4 ms·
> Even by today's loose definition of "AI" I'm having trouble making that connection. I guess the OCR is based on machine learning? It's long been noticed that
by ben_w 2y ago
> Even by today's loose definition of "AI" I'm having trouble making that connection. I guess the OCR is based on machine learning?
It's long been noticed that every time AI researchers figure out how to do a thing, it goes from "this is impossible SciFi nonsense" to "that's not real AI".
It's weird for me to actually encounter people doing this.
I remember when OCR was impossible, at any decent quality level, for AI. We used this to stop bots logging into forums, with a thing we called a "Completely Automated Public Turing test to tell Computers and Humans Apart" or CAPTCHA for short. It started off as text, then the text got increasingly distorted until most humans had trouble reading it, then it became house numbers, then it became "click all pictures of XYZ", before mostly disappearing into analytics seeing where you hovered your mouse cursor and which other websites you visited.
- MrRadar 2y agoYeah, take this XKCD for instance: https://xkcd.com/1425/ https://xkcd.com/1425/ That was published 10 years ago but now the second item is (nearly) as trivial to accomplish as the first.
- pavel_lishin 2y agoTo be fair, we've had multiple research teams and ten years :)
- jantissler 2y agoBut that's not the point I think. The point to me is: 10 years ago, this seemed nearly impossible to solve. "Weird, impossible sci-fi stuff". Now I have this exact feature in the Photos app of my iPhone. It not only finds my dog in the photos, but correctly determines its breed. It's amazing! And it works locally on my device, no servers involved. But I'm sure many people would argue that it is not "real AI", because it is "just XYZ". So as soon as we figure out how to do it, it's declared banal. Like LLMs. I'm baffled by the people who think it's "just" this or "just" that. That little word "just" buries years of research and several breakthroughs. Somehow, AI is always what AI can't do yet. It's always the next thing. The noise of goal posts being moved is sometimes deafening. And people don't even realize they're doing it.
- ben_w 2y agoMm. I don't normally like reaching for SciFi in these conversations, as there's always at least one of someone who mistakes a story for reality, and someone who misses the point and accuses the person giving the SciFi as an example of the same… …but there are two episodes of TNG Trek which come to mind: 1. Elementary, Dear Data: Dr. Pulaski asserts that Data, being a robot, is incapable of solving a mystery to which he does not already know the outcome. Data accepts Dr. Pulaski's challenge and invites her to join them on the holodeck. There, Geordi instructs the computer to create a unique Sherlock Holmes mystery, but accidentally specifies an adversary "who is capable of defeating Data" rather than "Sherlock" and thus shenanigans happen. 2. The Measure of a Man: Lawsuit over "is Data (a) a person with the right to refuse consent; or (b) a thing to be disassembled, studied, replicated, and used as a mechanical servant?" We've had ongoing arguments about #1 with AI for a long time, even though Chess and Go playing models beating the best human players should've ended this one. I think we're going to get a lot of real life cases like #2 even when they involve high-fidelity brain uploads.
- thunderbong 2y agoMobile version https://m.xkcd.com/1425/ https://m.xkcd.com/1425/
- tpoacher 2y agoTo paraphrase the Incredibles, "if everything is AI, then nothing is".
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- quectophoton 2y ago> It's long been noticed that every time AI researchers figure out how to do a thing, it goes from "this is impossible SciFi nonsense" to "that's not real AI". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AI_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AI_effect The most extreme example I can find of this, is Google Translate; I don't know of anybody who thinks of it as AI.
- ben_w 2y ago> The most extreme example I can find of this, is Google Translate; I don't know of anybody who thinks of it as AI. Huh. I'm (to my own surprise, given how old the feature is) still astounding people by demonstrating that it has augmented reality mode.
- sebazzz 2y agoIt is only because it already existed it isn't branded as AI.
- bsharper 2y agoIt's also how Google generally brands consumer-facing products, which is just Google + Noun. Most of their non-enterprise products tend to have unambiguous names (Google Search, Google Maps, Google Calendar, Google Translate).
- mannykannot 2y ago> Every time AI researchers figure out how to do a thing... If we are going to define AI as whatever AI researchers are working on (a definition having something of a bootstrap problem), then the only way the goalposts will not move is when they are not making progress.
- ben_w 2y agoI wonder which other professions exhibit the same effect? Artists certainly don't, as art remains art even when the artist themselves becomes lost to time. I suspect politicians may be, for every problem they do solve becomes the status quo… though also every problem they don't solve becomes their fault, so perhaps not. Civil engineers may be on the boundary, people forgetting that cities are built rather than natural when complaining about immigrants with phrases such as "we are full", yet remember well enough for politicians to score points with what they promise to get built.
- mannykannot 2y agoThat's a good question, though I think art is one of the few things that is in some sense a parallel. While masterpieces of the past remain masterpieces today, the scope of what is considered art has been expanding, and while perfectly good work is being done today in styles that would have been recognized as art in the past, it probably will not attract the attention it would have gained if it had been produced in the past. Perhaps the thing that makes AI different from other aspects of computing, in terms of how its progress is regarded, is that the term invites lofty expectations.
- yutrin 2y ago> It's long been noticed that every time AI researchers figure out how to do a thing, it goes from "this is impossible SciFi nonsense" to "that's not real AI". I struggle to see how anything we have today is “AI”. So you think we’ve done it? We’ve solved the “AI” problem. We can just stop working on it now? > It's weird for me to actually encounter people doing this. Rather than posturing, perhaps you could provide us with the definition of “AI” so we can all agree it’s here. > art remains art even when the artist themselves becomes lost to time. And if statements remain if statements. What’s your point? > I wonder which other professions exhibit the same effect? I disagree that there is any “effect” worth pondering, but here’s a biting quote that if written by a tech bro with unsubstantiated zeal for wasting planetary resources to engorge the wealth of unethical sociopaths it would have the word “goalposts” in it, and be the worse for it. “Fashion is a form of ugliness so intolerable that we have to alter it every six months.” -Oscar Wilde
- JohnTHaller 2y agoIf someone created the first Bayesian filter for classifying spam today, they would call it 'AI'.
- ben_w 2y agoP(what you did there | I see it) = P(I see it | what you did there) * P(what you did there) / P(I see it)
- bsharper 2y agoIt's funny when you look at this list: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_artificial_intelligence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_artificial_intelli... The original bump-and-turn Roomba is listed for 2002.
- theanonymousone 2y agoDo bot detectors check browsing history of a prospective bot? How?
- ben_w 2y agoAll those tracking cookies, or so I'm told.
- _heimdall 2y agoWell that's really just a side effect of capitalism and marketing. Some AI researchers are working through incremental discoveries needed to potentially have artificial intelligence. Companies come along and roll up each innovation into products and pitch them as some massive AI revolution. LLMs, at least as they are publicly understood, aren't AI any more than OCR is.