4 ms·
The interesting submitted article refers to "and as-yet undeciphered writing," but there is considerable controversy about whether or not the Indus Valley scrip
by tokenadult 14y ago
The interesting submitted article refers to "and as-yet undeciphered writing," but there is considerable controversy about whether or not the Indus Valley script
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indus_script http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indus_script
is a writing system at all, rather than the kind of ornamentation from a pre-proto-writing stage known in several other sites of ancient civilizations. (As a reality check, we can remember that several regions of the world had elaborate empires and cities with extensive trade routes but without writing.)
Some of the controversy about this issue arises because of the extreme sensitivity of cultural heritage claims in south Asia in a region that spans a heavily militarized border. A good popular book about the nature and origin of writing systems in general, worldwide, is Visible Speech by John DeFrancis,
http://www.amazon.com/Visible-Speech-Diverse-Interactions-Comparisons/dp/0824812077 http://www.amazon.com/Visible-Speech-Diverse-Interactions-Co...
and the definitive compilation of international research on writing systems to the date of publication is The World's Writing Systems
http://www.amazon.com/Worlds-Writing-Systems-Peter-Daniels/dp/0195079930/ http://www.amazon.com/Worlds-Writing-Systems-Peter-Daniels/d...
edited by Peter T. Daniels and William Bright and published in 1996. I haven't concluded absolutely that the Indus Valley Script could not be a writing system, but there is no sure evidence that it is, and the earliest attested writing system in a nearby region is the Brahmi script
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Br%C4%81hm%C4%AB_script http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Br%C4%81hm%C4%AB_script
that is much more recent in time (a few centuries older than the common era, that is approximately 2,300 years old) and unquestionably based on the scripts of the ancient Near East.
- rd108 14y agoIs there a real controversy over whether the Harappan script is writing vs. "a kind of ornamentation"? Your comment smacks of condescension but I'm sure you can just provide citations. Your (wikipedia) article contains some arguments based on relative frequency of symbols, but is controverted by studies of modern pictographic languages with similar characteristic (e.g. Chinese.) http://www.sciencemag.org/content/324/5931/1165 http://www.sciencemag.org/content/324/5931/1165 You also mentioned the Brahmi script is "unquestionably based on the scripts of the ancient Near East". That is also news to me. Could you provide citations, please? The real controversial implication, IMHO, of studying ancient Indian languages is that Sanskrit (used over thousands of years and refined by rigid grammar rules by e.g. Panini 500 B.C.) may actually be the language from which Latin, and hence many European Romantic languages, developed. http://mutiny.wordpress.com/2007/02/09/sanskrit-mother-of-european-languages-says-prof-dean-brown/ http://mutiny.wordpress.com/2007/02/09/sanskrit-mother-of-eu... That's probably worth diving into, if you are genuinely curious. As the Welsh linguist Sir William Jones said, "The Sanskrit language, whatever be its antiquity, is of a wonderful structure; more perfect than the Greek, more copious than the Latin, and more exquisitely refined than either, yet bearing to both of them a stronger affinity, both in the roots of verbs and in the forms of grammar, than could possibly have been produced by accident; so strong, indeed, that no philologer could examine them all three, without believing them to have sprung from some common source, which, perhaps, no longer exists." [edit- link added and fluff redacted. :)]
- meepmorp 14y ago> You also mentioned the Brahmi script is "unquestionably based on the scripts of the ancient Near East". That is also news to me. Could you provide citations, please? Brahmi and Karoshthi (the two major origin scripts for the writing systems of the subcontinent) are generally accepted to be related to the Semitic writing systems. Source: an undergraduate class in writing systems several years ago; also, the relevant Wikipedia pages agree, giving Aramaic as the parent script.
