3 ms·
TL;DR: They mine the Antarctic for ice, creating huge sinkholes, then fill the holes in with raw sewage, a gift for future generations. Environmentally friendly
by immibis 2y ago
TL;DR: They mine the Antarctic for ice, creating huge sinkholes, then fill the holes in with raw sewage, a gift for future generations. Environmentally friendly, right!
- icapybara 2y agoDo you have a better idea?
- michael9423 2y agodrying and burning.
- consumer451 2y agoThere are some smart folks making the decisions for the procedures down there. I wonder how that decision process went, to end up with burial. I would love to know the details.
- yencabulator 2y agoThe article briefly mentions this (search for budget), it's pretty much "we don't want to pay for that". https://www.nsf.gov/geo/opp/documents/SPSMP_Fed%20Reg%20Draft_NSF.pdf https://www.nsf.gov/geo/opp/documents/SPSMP_Fed%20Reg%20Draf...
- noprocrasted 2y agoThe alternative would be to collect and ship it back which would require tons of energy that will have to be in the form of fossil fuels given current technology. Said fossil fuels have a huge environmental footprint (greenhouse gas emissions and depletion of fossil fuel reserves) that is affecting us now. In contrast, the ice shelf is huge and still has a lot of capacity to contain sewage. It should remain frozen for the foreseeable future - if it melts (to the level where this sewage will become liquid) it means the global warming situation is so bad that there's likely no longer any humans around to actually witness this sudden deluge of sewage. As long as we manage to keep that ice shelf frozen, we're fine. If we somehow fail at it it's likely there wouldn't be anyone around to complain about the sewage anyway.
- unethical_ban 2y agoWait until you learn about landfills! Although considering the desire to survive on the Moon and Mars, one would think recycling sewage in more of a closed system would be worth funding.
- immibis 2y agoLandfills aren't usually in Antarctica. I thought we were supposed to be trying to keep Antarctica relatively pristine because it's Antarctica. Also, the sewage doesn't decompose in those temperatures, like it would in a normal landfill.
- tekla 2y agoWait until you learn where the penguins shit
- akira2501 2y agoIt's otherwise uninhabitable. Aside from that what do you think our ancestors did with their waste? People overestimate the impact of individuals on the planet. Which is a game corporations play so you underestimate the impact of their profits on the planet.
- immibis 2y agoThis would be valid if it was a small natural amount of sewage from a few humans, not tens of millions of gallons. Penguins shit somewhere, so the ecosystem probably won't mind if a few humans shit where a few penguins shit. But this is like noticing a few burger wrappers on the side of the road so you dump your commercial trash bin there every week.
- akira2501 2y agoHumans have been living in cities for thousands of years yet we've only very recently began treating our waste. Humans outside of cities have been using septic systems for centuries. "Tens of millions of gallons" of human waste sounds significant, but, it likely isn't. I also feel that equating the unavoidable byproduct of human scientific research in remote locations with road side burger wrappers is bordering on luddite hyperbole.