3 ms·
Putin's Limited Tactical Nuclear Warfare Options
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- delichon 2y agoHow realistic is the assumption that NATO would launch reciprocal tactical nukes, or that the nukes would stay tactical?
- belter 2y agoThe story mentioned many times, and that Pentagon mentioned communicated to the Russians, is that the use of a tactical nuclear weapon would trigger a full and complete conventional response and the destruction of the Russian forces in Ukraine. It seems in 2022, the Pentagon believed so strongly, Russians were really close to use them, and the US called upon diplomatic pressures by India and China to dissuade Putin: https://youtu.be/gk7D_TliAuE?t=928 https://youtu.be/gk7D_TliAuE?t=928 But Russian forces would retire back behind Russia borders, and anyway it's a bit like saying, if you shoot your gun I will take my knife out... Best option would be Putin getting close to a window.
- 52345fgsddf 2y ago[flagged]
- belter 2y agoAll those scenarios are sadly quite possible, and it shows the madness and the recklessness of the Russian leadership in even entertaining such threats, and voicing them publicly. So many windows in Moscow...
- Someone 2y ago> Best option would be Putin getting close to a window. It isn’t guaranteed his successor would be less of a warmonger. Most likely, his successor would make a judgment call somewhere between the extremes of blaming the west for all of Russia’s problems and continuing the war, possibly more fervently, and of blaming Putin for all of Russia’s problems and getting out of Ukraine, with the judgment call not being on what’s best for the world, but on what’s best for his successor.
- breck 2y ago> It isn’t guaranteed his successor would be less of a warmonger. In fact, from what I heard from leaders in Kyiv on a journalism trip I took in 2022, the common thought is if something happened to Putin his successor would likely be a _larger warmonger_. The guy is _very_ smart, and easily figured out it would be unwise for his personal well being to surround himself with Peace and Western Loving capable lieutenants. Sad for the people of Ukraine, and hope sooner rather than later peace comes for their sake.
- 52345fgsddf 2y ago[flagged]
- 52345fgsddf 2y agoHow obvious nobody in the planet actually ever fought an actual nuclear war. The whole thing has no imagination whatsoever regarding tactical deployment. - They could send operatives with at least a dozen of nukes into Kiev. Then just announce the end of the war. You fill the details. - They could just bring some big nuke just as close to Ukrain as possible, anything like 50-80 megatons deployed on russian soil would just erase most of anything at the other side of the border. If you see lots of russian towns evacuated, this strategy should be obvious. and so on. The bigger nuclear game is all about NOT triggering any bomb never ever. An actual nuclear war would be a very different thing.
- jfengel 2y agoThey could announce the end of the war, but would instantly find themselves embroiled in a new one. NATO will not tolerate the use of nuclear weapons, even tactically. It's the reason that the organization exists. Russia has made nuclear threats at NATO nations and it's only the fact that they've never used a nuclear weapon that keeps Russia from being forcibly disarmed. It's hard to see a route whereby that does not escalate. But there is no chance that NATO will say, "Well, I guess you win Ukraine, congratulations".
- talldayo 2y agoThose inherently aren't tactical strikes, though. Threatening to nuke civilians if people don't agree with you is nuclear blackmail, and NATO would bring the guillotine down on Russia's head overnight. The entire point of the cold war was that imagination kills us, and the only point of keeping nuclear weapons is to ensure proportional retaliation if someone else nukes you. Russia knows this; they aren't stupid, and they full-well know that deploying nuclear weapons in any capacity gives the west a fully-justified casus belli on any preparatory strikes they want to make. Russia loves to talk a big game, but it should be plainly obvious that they could not possibly hope to survive a second-strike attack from NATO. It is all or nothing.