8 ms·
Ever wonder why, in some buildings (mainly commercial properties), the plugs are installed so that the ground is at the top of the outlet? I asked an older ele
by zdw 14y ago
Ever wonder why, in some buildings (mainly commercial properties), the plugs are installed so that the ground is at the top of the outlet?
I asked an older electrician/installer about this once, and the reason he gave was that if a wire fell in between the gap between the plug and outlet it could short easily.
Having the ground on the top makes it so that if something does land in this way, it will be at an angle and more likely to fall off the shorting outlet.
Plugs in other countries, specifically european or british plugs aren't susceptible to this because they're designed not to expose hot wires during insertion.
- TazeTSchnitzel 14y agoBritish plugs[1] have a pretty clever design. There's 3 prongs arranged in a triangle, each of equal length, but they are rectangular prisms, not cuboids, so you can only plug it in one way up. The lower 2 "live" holes only open if there's a prong in the top earth hole. Because of this, double-insulated appliances still have a plastic prong on the plug. And yes, we have insulation on both "live" prongs. Plus, it's the only kind of plug that's both Grounded, Polarised, Fused and has Insulated Pins[2] [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BS_1363 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BS_1363 [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AC_power_plugs_and_sockets#Comparison_of_sockets http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AC_power_plugs_and_sockets#Comp...
- kalleboo 14y agoIt's also the only plug that'll wake the neighbors when you step on it going to the loo in the middle of the night.
- lmm 14y agoTrue, but you learn after the first time, and it's pretty non-lethal (I think? It doesn't seem sharp enough to do serious damage, but for something to hurt that much your body must think something's up). The real problem with British electrical standards is the nutty "ring main" system.
- dfc 14y agoWhat is the "ring main" system?
- DanBC2 14y agoIt's a circuit layout used mostly in the UK. Wikipedia has a nice explanation. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ring_circuit http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ring_circuit)
- ricardobeat 14y agoSo THAT's the reason for the damn fuses. Thanks!
- jdietrich 14y agoWe'll be laughing when copper hits $20,000 a ton - the ring main is very close to the most economical possible design.
- ricardobeat 14y agoThen we'll switch to copper clad steel/aluminum :)
- ars 14y agoThe ring main makes wifi much more difficult, and encircles the building with a strong (and varying) magnetic field causing problems for many devices. It induces current in all metal near it, which causes sensitive devices to fail. And it was only economical when you assumed a small number of high current devices. But these days when every outlet has something plugged into it the benefits are nill (since you have to have enough capacity for all the outlets, not just a small number of them).
- kika 14y agoAnd the only kind of plug the size of the aircraft carrier :-)
- jevinskie 14y agoExactly. Is there another design that shares the same features but in a smaller (more in line with US plugs) size?
- magic_haze 14y agoAfter an hour-long detour through Wikipedia's various power plugs articles (shocking how many of them there are), I have to ask this: historical reasons aside, isn't there any kind of consensus on which is the "best" plug/socket system (in purely objective terms)? The comparison table in [2] would have us believe BS1363 has the most features, but surely, there must have been more improvements in plug design since that huge lump was designed in the 1940s?
- DanBC2 14y agoIt's a huge lump, but it handles 240 v at 13 amp and does so without burning down houses or killing people who plug it in. I have no idea how many sockets are installed in UK houses and how many plugs are fitted to UK equipment but a new plug / socket design would have to be God-Tier to justify the cost of replacement. Also, I've seen people wiring plugs and it's sometimes scary, so anything that avoids the need for many people to botch a new plug onto their equipment is a good thing. And I guess this is where most improvement has happened - plugs that can be built quickly, cheaply and safely in Chinese factories for use in UK. You can change the fuse, but the plug is molded and you can't take it apart.
- magic_haze 14y agoyou misunderstand my intent: I was merely interested in finding out if there were any new ideas in plug design than what was indicated in the wiki article. The IEC 60906-1 design linked by ricardobeat above, for example, can handle 250V at 16A and is way smaller and more compatible with other european standards. It was designed in the mid 80s, taking advantage of the new injection molding processes popularized in the late 70s. I was wondering if there were any other designs that took advantage of the newer technologies since: I seem to recall a concept plug designed by an art student that was on HN a few years back that folded up rather neatly: does anyone know what happened to that?
- DanBC2 14y agoOh! That was posted here very recently. It's going into production with a few small changes. (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4033328 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4033328)
- DanBC 14y agoThe Earth prong is longer!! > Most of the time the floor is a pretty terrible conductor, so most of the time the hazard is small. The article doesn't mention the fact that a human standing on a wooden floor in rubber boots acts as a capacitor if s/he sticks a finger into a socket. The charge (or perhaps discharge?) can be fatal.
- sc00ter 14y ago" There's 3 prongs arranged in a triangle, each of equal length" No, the earth pin is noticeably longer. This serves two purposes - first, to ground the device being plugged in before it is live; second, to retract the mechanical barriers that are ordinarily across the entrance to the power pins, in order that the plug can be inserted, but stray fingers, paperclips, keys, or other conductive items cannot (without some effort and intent). As an aside - as a result of the mechanical barrier across the power pins, the plastic socket safety inserts that parenting stores sell are completely redundant, and arguably a scam.
- TazeTSchnitzel 14y agoOh, I notice the Earth pin is longer now that you mention it, you're right. Makes sense, considering it retracts the flaps.
