3 ms·
This article is painting with far too large a brush. Heroku is not The Cloud, it's just a little piece of it. When you use Heroku you are paying a premium for
by dasil003 14y ago
This article is painting with far too large a brush. Heroku is not The Cloud, it's just a little piece of it.
When you use Heroku you are paying a premium for the platform. You do this because it saves you sysadmin duties, and you pay a premium in terms of base cost as well as flexibility. Obviously it only makes sense if the platform suits your app.
If you want to manage your servers yourself you will save a ton of money and gain a ton of flexibility. But does this mean you should reject the cloud and order some servers and start shopping for colocation facilities right away? No, you still have dozens of competing choices for how to get your vanilla linux boxen up and running, some of them fall under the purview of "the cloud" and some of them don't. These choices become very interesting based on your specific requirements. Sure raw EC2 is going to charge more than buying your own server, but if you buy reserved instances and factor in the colocation costs it's actually not that much more, and you may have many other reasons to look at it. For instance maybe you push a lot of data to and from S3 and you want it to be fast, or maybe you want to easily put identical deployments in Europe, Asia and South America for your global customers.
Beyond that, the premise that the cloud is somehow a big pain in the ass and owning your own hardware does not really wash. They both can utilize chef/puppet equally well, and being able to programmatically commission hardware is a huge convenience, the learning curve notwithstanding.
I also don't like hosting substantial apps of any kind on Heroku for some of the reasons the OA touches on, but that is not an indictment of cloud hosting in general. This article jumps to conclusions far too hastily and then arrogantly proclaims their generality with the threadbarest of anecdotes.