3 ms·
Do we need grounded sockets now that we have GFCIs?
by jrockway 14y ago
Do we need grounded sockets now that we have GFCIs?
- X-Istence 14y agoYes. We still want device manufacturers to ground their cases, and using a third wire that is most likely not mounted the wrong way round is preferable.
- marshray 14y agoI agree. It would be a bad idea to have a stack of metal equipment all plugged into floating outlets. You'd be likely to get all kinds of weird voltages between the metal cases. The electrocution hazard was just one way it was the bad old days. It also sucked for other kinds of signals, hi fi, radio, etc. I would not want to try to have a home office full of computer equipment that weren't sharing a common ground. Did you ever have one of those 17"+ CRT monitors? Recall how they would make the hair on your arm stand on end when you turned them off or on? Without a dedicated ground for those things, guess where all that charge is going to go? Into your computer, via the ground on the signal cable.
- keenerd 14y agoDo you absolutely 100% trust the GFCI breaker? They do require a small imbalance to trip, so something bad could happen in that brief time. Or maybe stopped working one day. But technically yes, ungrounded GFCI will still protect you. Doing it intentionally is a bit like not buckling up because you have 100% faith in your air bags. For the non electrical people: GFCI works by measuring the current in vs the current out. Normally these should be perfectly equal. But if you drop your hairdryer in the bathtub, maybe 10 amps comes in (through the plug), 9.9 amps goes out (through the plug) and 0.1 amps goes out (through the bathtub, killing you). GFCI notices that 10 != 9.9 and shuts down. The trick is detecting 0.01% differences and shutting it down in milliseconds, fast enough to save someone's life. GCFI is way more complicated than a ground wire, and you'd be a fool to not have a cheap, passive and redundant safety system.
- ars 14y agoActually, it's totally legal. If you have an outlet without a ground wire, you can use a three prong GFCI and put a sticker on it that says "No Equipment Ground" and it's totally legal and to code. You are over exaggerating how useful the ground is - a GFCI is far more effective, the ground pin hardly does anything at all.
- keenerd 14y agoWhile I never said it was not legal (though I may have implied as such considering seat belt laws), code does require properly grounded outlets in bathrooms and other high risk areas.
- jrockway 14y agoOr maybe stopped working one day. I believe this is why they are labeled "test monthly". This is a lot more frequently than I check that neutral is not accidentally wired to hot or that the ground wire actually goes to the ground and not some random piece of plumbing that was removed in a renovation. (I live in a building that was built in the 1860s, and plumbing and wiring are being redone all the time.)