5 ms·
A good downvote is when a post/comment is abusive or pointless. A bad downvote is when the voter disagrees with the opinion expressed. At least 1568 days ago,
by tokenadult 14y ago
A good downvote is when a post/comment is abusive or pointless. A bad downvote is when the voter disagrees with the opinion expressed.
At least 1568 days ago, the site founder pg was of a different opinion. He wrote,
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=117171 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=117171
"I think it's ok to use the up and down arrows to express agreement. Obviously the uparrows aren't only for applauding politeness, so it seems reasonable that the downarrows aren't only for booing rudeness.
"It only becomes abuse when people resort to karma bombing: downvoting a lot of comments by one user without reading them in order to subtract maximum karma. Fortunately we now have several levels of software to protect against that."
My own analysis of the issue is that if I receive a downvote, I'm curious about why I received it. I understand that not everyone shares all of my opinions, but perhaps if one of my comments is downvoted, I can learn something about how to express my opinions so that they are allowed to stand, without people feeling they have to go out of their way to vote them down. Any time I have a comment with negative karma (which is a rare occurrence), I look back on what I said, and think about what I can learn from the other comments in the same thread and how I might express myself better the next time. I try to learn from the people who disagree with me as well as from the people who agree with me.
- sounds 14y agoThank you for quoting the comment more fully. I've seen it paraphrased too succinctly as "pg says downvotes can mean disagree." Although pg hasn't implemented a change to this effect, I believe he would agree that -- "people feeling they have to go out of their way to vote them down" -- implies a downvote should be more work than an upvote. I think a downvote should require a response to the parent comment that: 1. contains at least 15 English words, excluding quoted phrases 2. quotes at least min(25% of entire comment, 5 consecutive words) of the parent comment 3. meets current downvote requirements (karma and downvote bombing protections spring to mind immediately) For the sake of argument, such a "required downvote comment" could contribute almost nothing -- but it would still reduce downvotes. An example of a really bad downvote comment on this comment might be: > a change to this effect This is HN, not reddit. Um, did you read the article? I down voted you. The 15 English word requirement sort of requires some sort of explanation. Does anyone think this would help?
- makecheck 14y agoI think that's going in the right direction, but arbitrary rules on replies will always fail for some situation. For instance if someone wrongly states "There are five lights." my reply would probably only contain the correction "There are FOUR lights!"; anything beyond that would be artificial inflation.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- mquander 14y agoI think this is an actively bad idea. If I had to reply to a comment, explaining why the comment is bad, then the most likely scenario is that the writer replies, arguing with me, and I reply, and now the thread is full of a bunch of bullshit that nobody wants to read. Multiply this by ten per post. If the downvote reason was only visible to the writer, then I could go for that. But it's ridiculous to make a rule that drives people to have huge off-topic flamewars in the middle of a comments section.
- sounds 14y agoAgreed, and good suggestion. Make the downvote reason only visible to the writer, and do not allow the writer to reply to the downvote reason - the system already heavily favors upvotes over downvotes, so that writers can just shrug off the downvotes. The main thrust of my suggestion is to make downvoting even harder.
- almost 14y agoDon't feed the trolls! If a comment is bad enough for me to want to downvote it I certainly don't want to engage the author in conversation. In fact, by downvoting I hope to push the comment further down so there to let the better comments float up and to make it less likely it will start a stupid pointless argument thread, replying would do the oposite usually. Also, I think that, in general, quoting in comments tends to lead to lower quality comments. It's a lot easier to do a point by point nitpick than the write a proper response to the ideas contained in the parent post.
- morsch 14y agoEssentially, posts are ranked on two dimensions: agreement, the degree to which you agree with the posts arguments and conclusions -- and quality, the degree to which the post the post conforms to certain expectations in a well-mannered, good faith discussion. Any ranking or moderation involves one degree of subjective judgement: you have a post and you have a dimension along which to rank it (according to certain criteria), where do you put it? This is true even if the criteria are completely objective, e.g. if you asked people to moderate posts in terms of spelling or grammar, which are fairly objective, moderation would introduce a subjective quality (e.g. people don't recognize a typo, some will think a couple of grammar mistakes in a long post shouldn't lead to a down vote, others will disagree). Post quality has fairly objective criteria, but they are never really spelled out. Nevertheless, it's usually fairly easy to recognize trolls and flamebaits and overall bad quality posts, independent of your own position or even the existence of a position in a certain context. Agreement introduces another level of indirection, in a manner of speaking: not only does the act of assessing the criteria involve a subjective effort, the criteria themselves are completely subjective, ie. it completely depends on the moderator's own opinion in the context. Why elaborate on this? Well, in the first place I think it's intellectually interesting how the two dimensions differ in a fairly fundamental way. But there are practical consequences to this, as well. Simply adding up up/downvotes means we can't distinguish between a post that has not received any moderation and one that has received an large amount of moderation that has cancelled out itself. This seems all right for "quality" moderation: when good-faith moderators can't decide on where to put a comment on this scale, then it's probably not clear where applying the objective-but-not-spelled-out criteria leads to, and it's probably a post that's neither particularly trolly or insightful -- the system works! But when good-faith moderators hugely conflict on an "agreement" moderation, this means the moderators themselves are in conflict, and the post articulates this in a way that makes them agree or disagree, e.g. by identifying the central contested issue. And despite being a +300 & -300 post, it sits there at +/- 0: I don't think the system works very well here. I'm not sure why we're trying to moderate both dimensions on a single scale on HN. I guess it's an elegant system, because it compresses so much information and complex judgements down to just a single up- or a downvote per person. On a large scale, this should yield good results, right? Well, I don't buy it. In effect, every post is a mini-poll mixed with a quality moderation -- and this is what we use to, essentially, delete comments. Ideally, we'd have two moderation options: a post quality moderation that's summed up, used to hide trolls and flamebaits and not otherwise shown, and an agreement moderation that's not summed up but displayed for everyone to see. "Agreement" votes wouldn't affect karma, as people should neither be awarded for having a popular opinion nor be punished for voicing an unpopular one.