3 ms·
> but are ultimately not provable at all No, they are potentially falsifiable as we get better at scanning, identifying, intervening in brain activity. Just o
by Terr_ 2y ago
> but are ultimately not provable at all
No, they are potentially falsifiable as we get better at scanning, identifying, intervening in brain activity.
Just off the top of my head here, suppose we create a table puzzle problem that (in itself) doesn't require language to understand, like ones we make for certain animals. Have human subjects (silently) solve it. Afterwards, quiz the solvers about their internal monologue--or lack thereof--dividing them into two groups and noting the words used.
Now change to a second puzzle of similar style and same overall difficult. Stun/anesthetize the language-centers of subjects, to deny access to any of the monologue-words (validating this intervention will involve other research), and then test them on the second problem.
* If performance is constant for both groups, that suggests the monologue is illusory or at least not needed for this kind/scope of problem.
* If performance drops for both groups, that suggests the no-monologue people might just not be as aware of a linguistic process that's actually happening.
* If performance drops for monologue-subjects, that suggests it's a real and important difference in modes of logical thought.
* If some other combination happens, you have an mysterious and exciting new line of research.
- ElevenLathe 2y agoSure, there is stuff we can do to tease around the edges (similar problems crop up all the time in psychology and sociology) but we will always have to weaken the claim in order to do experiments relating to it.