5 ms·
One of the reasons I no longer ask questions on Physics stack exchange: 1. I asked "how powerful" such waves would have to be to be audible. 2. I directly lin
by ben_w 2y ago
One of the reasons I no longer ask questions on Physics stack exchange:
1. I asked "how powerful" such waves would have to be to be audible.
2. I directly linked to another question whose accepted answer said "these waves can wiggle your ear drum"
3. Got my question closed as a duplicate but the link was to different question that only asked "is it possible" (and accepted the answer "yes") without there being any answer to the "how powerful" part.
4. Got an answer which said "no, never".
Of course, I can now get an infinite supply of confusing contradictions from ChatGPT, and because I ask questions from a position of ignorant curiosity, I'm equally incapable of discerning which of the mutually incompatible responses I get is definitely incorrect regardless of if it comes from an LLM or a trained physicist.
- jvanderbot 2y agoThe moderation on SE is abysmal, but it's the best moderation around for such a large, universally accessible, user-submitted knowledge store.
- chownie 2y agoA better form of moderation exists in the form of whatever they were doing before, when you could ask a question and get an answer. At one point SE was my most used resource. As of now I haven't used SE at all for I think four years. Why would you, when so much of the site's content is outdated and the moderators enforce that situation?
- Filligree 2y agoThat's for sure. It's been... five, six years? Since last time I visited any of those sites and found relevant information. Not for lack of trying, but it's all outdated or incomplete.
- digging 2y agoI find that weird, so maybe we're in different spaces. SO often comes up with relevant answers to my queries, and I'll click them if they seem helpful. They aren't always available and when they are they aren't always useful, but I still end up on it at least once or twice a month.
- StableAlkyne 2y ago"Marked as a duplicate of an outdated post" has been a common complaint since the 2000s, the only "before" was when the site was brand new. I even checked to make sure I wasn't misremembering things - here's someone complaining about the same thing in 2011: https://old.reddit.com/r/programming/comments/cm02a/you_cant_parse_html_with_regular_expressions/c0tjya5/ https://old.reddit.com/r/programming/comments/cm02a/you_cant...
- chownie 2y agoThat doesn't really show that it was a common complaint given it accrued zero Reddit agreement points. The situation now is also much worse than it was, because answers could be two years out of date then and beyond a decade out of date now. I quit when I realised I would be scrolling by walls of jQuery answers for the foreseeable future if I kept using the site, not worth the waste of my time.
- j16sdiz 2y agoIn the old days, moderators were encouraged to update the old post. Many stopped to do that when people complain their post were edited by others, or the votes goes to wrong person because it was edited.
- j16sdiz 2y agoI was an moderator in very early days. Afaik, this is the policy since day one. It was aimed to be a FAQ site -- not just a question-answer site.. That's why it have community answer, allow the same poster answering his own question, encourage duping, allow other people to update/correct an existing answer,etc. Back in those days: 1) Moderator knew the subject. 2) Most questions are "frequent" enough to qualify as FAQ. 3) When duped, the old answer is less likely to be outdated (because the site was new)
- rachofsunshine 2y agoI worked this out once! Gravitational waves obey the inverse-square law much like most radiation does (and subject to some constraints about weird spatial geometry, but most of their propagation is going on in open flat-ish space, so we can ignore that). GW150914, the first gravitational wave observed, had an amplitude of about 4 times 10^-22 [1], i.e., differences changed by a factor of about that. Typical sound displaces the eardrum by on the order of half a micron or so [2], with the threshold of hearing at about 100 nm. The inner ear's shape is curved, but linear length is on the order of 10 mm [3] (it curves around so the total length is longer, but the gravitational wave would be transverse along its length). A 100 nm displacement on a 10 mm length is a relative change of (100 x 10^-9) / (10 x 10^-3) = 10^-7, that is, 4 times 10^-17 times larger than the gravitational wave detected. That gravitational wave was emitted at a distance of about 410 Mpc [1], and so we can solve: (d / 410 Mpc)^2 = 4 x 10^-17 d^2 = 4 x 10^-17 * (410 Mpc)^2 d = 2 parsec. Granted, this is at the limit of hearing for a very brief sound (the sound was only in the human audible range for about a tenth of a second). You'd need to be perhaps 10 times closer - about 20,000 AU - for it to be a loud sound under these assumptions. Of course you wouldn't be around to hear it for very long because you're 20,000 AU from one of the most energetic events in the cosmos, but hey, you'd hear a brief "click". Totally worth being vaporized. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_observation_of_gravitational_waves https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_observation_of_gravitati... [2] https://biology.stackexchange.com/questions/79963/how-far-does-eardrum-move https://biology.stackexchange.com/questions/79963/how-far-do... [3] https://www.verywellhealth.com/inner-ear-anatomy-5094399 https://www.verywellhealth.com/inner-ear-anatomy-5094399
- colanderman 2y ago4 times 10^-17 doesn't sound right... 2.5 times 10^14 I think?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- rachofsunshine 2y agoEDIT: the CALCULATIONS are right, but they're based on an incorrect assumption. As a poster further down this thread corrects me, while the energy of a GW obeys inverse-square, the amplitude is just inverse. I can't edit my original post, but the corrected calc is here. There is also a typo in my post where there's 10^-7 instead of 10^-5, but the calculations are done correctly. That corrected assumption gives: d_audible / d_actual = 4 x 10^-17 x 410 Mpc = about 500,000 km or about the distance to the Moon. ---- <rest of post deleted since it was based on an incorrect premise>
- spankalee 2y agoWhy would you ever consider asking an LLM a question like this though? They just make plausible-sounding things up, even if sometimes they're correct.
