3 ms·
> Your competition is no longer non-software solutions. It's probably existing, but sub-optimal software. Which means if you're going to compete with it, your s
by Aurornis 2y ago
> Your competition is no longer non-software solutions. It's probably existing, but sub-optimal software. Which means if you're going to compete with it, your software needs to be significantly better.
This is the crux of this person’s argument, but it’s not a generally true statement.
If you are competing with existing software, then it’s true that you need to bring something new to the table: A new feature that people need, a lower price for core functionality, or a better experience. If you don’t have any differentiator, of course you’re going to fail.
However, you still need to find what that MVP is and ship that.
I think there is a real problem of people taking the old MVP advice too literally about shipping software when you’re still embarrassed by the quality. Recently there are numerous examples of companies shipping things that are so MVP that they’re either nearly unusable or missing actual key features that people need. The recent trend of AI hardware assistants is a prime example. The products are so MVP that they’re not even enjoyable to use and the promised killer features are missing. As a result, the reviews are terrible and people are noticing. Even if they can improve the product later, it’s going to be very difficult to recover from all of those initial negative impressions.
- karmakaze 2y agoYep, the view in the post is narrow and singular. It just happens to be the type of apps that show up on HN. I would call them lifestyle apps where "craft and taste" is what differentiates them.
- xboxnolifes 2y agoPeople overly focus on the M and completely forget about the V in MVP.