3 ms·
I'm going to go on record and say that the Tragedy of George Lucas started in ROTJ. Watching it for the first time in a while a few years ago, the Gonk Torture
by toast0 2y ago
I'm going to go on record and say that the Tragedy of George Lucas started in ROTJ. Watching it for the first time in a while a few years ago, the Gonk Torture scene[1] was where my switch flipped. That scene is just a callout to the looped animatronics in the line at Star Tours --- does bad looped robotic torture add anything, or did Lucas put it in because nobody would tell him no. I think ROTJ is also where Lucas started becoming dependent on chroma key (although he had used it before). Some of the chrome keyed scenes are groundbreaking effects wise, and that's neat, but it takes away from immersion.
The prequel trilogy has so many scenes that feel sterile because the actors are clearly separated from the backdrop. It's hard to feel like the actors are in a desert wasteland when they don't even look warm.
[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4O0-dCLFadQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4O0-dCLFadQ
- stnmtn 2y agoI think this scene does add something, which is showing how scary this environment is to droids as R2 and C3pO are walking in. It shows it quickly, efficiently, without having to use dialogue on it. It takes ~15 seconds, and also has the fun side-effect of being a cute easter egg to anyone who went to star tours. I think it's a rare example of a good easter egg because it still communicates something important to the scene without just feeling like it's there for a nod or reference.
- optimalquiet 2y ago> and also has the fun side-effect of being a cute easter egg to anyone who went to star tours. I don't think that was an explicit callout to Star Tours -- which opened at Disneyland years after RotJ came out (1983 and 1987). If anything, the easter egg went the opposite direction!
- Modified3019 2y ago>The prequel trilogy has so many scenes that feel sterile because the actors are clearly separated from the backdrop. It's hard to feel like the actors are in a desert wasteland when they don't even look warm. Ah, that’s it! That perfectly encapsulates why the prequels felt so off.
- dehrmann 2y agoYou didn't even mention Ewoks. If people hadn't grown up with them, they'd get Jar Jar Binks-level hate.
- toast0 2y agoJarJar is the best part of the prequels. It's clear he's the phantom menace, and yet everybody wants to fight me about it. To be clear, that's the best part of a terrible film, so it's still not very good.