5 ms·
Zany ideas to slow polar melting are gathering momentum
- vm 2y agohttps://archive.ph/xK7tV https://archive.ph/xK7tV
- hinkley 2y agoI’ve seen some pretty vivid demos of how soot affects melt rate of snow. Anything dark fucks up the albedo. And the thing with soot is that it’s the sort of thing where if you could fix it, the benefits would be nearly immediate. All you need is a couple clean layers of snow on top of the pack and most of the absorption stops.
- arijun 2y agoIs polar ice very sooty?
- itishappy 2y agoI suspect it gets more and more so as the ice melts and particles trapped in the ice don't.
- fatihpense 2y agoInteresting argument, so you think the non-white particles of each layer might accumulate while layers of ice melt
- itishappy 2y agoI could also see them washing off with the meltwater, but I'd bet some stick around. I'm no expert, so I'd take my ideas with a grain of salt.
- hinkley 2y agoThere are pictures where people walked out on snowpack and scooped out a handful of snow, then they come back months later and there's an ice stalactite as tall as a man left behind.
- throwup238 2y agoIt's not very sooty in Antarctica because its further from human activity but Arctic ice can get pretty dirty after volcanic eruptions or wildfires. Greenland gets it especially bad from all the Canadian fires that are nearly annual now: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/energy-environment/wp/2017/06/26/wildfires-can-cause-glaciers-to-melt-from-over-a-thousand-miles-away-scientists-find/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/energy-environment/wp/20...
- FrustratedMonky 2y agoWhen the fire nation attacks it is.
- model-15-DAV 2y agoI have some hope for a technological solution to the climate change problem. However, I constantly struggle with the question, what if we are wrong? What if we will not be able to fix it fast enough? We are sitting on our hands and praying for a deus ex machina to save us from ecological collapse, when we should be actively striving for a sustainable society. So, in addition to being hopeful for technological innovation, we must advocate for widespread systemic change, so that we would not even need technology to fix the problem for us. This includes destroying the inherently unsustainable supply chain and in its place constructing a supply cycle. We need to abolish landfills, and require all (at least industrially) produced goods to have a clear recycling strategy. Sustainability is a problem that needs to be solved socially as well as technologically.
- irrational 2y agoThe things you are describing are not going to make a material difference. Ground all plane travel, permanently. Ground all car and truck transportation that is not electric, permanently. No electricity generation except by solar, wind, wave, nuclear, etc., permanently. Kill all cows and have a giant BBQ and then no more methane producing livestock are allowed, permanently.
- StephenSmith 2y agoAKA kill half the worlds population
- Workaccount2 2y agoI have a head sci-fi story of us creating a super powerful AI that solves almost all of humanity's and the Earths problems by curating a selection of 250,000 ideal humans, and then killing everyone else. A quarter million good people living in a near perfect world propped up by AI robots with essentially infinite resources. I'm almost positive I wouldn't make the cut, the top .003% has gotta be a higher bar than me to clear, hah. But still fun to think about.
- 2y ago
- ck2 2y agoWe are going to do absolutely nothing Makes for lots of articles and airtime, that's all Soon only multi-millionaires will be able to afford property insurance in large parts of Florida and California and eventually Nevada is going to have some amazing oceanview property. That's how it works, we do nothing.
- sneilan1 2y agoI agree with you even though this is cynical. This is the likely response to climate change. It seems that our societal inertia is too great. People will not change unless climate change forces them to adapt.
- AtlasBarfed 2y agoEven then, climate change is this can become a problem for the poors. The rich can just get better air conditioning and air processing. About the only blue black to any of the rich/ elite is war famine and general economic disruption from The four horsemen of the Apocalypse
- vpribish 2y agoCynical and ignorant is just the worst combination. We are doing a lot - all of California runs on solar for a few hours every day and no coal plants are being built. Nihilism is pathetic.