- bongodongobob 2y agoIf you tell it to use wolframalpha it could probably do some ballpark spherical cow physics.
- perrygeo 2y agoAmazing comment for two reasons: The idea of asking an LLM to generate code for a more rigorous but still high-level language is under-explored. This way you can experiment with AI - but at least have an intermediate code artifact that you can review and test before it gets published! Exposing the raw token stream is reckless. I had never heard of "spherical cow" science before but I love the imagery.
- Cyphase 2y agoYou really are one of today's lucky 10,000! For anyone else: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spherical_cow https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spherical_cow Meta reference: https://xkcd.com/1053/ https://xkcd.com/1053/
- burnished 2y agoBecause with an LLM you can walk away confused for only a fraction of the frustration and time of the old way.
- ben_w 2y agoWhy? Same reason I'd ask a student in the second year of a degree — knows more than I do. > They just make plausible-sounding things up, even if sometimes they're correct. This is indistinguishable from my experience described above.
- mort96 2y agoI think the point of the comparison with LLMs was to disparage StackExchange, I don't think they disagree with your view of LLMs
- hatthew 2y agoIt was closed as a duplicate because you asked 3 separate questions in your post, and the most prominent one (the title) was a clear duplicate of the original. I doubt it would have been closed if you had asked only "how powerful would the waves have to be?"
- mappu 2y agoIt's the same cognitive disconnect that comes up with Wikipedia and Debian too. People often add more facts to Wikipedia and complain when they get deleted. The misconception is that wikipedia is where facts go, whereas, Wikipedia is specifically trying to be a tertiary source, where all the facts can be traced back to primary sources and all the analysis can be traced back to secondary sources. People often complain that Debian testing gets almost no updates at all for six months every two years. The misconception is that it's a general rolling release distro, whereas, testing is specifically trying to become the next stable release and needs to have a freeze period. People often complain that stack exchange deletes their questions. The misconception is that it's a site to ask a question and get an answer, whereas, stack exchange is specifically trying to produce a 1:1 mapping between specific questions and answers. There's a saying in business that "you're not in the business you think you're in; you're in the business that your customers think you're in". If any of the above wanted to pivot, into what their less-informed users think they are, they'd do great at it, but their (sometimes inconvenient) organizational goals are what produces the high quality that made them all popular in the first place.
- guiambros 2y ago> ...produces the high quality that made them all popular in the first place Agree with everything you said in general, but you lost me at the very end in the context of this thread. Hard to equate Stack Exchange as a "high quality" destination. It was probably true in the first few years after inception, but years of tug war between "the business they think they're in" vs. "the business their users think they are" have made a terrible experience for said less-informed users. When given an alternative (e.g. LLMs, ironically probably trained on their own content, but without the snarkiness and self-righteousness of their mods), users seem to be voting with their clicks [1]. [1] https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/387278/has-stack-exchanges-traffic-decreased-since-chatgpt https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/387278/has-stack-ex...
- NoMoreNicksLeft 2y ago>I no longer ask questions on Physics stack exchange: Lately, on the science fiction stack exchange, they've been opening new questions that are duplicates, then closing my old questions/answers as the duplicate, so they can point farm their own newer ones that naturally get more traffic while making sure mine are dead and can't get more upvotes. When you check dates, mine are all timestamped years before theirs. I do remember the day Stack Exchange was announced (on reddit maybe), and I thought to myself how great it would be compared to Expert Sexchange... little did I know.
- worewood 2y agoSometimes I like to go on StackExchange, find questions I'm deeply knowledgeable in and where people are saying things like "it can't be done" and reply with a code example doing the thing.
- ben_w 2y agoI find it deeply pleasing when I witness this in any domain. It's like watching a magic trick :)
- darkwater 2y agoI really don't understand how people can answer questions they are not 101% sure of the answer, on a public site like that. I mean, informal chat with a colleague? Sure. But to go on SO and do it, it's unthinkable for me.
- ben_w 2y agoIf they're like me (I'm weird, but I think in this case it's likely), then they may be both confident and wrong at the same time. My brain doesn't seem to index many examples of my own wrongness, even though I have more than once thought "this would be a good mistake to remember", and the worst that I can remember is under an NDA (very confident and very wrong), so the only example I can give is a currently ongoing personal error: I've spent the last 5 years improving my German substantially, but the whole time I've been trying to estimate my current skill level and gotten the same answer, B1.
- meat_machine 2y agoWhile LLMs and people are questionable in their ability for one-shot answers to complex things, with an LLM you can at least ask questions ad-nauseum all the way down the tree, ask for sources, ask it to be self-critical, think step-by-step, etc. From there, you'll at least be armed with more knowledge to ask better questions, whether to an LLM or a person. I think it's also a good exercise in figuring out how to break complex things down into smaller parts, and figuring out what questions to ask -- especially important if it's something where you barely know where to start. Humans have a tendency to over-value their personal experience and cite their limited knowledge sets, beliefs, and intuitions as fact, and will probably tend to only show you the info that aligns with that. I guess I'm biased, but for the most part, I don't think the error rates between people and LLMs are significant enough for me to want to deal with the human ego, versus an AI with infinite patience. There are certainly equally intelligent and gracious people, but I don't think they hang out much on Stack Exchange (or much of the popular internet, really)
- chiggsy 2y agoGravitational waves would "wiggle" all of you the same way, so not sure how they would do something different for one part of your body, so you could hear it.