5 ms·
Jury finds Boeing stole technology from electric airplane startup Zunum
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- bookofjoe 2y agohttps://archive.ph/kShk8 https://archive.ph/kShk8
- tracker1 2y agoBoeing legal strategy is to maintain litigation for as long as humanly possible to block, wear down, bankrupt and otherwise break upstart competition. In this case it seems they outright stole as well.
- chuckadams 2y agoBoeing had best be careful with its illegal activities, lest it get fined up to a double-digit percentage of the profits it makes from them.
- codazoda 2y agoDid you forget a /s tag? I feel like the penalties are so small for the big companies that they just become small expense lines that need to be passed on to the consumers (airlines in this case).
- HyulianGrader 2y agoHe didn't forget it, he just didn't imagine it could be necessary for any reader but here we are.
- soulofmischief 2y agoNot everyone subscribes to this silly /s tag trend which defeats the intended purpose of sarcasm.
- yareal 2y agoRight? Sarcasm is so easy to detect using only text with no additional signifiers. Wait. Was that sarcastic? Who could say. /s is just the same as using a sarcastic vocal tone, eye roll, or hand gesture. Surely you aren't against those?
- mpalmer 2y ago/s is about as subtle as just saying "jk". It's a big old wink. Challenge yourselves to write something that 5-10% of people wouldn't spot as sarcasm. I'm sure you can manage that!
- soulofmischief 2y ago> Surely you aren't against those? Other people can do whatever they want, I'm not against anything. And I'm well familiar with Poe's law. Now try not being against how I like to communicate on the internet, or OP, and everyone's happy.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- SkyMarshal 2y agoDon't forget cutting corners in manufacturing and murdering whistle-blowers.
- LegitShady 2y agopretty sure this is every big company with a large war chest and a legal department.
- banish-m4 2y agoRecall that in 1997, Boeing was infected by the zombie mind-control fungus of McDonnell-Douglas management.
- WJW 2y agoIf a few people from a company you acquire can seemingly overthrow all principles and radically change the engineering culture, I'd offer that maybe the culture at Boeing wasn't all that strong in the first place. In any case, the acquisition of McDonnell-Douglas was 27 years ago. You can't keep blaming that forever.
- renegade-otter 2y agoThere is a link, however, because after the merger, most of the Boeing execs peaced out, letting the students of Jack Welch gut the company.
- buildsjets 2y agoMy personal observation is that a series of incompetent executives from GE caused a LOT more damage to Boeing than any damage incurred from ex-McDonnell-Douglass executives. Boeing and GE have always had an excessively cozy relationship, predating the McD merger. For two of the past three decades, the corporate leaders of Boeing were former GE managers: Stonecipher (eight years as CEO and COO), McNerney (ten years) and Calhoun as from 2020 to present. It is fair to say that, because of the number of former GE top managers at Boeing, it almost turned into a division of GE. Sores: https://www.managerism.org/images/Thinkpiece38-Boeing-Part2.pdf https://www.managerism.org/images/Thinkpiece38-Boeing-Part2....
- benoliver999 2y agoYou go in, fire replace or sideline anyone who isn't 100% profit motivated then the culture is gone, no? Time is then only going to make that worse
- cogman10 2y agoIf those few people are in management and making hiring/firing decisions then yes, they can completely wipe out a culture. But also, wiping out a culture does take some time. You wouldn't expect it to completely change overnight. The 787 Dreamliner was completed in 2003, it was the last plane developed with the old Boeing culture. The 737 max was the first plane developed post merger 13 years later.
- madaxe_again 2y agoWell, how else would they develop products? It’s not like they have any engineers, just a bunch of MBAs padding their resumés for the next gig.
- Cacti 2y agoI mean, they just put astronauts into orbit a minute ago. What’d you do today?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- thmsths 2y agoAnd they did it a year late and over budget (thankfully they had to absorb the loss), despite submitting a much higher bid than their competitor. So it may not be a total failure since they did eventually launch, but I would hardly call this a success.
- Cacti 2y agoEveryone going up and coming down is a success. Everything else is not a success. If you want to care about the schedule or cost, you’re welcome to.
- skellera 2y agoWhen we are paying for it, we should care about those things.
- nickff 2y agoJWST was about 15 years late and 20x over budget; would you apply a similar criteria, in which case that would probably be "a total failure"?
- thmsths 2y agoNo, because I don't have another data point to compare. In the case of Starliner, there was a competitor, with a lower bid, that launched 4 years prior and did not suffer a billion dollar loss to top it all.
- duxup 2y agoIt's interesting to me that Boeing did all that ... for a company with 35 employees tops and a company that never produced an airplane. Also I thought the feasibility of electric aircraft is largely known to be (at best) limited to small planes. I wonder if Boeing's lack of engineering talent at the top lead executives to over estimate the risks of this start up?
- datavirtue 2y agoEvery company is insecure and paranoid as hell about being disrupted.
- mannykannot 2y agoMy guess is that Boeing as a whole had very little interest in Zunum's work, but one plausible consequence of that might be increased pressure (real or perceived) on the the small number of people working on this niche concern to give the impression that they were achieving something, even if (or especially if) they themselves were not achieving much on their own. To be clear, my only basis for positing this is that it happens in other organizations - academic plagiarism, for example.
- incomingpain 2y ago[flagged]
- bilbo0s 2y agoSorry, but this is not a Trump issue. Not Bush. Not Obama. Not any of that political noise. These injuries are largely self inflicted. To the extent that there were political decisions, it was the one fatal decision to get high paying jobs in the south by moving the manufacture of unbelievably complex airliners to South Carolina. There was obviously some political pressure that made that happen, but that was long before the Trump/Obama era, and involved mostly state level politicians and senators. But even that required the collaboration of Boeing executives, who somehow believed that engineers were cogs in a wheel. And an industrial engineer in South Carolina, where they never built airliners and schools consistently rank in the bottom 10 states of the notoriously horrible US educational system; would somehow be just as good as an industrial engineer in Washington state, which has been the center of aviation for over a century, and has schools that consistently rank in the top 15 states in the US. Setting aside the hundred years of institutional knowledge base you are throwing away when you make hare-brained moves like that; it's not possible to just swap one engineer for another and get the same results. The executives of an aviation company like Boeing should have known that.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- w10-1 2y agoThe article doesn't say what proof was shown or what actions were actionable. This is a very, very common scenario where BigCo X invests in SmallCo X' to get a board seat and a peek at the technology. SmallCo X' wants not only money but industry validation and the chance to dance with a potential suitor. But when SmallCo X' has failed (after taking both public and private money), it has nothing left than to sell its technology and any assets, including legal judgments. Because it's no longer viable, it has no problem burning relations with an investor, potential buyer, and market leader. So the proof and what's actionable matters. If the law is ambiguous here, it would disincentivize any investments by any BigCo x, and make it harder for any SmallCo x to get money or keiretsu involvement. And when an industry (like aviation) has only a few big fish, any trouble at one can affect everyone, ruining careers and setting back progress for decades.
- more_corn 2y agoNote to idiots considering doing this sort of thing in the future. Just buy the company.
- nickff 2y agoThis may have been part of Boeing’s acquisition strategy; sue the company to put them in financial distress, and buy them at a discount (this is a fairly common strategy).
- black_13 2y ago[dead]
- siod 2y agoThe facts seem kind of light here. Sounds like Boeing essentially did further "due diligence" using privileged information, decided the whole concept wasn't viable and wasn't afraid to share that information. Given that buying companies is the only way such a calcified company can expand its product base, you'd expect them to be better at it...