- brudgers 14y agoIt's simultaneous pressure on the two live prongs which allows the plug to enter the receptacle - a two pronged plug still works. See: http://www.nfpa.org/itemDetail.asp?categoryID=1508&itemID=36117&URL=Safety%20Information/For%20consumers/Causes/Electrical/Tamper-resistant%20electrical%20receptacles&cookie_test=1 http://www.nfpa.org/itemDetail.asp?categoryID=1508&itemI...
- quarterto 14y agoWe're talking about UK plugs here. It's impossible to insert a plug without the ground pin entering first. I've had a few double-insulated AC adaptor where the dummy plastic ground pin has broken off (in the socket!) rendering the plug unusable in most sockets.
- njs12345 14y agoIf this happens and you don't want to replace the plug, you can get a pencil and put that in the ground hole to allow you to put the other two pins in.
- ricardobeat 14y agoThe new standard plug in Brazil[1] is both grounded, polarised and has insulated pins, plus it's obligatorily recessed and connects earth first. And you don't get hurt or break anything if you step on it :) [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IEC_60906-1 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IEC_60906-1
- swah 14y agoAnd we have our own exclusive design because no other was good enough. Also, so that using imported products its harder :)
- ricardobeat 14y agoIt's based on an international standard. The different plug diameter is an annoyance (why shave .5mm?), but it's still backwards-compatible with the spec, and the standard plugs will probably fit anyway. (Legally) imported products must conform to the local standards and pass inspection anyway :)
- swah 14y agoI'm also from Poa :)
- ricardobeat 14y agoHey, hit me up on LinkedIn/twitter. You should add some contact info to your HN profile :)
- gcb 14y agoLast time i checked the middle plug was optional, so no, not polarized. granted, the last time i looked at the paper was 2,5 years ago and there was still a lot of allowances for transition. And i'm certain the Nokia adapters sold via local phone operators only have two plugs.
- ricardobeat 14y ago
- swah 14y agoI hate those plugs because I can't find adapters to usethem in Brazil (while european/US ones can go directly into our (now replaced with 3-pin version) outlets: http://www.osetoreletrico.com.br/web/images/stories/Edicao59_dez2010/tomada_universal_1.gif http://www.osetoreletrico.com.br/web/images/stories/Edicao59...)
- ricardobeat 14y agoCut them up and replace the plug. You wouldn't want an adapter the size of a brick attached to your outlet anyway.
- swah 14y agoI just buy replacements from DealExtreme, because they're just USB hubs in the end... (but the Apple and Amazon versions have great build quality).
- Fizzadar 14y agoI love the British design; I've always found two pronged cables wobblier in the socket/not to mention buying-forgetting-rebuying many adapters of course
- speleding 14y agoThe UK plugs are over engineered for their task though. It's occasionally useful that you can use the same outlet that you use for your 4.5W iPhone to use for 6000W welding torch but IMHO the Euro plugs that are a third the size and a third the price are a better use of resources. When you imagine there are hundreds of millions of these plugs that bit of over-engineering really adds up. Really, when was the last time you plugged in anything above 2KW?
- dpitkin 14y agoIt looks like only the 30 Amp plus NEMA connectors require ground to be on top. It does appear technically "safer". http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NEMA_connector http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NEMA_connector
- sc00ter 14y agoNope - the diagram on that page shows every current rating of NEMA plug with an earth pin at the bottom. I call bullshit on the whole "earth pin position as a safety measure" debate anyway. Copper wiring of any substance is physically to rigid to move, even if completely free of other mechanical constraints, so isn't going to "drop onto the live pins" no matter what, even if the internal arrangement of a socket facilitated it. (They - don't they're insulated, shrouded, separated etc.)
- X-Istence 14y agoThis isn't for in the wall, but outside of it... For example you plug in a drill but it slowly works its way out, you are working with a screw driver against the wall and accidentally drop it, at this point the screw driver can come to rest on the live pins of the drill that is plugged partially into the wall. With the ground pins up the screw driver will pick a side and fall off...
- dubya 14y agoYou can try it yourself by dropping a bit of pencil lead across the prongs a slightly unplugged plug. You get a flash and it hops away, but I don't know that a piece of metal would break contact. I don't recall this ever even tripping a breaker, but be careful.
- X-Istence 14y agoIf you want a nice flash, take some low resistance half watt or even quarter watt resistors, place in power strip, plug power strip in ... Ah, so awesome.
- 14y ago
- dfc 14y agoThe upside-down / ground on top installation is a requirement in hospitals because of the danger of a scalpel falling between the plug and wall.
- rdl 14y agoThis was in the NEC a few versions ago, but removed. It was very common in hospitals, and then got used elsewhere, added to NEC, and then people complained (due to some plugs, like transformer wall warts, not working as well in this orientation). Of course the NEC isn't itself law, it's just an industry standard which is sometimes incorporated into local code (which is law).
- kevindication 14y agoKind of not law. Most local codes will have a few items that they consider special and worth mentioning, and then it will tell you to refer to the County code (assuming you were at the city level). Then the County code will add some things and refer you to the State code. The State code may add a few more and then ultimately tell you that the NFPA 70 (NEC) is law. Oh and by the way, did you want to know what the NFPA 70 actually says, since it's you know, law? Up until a few years ago that cost you a pretty penny. In recent times you can read it for free through their special online viewer.