but I think it’s clear to a lot of us that a significant percentage of US voters are very let’s say… Darwinian about how they think about things (even though, ironically, many of them don’t believe in evolution). Of course this worldview is counterproductive, America would be much better off in the long run if we had a more compassionate approach to everything. People want to charge kids for lunch at school, as if society as a whole wouldn’t be better off if kids were well fed when they’re trying to learn. It’s not just that their worldview is immoral, it’s deeply counterproductive and puts a lot of strain on the social fabric.
- zamadatix 2y agoI was curious what a significant percentage might be as it just feels odd at first glance that a large percentage of the US population would rather children go hungry if they can't pay for lunch at school. About the worst stat I could come up with was that 20% opposed extension of universal free breakfast and lunch to all students. Of course that 20% is largely in opposition to the universal part more than wanting the children unable to pay to go hungry. In all it's surprising there is any single digit percentage that would oppose this but it disagrees with what most would expect in terms of numbers to a significant percentage holding this view. Doubly so when the comparison provided is a ~35% viewpoint (percentage varies depending on how you frame and measure the question). Another interesting stat I found along the way was more children were receiving free or reduced lunch than not even prior to the pandemic.
- therobots927 2y agoThe percentage is high enough that it’s difficult to enact free lunch programs.
- excalibur 2y ago> Williams, who is disabled and doesn’t work, relied upon a little-known federal assistance program — Supplemental Security Income, or SSI, run by the Social Security Administration. What kind of circles does the author run in where SSI is obscure?
- lionsdan 2y agoThere are two forms of Social Security disability benefits, one paid from payroll taxes (SSDI) and one from general tax revenues (SSI, this one). I for one was not really aware of the distinction. https://www.usa.gov/social-security-disability https://www.usa.gov/social-security-disability https://blog.ssa.gov/understanding-social-security-disability-benefits https://blog.ssa.gov/understanding-social-security-disabilit...
- nytesky 2y agoFrom my families experience, SSI is very hard to qualify for; it’s for when you have not worked long enough to pay into and qualify for SSDI, which is more lenient. I can imagine it’s rare comparatively; especially if you don’t associate with people who have never really had a job.
- LorenPechtel 2y agoI don't think it's all that rare. It's all the people that grew up with medical issues that preclude work. It's just that until the internet such people tended to be pretty isolated from most of society.
- xboxnolifes 2y agoCrazy that the asset limit isn't tied to inflation, but the payments are.
- frumper 2y agoA lot of people are talking about the low asset limit, but a relatively new account type gets ignored by that limit. An ABLE account. It’s not perfect and asset limits are way too low, but this type of account greatly helps people with disabilities save/invest up to $100k without counting against the limit. It is restricted to specific uses, but it’s very broad and pretty much anything but alcohol and gambling can be spent on from it. https://www.ssa.gov/ssi/spotlights/spot-able.html https://www.ssa.gov/ssi/spotlights/spot-able.html
- Volundr 2y agoUnless I'm missing something, it appears only those who were disabled before the age of 26 qualify... That seems VERY limiting.