3 ms·
Interesting theory. What do you think of the following test? Someone starts a new online "meeting-place" (yeah, I know, it takes a lot of work for a new one to
by hollerith 14y ago
Interesting theory. What do you think of the following test? Someone starts a new online "meeting-place" (yeah, I know, it takes a lot of work for a new one to get traction) and take pains to ensure that all the moderators are Perceptives. Make it an explicit norm of the meeting-place to avoid judgemental comments. Then wait to see whether this new meeting-place degrades less quickly than average.
I tend to think that most people can learn not to express judgements if they want to become accepted by the others at the meeting-place (and that it is possible to exclude those who will not learn).
- nir 14y agoSeems to me the key is topics - it's easier to stay perceptive when discussing Python micro frameworks than the Middle East. When HN started featuring contentious topics like that, it brought out the judgmental side of people, and later influenced even technical threads. I remember first being impressed by HN when seeing a discussion on some PHP framework that didn't contain any of the inane "PHP sucks" slogans I've gotten used to on Proggit. That impressed me not because of my opinion on PHP, but because it was clear these people deal in building things - a language is a tool for them, not a fashion statement. As more recent PHP-related threads show, that's not the case anymore.