3 ms·
For people who don't live in a Waymo market, it's easy to think that self-driving cars are vaporware, and perpetually 5 years off. For those that live in a Waym
by xnx 2y ago
For people who don't live in a Waymo market, it's easy to think that self-driving cars are vaporware, and perpetually 5 years off. For those that live in a Waymo market, self-driving cars are at once amazingly futuristic and mundane.
- lunarboy 2y agoAgreed. It's only been a decade as an adult, but riding a waymo was my first real wow moment for a technology. Not VR, not LLMs, etc. I would actually only ride waymos over human driven taxis if they were available in my current area
- vineyardmike 2y agoAnd incredibly, it’s not some buggy mess. They’re real, they work, and they provide utility. They’re not perfect, but it’s not some horrible battleground of robotic bumper cars and dead bicyclists.
- Lammy 2y agoThey work fine but are a privacy nightmare for occupants and the public alike: https://support.google.com/waymo/answer/9190819?hl=en https://support.google.com/waymo/answer/9190819?hl=en InB4 “akshully you have no right to privacy in public” — you should, and those laws predate ubiquitous cameras in every pocket, on every doorbell, and rolling down every street.
- jessriedel 2y agoI think this is a reasonable concern, but it any/much different than Uber or Lyft?
- Aurornis 2y agoWhat’s the privacy nightmare? That the cars have cameras? Do you also think it’s a privacy nightmare when you step into an elevator with cameras? Walk into a building with cameras? > InB4 “akshully you have no right to privacy in public” — you should, and those laws predate ubiquitous cameras in every pocket, on every doorbell, and rolling down every street. Surveillance cameras have been ubiquitous for a decade and the laws have been updated in many countries around that fact. Cameras in public spaces are not a new invention. If you’re trying to suggest that we should ban cameras in public spaces then you’re never going to be happy with reality.
- 93po 2y agoExcept for when a dozen of them all fail in the same intersection, and the endless videos of them nearly hitting pedestrians
- lovestoChatGPT 2y ago10 years ago HN was full of threads about self-driving cars. Waymo, Cruise, Tesla, Uber... 1000+ comments shouting about the end of trucking and mass layoffs. We must have UBI now! because of the power of this technology and its rapid growth that the next 5-10 years surely hold in store. Where exactly are we now? The greater-Phoenix metro?
- Loughla 2y agoIt really puts the AI threads in perspective. The same comments appear in those threads today. Interesting.
- abound 2y agoAnd also San Francisco and LA, if we're talking about Waymo. More generally, I think this is the kind of rollout you'd expect from a technology like self-driving cars: slow to start, and likely exponential beyond a certain point. The time from 1 to 10 cities may very well be longer than from 10 to 100 cities.
- ppeetteerr 2y agoShould still have UBI or at least some form of government training and placement. Just because it’s slower than overnight, doesn’t mean it won’t affect people’s livelihood.
- culopatin 2y agoPeople will do other things, like maintain them, pick them up when there is an error, clean them, etc. I’m still waiting for a car shape change.
- AlotOfReading 2y agoRobotaxi economics simply don't work out if there's a 1:1 shift from driving to maintenance. As for the shape, they're all going to converge to rounded bricks eventually.
- xnx 2y ago
- sefrost 2y agoI just visited San Francisco for a few days (first time!) and it was absolutely amazing seeing all of these cars driving around everywhere. I also thought the driverless car companies had stalled (bad pun); but that is obviously not the case. I reflected on why I thought that and I realized I had allowed news about the Tesla self driving technology to negatively affect my understanding of this whole market. I have since watched a bunch of Waymo videos online, they are so cool! The possibilities seem huge.
- martythemaniak 2y agoIs it possible you were similarly mistaken about FSD?
- llamaimperative 2y agoFSD vs Waymo is not even close.
- spiderice 2y agoTrue. FSD works anywhere while Waymo works in a few square miles.
- AlotOfReading 2y agoFSD is level 4 nowhere. The human is always responsible for driving.
- lopkeny12ko 2y agoTell me then, what Tesla do you own? When's the last time you used FSD? What version did you use? And if your answer is "I don't own a Tesla" why should anyone take you seriously?