- tokenadult 14y agoIs there a real controversy over whether the Harappan script is writing Yes. Again, this is a familiar issue to people who are familiar with linguistics, and one of the criticisms of the Rao et al. publication is that none of the authors are familiar with the methodology used in historical linguistics to solve comparable problems in other parts of the world. (I am able to read ancient Chinese and am intimately familiar with the history of the Chinese script, which is an illuminating example for comparing periods of early ornamentation, proto-writing, and full writing as that script developed with attested archeological finds.) I am also very familiar with the extent of the Indo-European languages and with the fact that many languages spoken in India (e.g., Tamil, a language spoken by many friends of mine) are not Indo-European. The links I already provided give much of the needed background information. But here are a few more links, for onlookers who are curious about this issue and may be interested in responses to the Rao et al. publication. http://www.safarmer.com/Refutation3.pdf http://www.safarmer.com/Refutation3.pdf http://www.safarmer.com/more.on.Rao.pdf http://www.safarmer.com/more.on.Rao.pdf http://horadecubitus.blogspot.com/2009/04/indus-what-did-rao-et-al-really-do.html http://horadecubitus.blogspot.com/2009/04/indus-what-did-rao... http://earningmyturns.blogspot.com/2009/04/falling-for-magic-formula.html http://earningmyturns.blogspot.com/2009/04/falling-for-magic... (The link immediately above is by a former president of the Society for Computational Linguistics.) http://www.mitpressjournals.org/doi/pdf/10.1162/coli_a_00011 http://www.mitpressjournals.org/doi/pdf/10.1162/coli_a_00011 (The review article linked above from the journal Computational Linguistics discussed the methodological issues involved.)
- naveensundar 14y ago
- sunwooz 14y agoWasn't there a mathematical study that concluded that the Indus script has the structure of a language? I found an article on it http://grimoires.wordpress.com/2009/07/20/grim-writing-the-indus-script-and-computer-science/ http://grimoires.wordpress.com/2009/07/20/grim-writing-the-i...
- pavanky 14y agoAh I didnt see your comment, but I added the TED talk which talks about this in the thread, up above. I hope this doesn't constitute spamming, but here is the link. http://www.ted.com/talks/rajesh_rao_computing_a_rosetta_stone_for_the_indus_script.html http://www.ted.com/talks/rajesh_rao_computing_a_rosetta_ston...
- einhverfr 14y ago"structure of a language" is a pretty vague claim. Arguably one could conclude that Roman Numerals have the structure of a language too, but I wouldn't conclude from such a claim that roman numerals encode spoken language in durable form. Rather they are communicative in function, but through an illustrative rather than spoken frame of reference (Roman Numerals illustrate positions on a tally stick).
- pavanky 14y agoWell, there is some controversy, not considerable. But I think that mostly stems from the fact that no one has been able to decipher it yet. But computer analysis and all was done recently to strongly suggest this is indeed a script rather than some kind of ornamentation. Please refer to the following TED talk by one of the scientists who worked on it. http://www.ted.com/talks/rajesh_rao_computing_a_rosetta_stone_for_the_indus_script.html http://www.ted.com/talks/rajesh_rao_computing_a_rosetta_ston...
- tmbsundar 14y agoSince these are all hypotheses, and no one has cracked the script yet for good, (at least where in all are in consent), I would suggest that these are looked from the Proto-Dravidian hypothesis as well. See the following links: http://www.hindu.com/mag/2007/02/04/stories/2007020400260500.htm http://www.hindu.com/mag/2007/02/04/stories/2007020400260500... The above is Iravadham Mahadevan's view. The following two are Asko Parpola's contributions: http://www.harappa.com/script/parpola0.html http://www.harappa.com/script/parpola0.html http://www.amazon.com/Deciphering-Indus-Script-Asko-Parpola/dp/0521430798 http://www.amazon.com/Deciphering-Indus-Script-Asko-Parpola/...
- einhverfr 14y agoPart of the problem is determining what we mean by writing. Keep in mind we don't see any long inscriptions of the sort we see in early Sanscrit or Hittite. Only a few areas are attested including stamp seals, pottery and the like. The Indus Valley script could have been, for example, a pictographic/ideographic labelling system without any real language-encoding function. But if I draw thee fish to indicate that you owe me three fish, is that writing? It's certainly encoded communications. I don't know that it is writing as we know it though.
- teyc 14y agoI wonder if it is possible to tell ornamentation from writing from the degree of entropy present. For instance, if it is easily compressed, then it is probably writing, as opposed to ornamentation - which will like be random.
- randallsquared 14y agoWhy would ornamentation be random? Actually, a lot of ornamentation (patterns on rugs, clothing, buildings, etc) one sees is more regular than writing.