4 ms·
The castle drawbridge at the top is apt, because academics are expecting universities to still be working on a feudal/guild model (lifetime loyalty is rewarded,
by pjc50 2y ago
The castle drawbridge at the top is apt, because academics are expecting universities to still be working on a feudal/guild model (lifetime loyalty is rewarded, progression from apprentice to master) while universities have moved to the Uber model (short term contracts for interchangeable staff).
I don't really know how to advise people other than "please consider working in the private sector, research is an expensive hobby".
- jltsiren 2y agoThis was about a failure mode in the old "guild model". That your career may fail due to guild politics, regardless of performance. If universities truly move to the "Uber model", this particular issue will go away.
- delichon 2y agoIf career is replace by gigs, politics wouldn't go away, it would just shift to affecting your gigs.
- Simon_ORourke 2y agoNot only that, the CS stuff they teach now is woefully behind the times apart from what you get at a few high profile colleges. Kids coming straight out of college CS courses not knowing GitHub for instance. Then again some colleges seem to think training folks for the workforce to somehow demean their efforts.
- masklinn 2y ago> Kids coming straight out of college CS courses not knowing GitHub for instance. That’s… not really surprising? Why would a CS course teach github? Hell I’d be surprised if a CS course taught git, that’s more of a CE subject, and not an amazing one either.
- zarathustreal 2y agoColleges focus on teaching things that require study to learn, things that you won’t really understand without intentionally analyzing them. Algorithms and data structures are great examples. An individual is never going to invent A* on the spot without an education, for example. Learning how to use the tools of the trade, e.g. OS, IDE, version control, etc, is not something you need to spend $50k/yr to have a Ph. D. Teach you, it’s something you pick up on your own. A lot of younger adults these days seem to think that college entitles you to a well-paying job, possibly due to the messaging from previous generation(s), but that is not (and never has been) the case.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- thaumasiotes 2y ago> An individual is never going to invent A* on the spot without an education, for example. What? A* is a brute force solution. Here's a complete description of A*: A* is a breadth-first search in which we use weighted path length, rather than unweighted path length, to calculate tree depth. Tons of people will invent it on the spot. The algorithm is just "let's try everything, in order of desirability, until something works".
- zarathustreal 2y agoLook brother you’re not winning any points by implying that you’d be the guy to invent A* on the spot. Without formal education you’re almost certainly not even dealing with concepts like breadth-first search, trees, or nodes, so no, a ton of people will not be inventing it on the spot. Edit: most people don’t even think about recursion as a possibility until taught about it in a formal setting, and even then it’s typically a struggle to understand. Even using a queue, that’s a data structure that a person with a task to do isn’t likely to spend the time to invent on the spot.
- hnfong 2y agoI agree the vast majority of people aren't going to invent A* on the spot. But I don't understand your emphasis on "formal" education. I'm pretty sure a sufficiently smart high school kid interested in the subject could learn all these topics online in a couple months without enrolling in any college.
- meragrin_ 2y agoWhat particular value is knowing GitHub? Git maybe, but GitHub is just too specific.
- 0x445442 2y agoYeah, just spitballing here but it seems like they could make DAG version control systems a unit of study in an algorithms course.
- loudmax 2y agoYes, students should learn the craft, not the tool. The craft here is understanding how to use a version control system, particularly when working on a team. In a practical sense, this usually means learning to use `git`, but it could also be Mercurial or something, and it certainly doesn't need to be a proprietary front-end.
- zarzavat 2y agoIn a country with free university tuition, I agree. In a country with paid tuition, universities need to provide education that provides the fastest path to paying off student debt, otherwise they are doing their customers a disservice in life. Far too many programmers exit from university without the skills that industry needs. If universities are places for free learning that's okay, but if you're paying $$$ for such a degree and been saddled with a mountain of debt then I think you've been robbed.
- hnfong 2y agoOne could flip your argument on its head and argue that, in countries with free (or subsidized) university tuition, because taxpayers are paying for the tuition, universities should teach things that are demonstrably valuable to provide graduates with a fast path to becoming a productive ($) person in the workforce. If somebody wants to learn "useless" things, they can do so with their own money. (Not that I disagree with your general thesis though. I just think it applies to free uni tuitions as well...)
- probably_wrong 2y agoIf you think CS is bad just wait until you see how bad Software Engineering programs are. Fresh graduates cannot explain the halting problem, the Church–Turing thesis, the maximum flow problem... some can't even formally demonstrate that a function's precondition implies its post-conditions!
- la_fayette 2y agoFine, ask any software engineer employed in a sillicon valley startup or any fortune 500 company if they ever required to explain or use these concepts...