- ra7 2y agoI own a Model 3 and have used FSD v12.3.x as recently as a month ago. I've also taken several Waymo rides in that time. I can confidently say it's not even in the same league as Waymo.
- verve_rat 2y ago> The future is already here — it's just not very evenly distributed.
- pclmulqdq 2y agoIt's distributed in the very few places where the future is very easy to build.
- signatoremo 2y agoWhen Waymo was only available in Chandler AZ it was often said here on HN that it needed to go to SF, with all of the foggy weather, and narrow and hilly streets, to prove its worth. I guess Waymo has passed that test and SF has became an “easy” place. What would be the next difficult place that will become easy someday?
- pclmulqdq 2y agoThey don't run the self-driving cars in the fog. Also, the streets aren't that narrow compared to most other major cities. It's certainly a step up from Arizona, though.
- minwcnt5 2y agoThey absolutely do run in the fog, I live in a particularly foggy part of the city and take them several times a week. And SF absolutely does have lots of narrow streets. There are a lot of neighborhoods where the roads are only wide enough for one direction of traffic at a time due to parked cars. Either you or the oncoming car needs to pull to the side in front of a driveway to pass. Waymo handles these situations expertly. Based on your other posts in here you seem to have some kind of axe to grind and are making stuff up. Go watch some Youtube videos.
- pclmulqdq 2y ago> And SF absolutely does have lots of narrow streets. There are a lot of neighborhoods where the roads are only wide enough for one direction of traffic at a time due to parked cars. Either you or the oncoming car needs to pull to the side in front of a driveway to pass. Waymo handles these situations expertly. That is not a narrow urban road, unless you have about 3 inches on either side of your car. Drive in Europe or NYC sometime. I have no axes to grind, but I find the optimism of "[X technology] works in [Y very easy condition], so it's going to explode any time now" somewhat tiresome and naive. I have been hearing it about self-driving cars for >10 years now (since the DARPA challenges). Plenty of technologies never leave the garden of that easy condition.
- pclmulqdq 2y agoAs someone who has lived in the Northeast US for most of my life (except for a stint in LA and SF), someone who has only lived in the two Waymo markets has no idea that they are playing the driving video game on the easiest mode possible. Almost no rain, it never snows, there's never any ice on the road, there are very few potholes, and the worst weather condition is some fog during which the Waymos can hide out in parking lots. At the same time, the pedestrians and other drivers are also relatively polite and concerned about their own survival. Also, respectfully, most people who live in CA have very little idea about the mechanics of how to drive a car - they never had to learn because of the lack of the aforementioned precipitation - so it's actually a lot easier for Waymo to get to the same level as you because you are all bad drivers (mechanically, not in terms of politeness or rule-following). In CA I frequently got asked whether I ever did amateur racing or go-karting as a child, and when I learned that this was about how I handled a car (at first I thought it was just an odd inquiry about a specific hobby), I politely informed them that I did not, but I learned to drive in an icy version of hell. I am hopeful, but it's going to be a long slog, and at the pace it took Waymos to become average-to-below-average drivers in SF, I assume it will be 10+ years before self-driving cars come to my area in a serious way.
- minwcnt5 2y agoAlmost no rain? Not sure what you're smoking, SF gets rain on 70+ days of the year, and it's concentrated in the winter so you have about three months where it's constantly raining. Sure, east coast cities get more rain in total but it's not binary. I also find SF has pretty poorly maintained roads with lots of potholes but YMMV.
- pclmulqdq 2y agoIn my admittedly limited and relatively dated experience driving in SF, the potholes are pretty shallow and you can usually drive over them safely. I imagine they have also gotten a lot worse since I left, as the city's management has only grown in incompetence. A quick Google search shows 50 inches of precipitation over 125 days in NYC, and 23 in SF in 71 days. That's less than half. The source (US NCEI) doesn't say how they measured, but I believe that's only rainfall. It also does appear that as of 6 months ago, Waymos can now operate in rain and fog, but still stay off the streets when it gets heavy.