- ck2 2y agoWe haven't even stopped for decades now something as simple and well agreed toxic as leaded fuel. It is sprayed around every airport in the United States and the world, there is always "reasons". Lead molecular-mimics calcium in the body, there is no "undo" it is deadly and physically and mentally damaging. Now go read about bunker fuel use in cruise ship and cargo ships around the world and how insanely toxic that is to wildlife. Now go read about fracking burnoff for months just into the air, thousands of wells. We have zero political will to changes things. I am very old now and have seen climate change talk for nearly 50 years. Nothing is ever done. Climate Change is past the turning point, billions will suffer the consequences, just not the wealthy.
- marze 2y agoPutting particulate mitigation gear on all existing coal plants that aren’t so equipped would be a good start. No tech dev required for that.
- AlexandrB 2y agoThere's a strategy in politics of opting for the impossible futuristic solution that's "right around the corner" instead of doing boring (and sometimes unpopular) things today. It gives the illusion of progress without having to actually make the hard decisions. See also: Hyperloop vs. regular high speed rail.
- darby_nine 2y agoIt also allows the government to "encourage entrepreneurialism" or "stimulate the economy" by subsidizing private research (which, if successful, we would then turn around and sell to the globe—as if this would somehow be more attractive than ignoring the west and building another coal plant at lowest cost possible) I've said this again and again—the only rational step is to directly subsidize poorer countries to not build coal plants and, in fact, replace them with more expensive but less destructive generation (inlcluding, say, battery farms, nuclear power, hydro, etc, that can properly address off-hour usage).
- psychlops 2y agoHow are they not then incentivized to build even more coal plants than they need to get free investment?
- darby_nine 2y agoThey could, but presumably further subsidizes would stop. This only works by continually and voluntarily applying flattening pressure to a power dynamic (which some might even call justice), and only to some extent. This is, however, a problem far easier to manage and deal with than the collectively suicidal tendencies we're stuck with now. And of course the devil would be in the details, and it'd probably look messy and ugly. But I just cannot conceive of it being messier and uglier than the future we're staring down the barrel of. I think the biggest barrier to this is not any rational problem that might be individually addressed but America's embarrassment at likely losing hegemony in the event we collectively manage to survive this catastrophe without mass death and the four horsemen. Really, refusing to stop global warming is a path towards retaining hegemony by taking advantage of future chaos as we have of past chaos. Everyone knows we have massive farmlands and water sources, enough to support our own people probably many many times over, and others do not have this luxury.
- tgv 2y agoAll of these ideas involve depositing the heat elsewhere on the planet, or even keeping in the same spot. That's not going to be great. There's only one solution: stop the greenhouse effect at the origin.
- nine_k 2y agoReflecting heat back to space should also work. E.g. cover large areas with white (IR-reflective) layer. Or with clouds. It's pretty involved, and harder to pull off exactly as planned, but should work in a pinch, e.g. to stop a catastrophic runaway heating trend.
- immibis 2y agoThese idea kill two birds with one stone: they stop global warming, and solve the threat to fossil fuel companies from cheap solar energy.
- rezonant 2y agoOh fantastic! Any way we could maybe just solve the second problem to get it done faster? Those poor fossil fuels companies are really hurting-- honestly that should be our priority. We can't have oil execs going hungry. /s
- johnchristopher 2y ago> Reflecting heat back to space should also work. E.g. cover large areas with white (IR-reflective) layer. Or with clouds. Clouds are keeping heat in though. https://earthobservatory.nasa.gov/images/44250/clouds-and-global-warming https://earthobservatory.nasa.gov/images/44250/clouds-and-gl...
- nine_k 2y agoDepends on the material of the cloud. Fire up some volcanoes! https://www.usgs.gov/faqs/do-volcanoes-affect-weather https://www.usgs.gov/faqs/do-volcanoes-affect-weather
- ratboy666 2y agoThat much sea level rise? From New York: https://psmsl.org/data/obtaining/stations/12.php https://psmsl.org/data/obtaining/stations/12.php From Stockholm: https://psmsl.org/data/obtaining/stations/78.php https://psmsl.org/data/obtaining/stations/78.php Simple: New York is sinking slowly. Stockhold is rising. Especially since the effects are pretty much linear 1880 to present.