- probably_wrong 2y agoI don't think it's such a crazy idea to suggest that if someone wants to get a highly-paid job as a Software Engineer then perhaps they should get a Software Engineer degree from the Software Engineering department. Or put differently: ask any computer science professor employed at a University if they ever required to explain or use CI/CD, or ask Geoffrey Hinton how different his work on backpropagation algorithms would have been if he had had AWS.
- wakawaka28 2y agoThe point of teaching cool theory to undergrads is not to enable them to explain it. Professors study for PhDs to prepare to explain it. The point of teaching theory to undergrads is so that they are aware of the implications of the theories, and so they don't waste time on projects that are obviously doomed to fail.
- nsagent 2y agoI frequently recommend MIT's missing semester to students [1]. I agree it sucks they don't teach this material, though to be fair they also neglected it when I was in undergrad a quarter century ago. I remember learning it on my own because I wanted to become better. That autodidact proclivity has served me well over the years. [1]: https://missing.csail.mit.edu/ https://missing.csail.mit.edu/
- ghaff 2y agoYou could probably argue that there would be a benefit to a semester or two of basic training/bootcamp for theory-heavy engineering curricula (not just CS) especially for students who are going in essentially cold. Probably CS is a particularly extreme example in that there's no formal expectation that an incoming freshman has done any real programming. Though even in something like mechanical engineering it's not like students have worked on cars or been in a machine shop.
- kcplate 2y agoIt’s been that way forever. In CS most colleges have always been about 2 beats behind current industry.
- wakawaka28 2y agoAre you kidding? Practical training isn't exclusively the domain of "a few high profile colleges." In fact, the more high profile your college, the less likely it is that you'll get practical training. I refuse to believe that there are many schools teaching CS that don't even cover the basics like how to commit something to git. You also make it sound like Github (which is just a commercial Git hosting service) is advanced "CS stuff" that you can't grasp without having this knowledge handed to you at an elite school. Most professionals and students of CS literally learn most or all of it in their spare time.
- probably_wrong 2y agoI don't think the market for ecologists in the private sector is super hot right now. But even then, I know plenty of researchers who would rather earn half their salary than dealing with the private sector's BS: bad science practices, endless meetings, "Powerpoint or it didn't happen", zero freedom to experiment, having to constantly "dumb it down" to your manager's manager, draconian publication guidelines, "are you sure we can't patent it?", and the list goes on. Research is only a hobby if you don't care about the impact and quality of your work. I'm sure the scientists who drafted the 1982 Exxon Internal Report on Global Temperatures [1] got paid very well for their report to be buried for 30+ years, but I would rather take a lower salary and make sure the fruits of my work actually get out there. [1] https://xkcd.com/2500/ https://xkcd.com/2500/
- pjc50 2y ago> But even then, I know plenty of researchers who would rather earn half their salary than dealing with the private sector's BS: bad science practices, endless meetings, "Powerpoint or it didn't happen", zero freedom to experiment, having to constantly "dumb it down" to your manager's manager, draconian publication guidelines, "are you sure we can't patent it?", and the list goes on. Sure, but I suspect you could find similar complaints from a lot of academics (UK "REF", for example). The UK situation is pretty dire at the moment and is unlikely to improve without the shock of a respected university simply becoming insolvent.
- foobarian 2y agoI thought that what OP said described academic life pretty accurately as well! Except dealing with grants, PIs, deans, etc.
- xyzzy123 2y ago> I don't think the market for ecologists in the private sector is super hot right now. You might be surprised to know that there's a fairly big environmental consulting sector. It's serious stuff. Multi billion dollar construction projects can be derailed by the discovery of e.g. a particular kind of unique beetle. I don't know what it's like in the US, but I have met some people in the sector in Australia and they do real work, they're ok with it, they do it with integrity - nobody gets asked to "bury" things. Of course, they DO get asked by their customers what the absolutely cheapest possible way to (legally) solve their problems might be :)
- harimau777 2y agoUnfortunately there's lots of types of work that are only available in academics. E.g. functional programming and most CS research.
- dimask 2y agoTo be fair people in the private sector typically make more money at least and have better work-related perks. Academia advertises mostly 1. you research stuff you find interesting and 2. you will get job security some point after a couple of postdocs. Currently neither 1 nor 2 apply for the vast majority of academic work.
- ghaff 2y agoFrom a somewhat outside perspective, I used to think that being a tenured professor at one of a relative handful of top institutions would be a pretty nice gig overall with at least decent pay and benefits. Over time, I came to think I probably wouldn't have liked it a lot even given that very optimistic hypothetical situation.
- throw0101c 2y ago> Academia advertises mostly 1. you research stuff you find interesting and 2. you will get job security some point after a couple of postdocs. Also pensions. Often, if you start early, you can retire with a full pension at 55 or so.