5 ms·
Valley gender gap a death spiral
- rcthompson 14y agoInteresting article, but submitting it with this as the title is misleading. The "death spiral" quote is from the text of the article, and is not used to describe the gender gap as a whole, but rather what happens when an individual startup fails to bring on any women in the first 15 to 20 employees (i.e. bringing one woman into an environment with 20 men is nigh impossible, and just gets harder as you hire more and more men because you can't hire any women).
- zerostar07 14y agoSteeped in video game culture and barraged by positive male tech industry role models, boys tend to dominate conversations around computing early on, leaving girls feeling shut out, said Yeung . this contradicts the evidence that social network use is mostly from girls
- jack-r-abbit 14y agoto be fair... using a social network site is not exactly conversations around computing.
- roopeshv 14y agoi stopped reading articles with "brogrammer" in them. it's overused to the point of absurdity right now.
- k-mcgrady 14y agoThat's just the way the press works. e.g. 'Pivot' has been a perfectly normal business term for a long time, then 1 tech company used it, suddenly dozens of companies were 'pivoting' and eventually people start avoiding articles using the term. It'll fade away soon (hopefully).
- mwd_ 14y agoThese articles typically throw the ratio of female to male employees out there as a statistic. How do we know that gender discrimination is the biggest factor in the gender gap? It's not hard to imagine that men and women on average would have different career preferences even without discrimination.
- FuzzyDunlop 14y agoThis is what crosses my mind quite often when gender is brought up here. The sentiment is that gender imbalance is a problem that needs to be fixed. And as you say, any other reason goes out of the window. I'm also of the opinion that there's a hint of arrogance in saying that men are the reason there are fewer women in the field. I generally take a feminist stance with these things, and am of the opinion that women's jobs being at the mercy of chauvinistic 'brogrammers' or some such bullshit is exactly that: bullshit. Given the desire and the determination, any woman interested in the field can pursue a career in it, and the field does not prevent that. > "For Yeung, having parents who were both engineers spared her the sense that computers weren't for girls." This conveys the real truth, hiding in the mound of rubbish that is the majority of that article. It's not Silicon Valley's fault; it's not the fault of technology, or programming; it's not the fault of the men working in those fields. It's society's fault for dictating what qualifies as 'girly', and what doesn't. Tech is not 'girly', therefore society fails to provide the same incentives to pursue those interests to young girls, that are available to young boys.
- Niten 14y ago> It's not Silicon Valley's fault; it's not the fault of technology, or programming; it's not the fault of the men working in those fields. It's society's fault for dictating what qualifies as 'girly', and what doesn't. Tech is not 'girly', therefore society fails to provide the same incentives to pursue those interests to young girls, that are available to young boys. I agree... there was another good comment along these lines in another thread on this topic earlier today: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4061749 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4061749 If the engineering gender gap is an issue we are going to address as a society, then we need to address it at its roots: childhood social pressures.
- bcardarella 14y agoWhile I agree with the point of the article I could help but think this writer didn't do too much research. Hewlett-Packard's CEO is Meg Whitman. I get the article was referring to the original entrepreneurs but another could could have been chosen.
- blantonl 14y agoTo be fair, Meg Whitman is not a technology person, she is a classic business executive. The article makes some fair points that are right on target. There is a significant disparity between the number of "hacker" types with regards to gender. Frankly, I think the article is saying we need more of this: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marissa_Mayer http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marissa_Mayer
- jack-r-abbit 14y agoThese articles rub me the wrong way. Unless their parents are engineers, girls also aren't likely to encounter coders in their own lives the same way they would, for example, a doctor or a teacher. "We don't really have that same kind of interaction with software engineers as we go about our daily lives," Goldfein said. Neither of my parents were engineers (uneducated truck/bus drivers actually) and I never interacted with engineers growing up. So... simply "being male" was my influence to be an engineer? I call bullshit.
- kylebrown 14y agoNo, not you being male. Other engineers being male ("role models in popular culture" not just day-to-day life).
- jack-r-abbit 14y agoI'm not sure what "role models in popular culture" I had in the 80's that steered me to be an engineer. It sure wasn't anybody on MTV. And assuming none of my school teachers were engineers, I didn't encounter my first (known to me) engineer until I got to college. But I started out just wanting to be a computer repairman because that looked like the future and the money would probably be good. It was after college that I realized my true passion was software and not hardware.
- loganfrederick 14y agoSo this story implies you found out about computers somehow? That source might be more male-centric. Some people are generally more predisposed to some fields than others anyway, so it's hard to extrapolate your anecdotal experience into a full counterargument against her story.
- jack-r-abbit 14y agoSome people are generally more predisposed to some fields than others anyway Agreed... perhaps this is another possible influence on the gender gap. But isn't a lot of this anecdotal? Edit: I found out about computers in school. I don't recall what grade.. somewhere in the 5th to 7th grade probably. I don't recall my middle school being male-centric but I suppose it could have been and I never noticed. I wanted to be a computer repairman after my sister told me about the nice guy that came to fix the copier in her office. He dressed nice. Kind of funny now that I'm where I am now. I don't like to dress up. :)
- vinayan3 14y agoI don't see much evidence of what the title says in the article. It just is based on anecdotal evidence. This is on par with a blog post by some random person. I'm surprised SFGate would publish this.
- kylebrown 14y agoThe Director of Engineering at Facebook is not just some random person.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]