4 ms·
> For those people there is no "spirit" or "true law". Actually, there is. Many judges take various interpretations of the 'spirit' into account. See eg http
by eru 2y ago
> For those people there is no "spirit" or "true law".
Actually, there is. Many judges take various interpretations of the 'spirit' into account. See eg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Originalism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Originalism for one example.
And if the courts use some 'spirit' guide them, companies and their lawyers better try and predict what that 'spirit' recommends.
> If they didn't write it down properly or the resulting compromise was a mess, that's on them, but a working legal system doesn't allow people to just blow off their written instructions and assume they know what was really meant.
Well, then by that definition the real life legal system of the US ain't working?
- mike_hearn 2y agoOriginalism is the opposite of that, no? Originalists are all about following what was actually written down, using an understanding of English as it was used at the time. It rejects modern re-interpretations of the law and avoids speculating about the 'spirit' of the constitution, even if that would be more convenient. The competing view is that of a 'living' body of law in which the meaning continually changes without the wording itself changing.
- eru 2y agoWell, either way: than the 'living body of law' theory is an example of such a 'spirit'.
- mike_hearn 2y agoIt is and you'll notice a lot of people really, really hate it. Trump just broke all fundraising records by miles, because a lot of people who previously didn't support him feel that New York has ignored the written letter of the law in favor of a tribalistic "spirit". There are similar society-rending controversies happening in Europe due to the activist lawmaking of the ECHR. These two perspectives aren't both equally valid: the courts are not allowed under any system of civics to simply do whatever the judge feels like. They are only given leeway to interpret the law when they have no other choice because the statutes are unclear. It's a last resort, and often the result will be people "getting away with it" because there's no law against what they did.